Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

[scandal of NOLS Excerpts from a Socialist Students…]

Socialist Organiser no. 333, 5 November 1987 · scan pp. 10–11 · about 2,449 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 10 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 10

scandal of NOLS Excerpts from a Socialist Students Labour Students lost numerical control of the National Union of Students Executive. However, there is still a majority of Labour Party members on the National Executive Committee.

The leadership of the National Organisation of Labour Students has alienated many good Labour Party and student union activists who will no longer toe the Party line and vote for official NOLS candidates. The NOLS candidates are branded as supporters of the Democratic Left (DL)

— a name synonymous with inactivity, and political and organisational duplicity.

The 1987 NOLS Conference was small; the membership of NOLS was down by 400 on the previous year. Part-time FE students, those on the dole, are still not allowed to join the organisation.

In NUS, NOLS are seen to have run out of ideas; they command little respect in the eyes of the membership. 1986-7 was widely regarded as the worst year for NUS campaigns since the turn of the decade. NOLS have been forced to electorally resurrect the Eurocommunists of the Communist Party to ensure a continued voting majority on NUS NEC.

NOLS appears to be heading for a semi-stable coalition with the CP. The CP has voted with the Democratic Left on every substantial issue on NUS Executive to date (November 1987).

The NOLS leadership - the DL with the Clause IV grouping at its ideological core — stands accused of destroying NOLS as a democratic, honest and political youth movement, and of stupefying the largest students' union in the non-Stalinist world - NUS - into a dead sleep.

For over a decade there have been accusations of Clause IV and then the DL rigging the annual conference of NOLS.

When SSiN was formed NOLS appeared to us to be an open organisation. Most of us had previously been YS activists and NOLS - at the time, — seemed like a haven. At the annual conference of NOLS there were_geThis is a letter from Glasgow University Labour Club -perhaps the contents explain allow auditors to examine the Dear Brian, photocopy the report and the letter I sent to the NEC concerning GULC's position. However I will tell you here the main events and the exact financial position with regards to the NOLS delegation entitlement would suffer).

000 EUWOCAT DIRE CEM then, constitutionally, we should not have been entitled to any delegates at NOIS conference 1986. As well as this our delegate registration was not paid and subsequently never has been. The cheque tor pooleo rare was tever cleared Decause pooleu rare caeques are not cashed and that the club is given its fares back in cash at the actual conon this yet.

With regards to last year's money (pooled fare), and €100 (delegate registration) were issued to NOLS. nuine debates; minorities were encouraged to speak; there were regional and national aggregates; everyone seemed to get the chance to participate in honest debates. It seemed to us that alignments inside NOLS were on the basis of politics. It was a far cry from the YS which we knew to be bureaucratic and stifled under the dead hand of Militant.

The proto-SSiN used to transfer votes to the Clause IV slate in NOLS elections. Not onlv were Clause IV at the time on the left of the Party, but their administration of NOLS appeared so much better than the Militant's administration of the YS._ Faced with a choice of voting for the Clause IV or voting Militant and letting them do to NOLS what they did to the YS — seal it up — we chose Clause IV.

By 1983 we had all changed our minds. The corruption in the NOLS office was so blatant that there was no choice.

Since then the situation has got worse. Now NOLS is declining and in all probability the DL do not have the support of most Labour Clubs. In a democratic conference they would lose control of the organisation.

While NOLS office has been spending its time carving up the opposition, Labour Clubs throughout the country have been left to go their w own way. There has been little or no - direction from the NC, little or no campaigning work, few forums for debate: NOLS has stagnated.

There is very little reason why anyone who is not involved in the prolonged power struggle in NOLS should want to be in the organisation. It is unattractive, it does little in its own right and even its control of NUS as been a charade, a mockery of the mass campaigning NUS they promised to create.

The record: 1983 This was the year when things changed for SSiN. Previously we had had a tew delegates carved out, but the 1983 conference at Manchester Poly was the start of the war of attrition. The opposition had more than 20delegates ruled out - Clause IV majority was only 19. And that figure of 20 excluded those delegates who were initially ruled out but reinstated after conference heard their case. Most spectacular were the cases of Manchester University Students' Union and Birmingham University.

Abdul Sheir and Phil Davidson were the two SSiN delegates from Birmingham which had four braden hornda hocke Ener a ded aa. Deim-ive Onde-l 1 HÉ597-Tasm÷1 Chinam d-fict mat contaak seen fiti Cit t aldokhous take club-e.g. Teresa Kelly.

antersece leis year Strathclyde University Labour Club was membership. This was despite the fact ahy-sen 1* membership caros plus an tou cheque up during questions to the Treasurer's been allowed its full delegate entitlement monev to NOES for two vears, As vor can imagine all hell broke loose and 1 was accused of "shitting all over the of most importance regardine SOS no right to be there, but the fact that I the letter to the !

You some me Yours in comradeship LINSDAY J. MUNRO Labour delegates. Dave Mason, a member of the NOLS Officers group was the 'reserve' delegate. Mason offered to send in the Club's membership cards to the Labour Party. He did so. Sheir and Davidson were subsequently ruled out because their cards were incorrectly filled in; Abdul's lacked an NUS card number — or so the NOLS office said.

In 1983 NOLS NC members were allowed to see the national files on clubs. Going through the cards revealed tht Abdul's card did indeed not have an NUS card number on it; neither did it have Abdul's signature on it. The card held by the NOLS office was a forgery. Dave Mason admitted throwing away Abdul's ge-s nuine card and replacing it with an incomplete forgery. Abdul was reinstated as a delegate and Mason went home.

Over half of the Manchester University delegation were SSiN supporters. The reserve delegates were Clause IV. The SSiN delegates were ruled out; again it was said that their cards were incomplete.

When challenged, John Mann (NOLS NUS officer) and John Dennis (Labour Party Student Organsier) both said they had themselves seen the cards, they were indeed incomplete and a photocopy would be forwarded in confirmation. The photocopy never arrived. NOLS office said that they had lost all the SSiN supporters' membership cards! A hastily convened meeting of NOLS NC reinstated the delegates — an admission by Clause IV that they had cheated.

Not curnricinalu the I PSO creden.

VIV DE VEGUVIR tials report took 2.5 conference sessions to get through. Conference was also suspended for a session because John Dennis, the LPSO refused to accept a conterence decision to give clubs appealing against his credentials ruling the right to reply to his defence.

This was the year when Clause IV did their sums wrong and failed to carve out enough of the opposition to give The conference was closed down in The combined opposition were passed against the NC and its Report recorded on a show of hands was 239. The election for the first block of officers of the NC was held. SSiN won two, Militant one and Clause IV total number of votes cast increased As John Dennis, the Returning Oftra votes come from.

John Dennis refused to allow his report to be questioned. SSiN demanded a roll-call vote to allow

Available

from Socialict in NOLS 54a Peckham Rye let London:

SE15 conference to see who was in the room. John Dennis refused to allov one. Militant declared that they knev how the ballot had been "rigged" -duplicate ballot forms had been give out to Clause IV loyalists.

John Dennis then insisted tha either his report be accepted or tha he would have to have the conferenc closed. Dennis said that Labour Par ty general secretary Jim Mortime had told him to say that. Militan pushed further and the conferenci was closed down. Chaos followed with both the Militant and DL shov ing people about - but not or anything like the scale that Clause IN later pretended./ -1984 was also the conference 1) New clubs mysteriously ap peared. By the time the list of af filiated clubs was released, eight club: were listed which had never been ac cepted into membership by the NC.

2) NC members were not allowed „sto see central files.

3) An attempt to change the stan ding orders was defeated - the changes would have abolished the roll call vote and given the chairper son the right to adjourn conference. 1985 This was a quiet conference. New standing orders were in effect, having been imposed by the Labour Party NEC after the "inquiry' into the 1984 conference. The Labour Party Student Officer's Credentials Repor was no longer taken. - A Credentials Committee had beer set up and so too had an Appeal committee. bou mese were Labour Praty bodies that few people knew anything about — let alone who was on them. T 1986= About 50 delegates were ruled out: more than enough to make the dif ference between the DL maintaining or losino control of the NC The NOLS machinery had harden. ed up and so too had the conference. The dispute over the accounts best illustrates this. SSiN supporter Dave Brennan was one of the NOLS Auditors — the other was a DL supDanny Nicol was leader of the Oxford University Labour Club delegation to the 1984 Conference at Hull. He sayst *It was a very tight situation: Militant and SSiN had about as many delegatescombined as the DE, and leading figures on the National Committee were worried about losing control of NOLS.

So certain members of my delegation decided to improve the DL's chances by some ballot-rigging. The ploy was to claim votes twice, pretending the second time to be another member of the delegation who hadn't managed to turn up. Two comrades tried this.

The first succeeded. The second was at a disadvantage by being a woman off striking appearance; she changed her clothes and wore her hair up, but Militant still managed to penetrate her disguise. One of their supporters, stationed outside the room where voting porter.

David had | not been allowed anywhere near the books, let alone given the chance to examine them or any other files equally relevant to his job. Presented only with a table of income and expenditure, David refused to sign these "accounts" as a true and accurate record.

The DL decided that this didn't matter; one student had signed and that was enough. SSiN appealed to conference CLE nuMIU! conference an Anditor had serious point to raise. He had been prevented from doing his job and wanted two minutes to explain why he had rejected the "accounts"

Disgustingly, conference voted against letting Dave speak. Conference thereby declared that they didn't care if NOLS had been robbed, or if there was a big cover-up going on. Conference was pro-DL, and •by fair means or foul it was going to stay that way. 1987 The 1987 conference was again shrouded in mystery. Most of the carving was kept well away from conference floor, with many Clubs ruled out well before that.

The carving was particularly vicious and small minded. North Staffs Poly, for example, asked for thirty more membership cards at the start of the year. They were sent them, but the thirty sent previously were cancelled at the same time! Then they had delegates ruled out of order because they had to replace one as he couldn't attend through pressure of work (Nottingham University). York University had delegates ruled out because the wrong club committee member signed some of the membership cards, despite the fact that this had happened previously on many occasions. Sussex University had their delegates ruled out, reinstated on appeal, and ruled out again 24 hours before the start of the conference - obviously with no time to appeal.

Perhaps the most vicious case was Newcastle Poly. NOLS rang to tell them they had to change the date of their selection meeting — which eventually the Poly agreed to do, and a date was set over the phone. NOLS then ruled them out of order because the Poly had changed the date without informing them!!

Although an appeal procedure was set up, several of the above were not told of it until they badgered the office, or found out from an outside source. In fact, some were informed there was no such right of appeal.

Al ine event, delore conterence had started, the Militant member of Standing Orders Committee and their NOLS NC member Julie Frost staged a sit-in protest, demanding information about Clubs registered, ruled out and so on. This lasted for hours but Militant backed down when it looked like the conference might be suspend-ed In anv event hu thie time the Democratic Left had guaranteed a smallish but sufficient majority. Their candidates beat the Militant/SSiN slate by an average of about 15-20 votes. So we still have the carving right-wing in control.

was taking place to guard against abuse, recognised her as someone who had voted before.

Of course, when this story broke in: the conference hall, it caused a hullaballoo. The comrade excused herself to the Party's student organiser, saying she acted under the misapprehension that she could cast a proxy vote on behalf of her absent friend. - Incidentally, her boyfriend was NOLS Treasurer. The last I heard of the couple they had ceased being active in the Labour Party and had got well-to-do jobs in banking and computing.

There was bad behaviour from Militant at the conference, too, but two wrongs don't make a right.

Danny Nichol is now a member of the Executive Committee ef the Campaign for Labour Party Democracy.

Scan page 11

astriall

----- pull-quotes -----

in NOLS pamphlet In the academic year of 1987

ŞŞİN stitch in time... The decline of

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 333

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →