1917 Why the crash happened
Socialist Organiser1987 1987-10-29Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 10 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 10
week, you would come out with until the last moment.
The bubble burst, in the end, rapid expansion. Companies which That's why people buy shares - because of worries about the US really can't afford new ventures can because they think the price will go trade deficit, US government policy borrow money on the strength of up. on the exchange rate of the dollar, their future profits. Capital is doublThere is a good reason to expect and the Gulf war. It could have been ed and trebled. But when credit Suare prices to go up in the long term. - lany one of a dozen other things. But TL becomes oversteerined, it can sudEL -If a company manes profito and -once the oubble burst lots of prople denly dwindle. and that usually n*t freinvests most ofithem rather than, wanted to sell as soon asthey could What sets off a stumple!! El paying them out in dividends, then its You can make just as much money by becomes: worth i-selline no LaT E100 and buving ter that outs back business iXbarsion in YEAR OF REVOLUTION From page 8 Sunday 22 October Meetings are held throughout Petrograd on the occasion of the Day of the Petrograd Soviet and pass resolutions calling for soviet power. The Petrograd Soviet appeals to the Petrograd garrison to defend the revolution under the leadership of the Military-Revolutionary Committee. A resolution of the Petrograd military garrison committee is published. declaring the garrison's support for the Military Revolutionary Commitee and the Petrograd Soviet.
The soldiers' section of the Central Exccutive Committee of Soviets passes a resolution opposing soviet power. A joint meeting of the Estonian regional soviet and the Revel Soviet sets up a MilitaryRevolutionary Committee. Bread rations in Moscow are cut from three-quarters to half a pound per coupon. The Bryansk Soviet Executive Committee bans the disbanding of any regiments in the town until after the election of a Constituent Assembly.
Soldiers in the 3rd Rifles division demonstrate on the Rumanian front with placards declaring "Down with war!" Demonstrations are held in Tsaritsyn and Zlatoust demanding "All power 1o the Monday 23 October The Petrograd Soviet passes resolutions approving the activities of the Military Revolutionary Committee and the Red Guards. The Obukhovsky regional soviet (Petrograd) bans the removal of weapons or missile shells from the local arsenal without the approvat of the Military Revolutionary Committee. The Centrat Committre of the Baltic Flec: orders the crew of the Arrora to ignore order to. wishdraw their cruiser from Petrograd.:
Kerensky and other minsters of the Provisional Government asset to disculi Tans against the Meaty Revolutionary Committee. Soldiers in the 85th, 86th, and 88th regiments on the Western front refuse to obey orders and demand an immediate end to the war. The Moscow Soviets Executive Committees, meeting together, demand immediate release of all imprisoned members of the Kaluga Soviet and restoration of the Soviet.
Workers and soldiers suppori a demonstration called by the Presnensky regional soviet (Moscow) under the slogan "Long live the power of workers and soldiers!" Workers and soldiers demonstrate in Shuya in support of a local textile workers' strike. The Tashkent tramway-workers' union resolves to take over the tramway network in the town. Tuesday 24 October By order of the Provisional Government the Petrograd newspapers Workers' Path' and 'Soldier' are shut down; the Military Revolutionary Committee overrules the order and printing is resumed under the protection of troops despatched by it. Junkers seize bridges across the River Neva in Petrograd, but by evening Red Guards have opened up the bridges agam Re rolutionary sailors and troops oespy telegraph offices in Petrograd and rive off attempts by Junkers to take em over. Telephone lines are restored to the Military-Revolutionary Committee after they are cut off by order of the Provisional Government. The Military Revolutionary Committee orders the arrest of all officers who refuse to obey its orders.
A joint meeting of the Central Excutive Committee of Soviets and the Executive Committee of the all-Russian peasant soviet opposes an armed uprising against the government. The commander of the Petrograd military district orders all troops to remain confined to barracks. and declares any soldier appearing on the street with his weapon to be guilty of armed mutiny. A meeting of the Pre-Parliament declares its opposition to an armed uprising.
A Military-Revolutionary Committee is set up in Yurev. Soldiers in Smolensk take over the local arsenal and transport away all its weapons. Soldiers in Vinnitsa demonstrate in opposition to orders 1o leave the town and resolve to disobey the order. The Revel Military Revolutionary Committee orders the takeover of local elephone exchanges, post offices. elegraph agencies and railways. Martial law is imposed on Kazan after clashes between revolutionary and counterrevolutionary troops.
Thu Martin Thomas starts a series of articles on the Great Crash Why does capitalism need the Stock Exchange?
The Stock Exchange is usetul f capıtalısm because it creates capı out of scattered sums of money.!
Take 200 people who each ha savings of £5,000. None of them i dividually is a capitalist. £5,000 wor buy a factory and machinery and p wages.
But if you can bring the 200 sur of £5,000 each together, you have million. And that is capital: enou! to launch a factory and hire workforce.
The stock market works a sort magic for capitalism. A compai which sells 200 shares of €5,000 ea comes away with E1 million cash spend on bulding, equipment, ai labour costs. Scattered cash transformed into capital. And weal is apparently doubled. The 21 shareholders still have £5,000 eac only in the form of share certificat rather than cash.
The stark marker carsalso daut capita _ a tailiomairer ouys ? million worth ; or shares in a co pany, then the single capita tot. million. Turns™ hto twoirT millionaire has f1 milla. In stard on which he will get dividends. T company has £l million in cash — the buildings, equipment, and labo it buys with the cash, from which will get profits.
So the stock market mak capitalism more elastic. Shar dealing in the City does not dive resources from productive inves ment; on the contrary it increases tl resources available for productive i vestment.
If capitalism makes sense, then ti stock market makes sense. If tl stock market is sick and crazy, it because capitalism is sick and craz A share is a piece of paper whic gives its owner a right to part of th profits in a company. That part ‹ the profits is called the shareholder dividend.
As profits go up and down, dividends go up and down and Logically, share prices go up an down But there is more to it than tha Nobody buys shares just for th dividends. If you had £100 worth shares in Britain in the last year, yo would only get about E2.50 dividends.
But if you bought f100 worth c shares a year ago, and sold them ju betore share prices collapsed la: about £150 — a tidy gain indeed Ananitar orows mold. And, correspondingly, a share in it becomes worth more. If the company is taken over, the buyer will pay more for shares.
So share prices can be expected to rise in line with the wealth of companies. When people make money from share-dealing, in the last analysis that money comes from the labour of the workers employed by the company, the labour which builds up the wealth of the company.
But the 50% gain on shares does not mean that British companies have made 50% profits over the last year. In the short or medium term, share prices can move way ahead of any stable relation to profits, or slump far behind it. As long as you think you can sell a share for £110 next week, it makes sense to pay f100 for it this week; as long as you think it will be at E90 next week, it makes sense to sell it at £100 this week. You need not worry about the long term.
Speculation — 'the rape of the greedy by the very greedy* - pushes shares even higher when they are going up, and even lower when they are going down.
Why did share crash?
Everyone knew that share prices had risen far above any long-term relation to profits. Everyone knew that they would go down some day. But everyone wanted to stay in the game 1 490 as you can by buying now at E100 and selling later at £110.
All the newspapers' City pages advise investors to hold on and wait. So why doesn't everyone do just that, and thus stop the slump?
One reason is that it makes sense to sell even at a low price just as long as you think prices will fall further. The other is that lots of shareholders have to sell whether they like it or not. They borrowed cash to buy shares in the first place, they need cash to pay their debts, and they need it now.
How does a stock market crash lead a slump in output, and income?
Because capitalism is an unplanned system, when it expands it tends to over-expand. Each producer strains to catch a bigger share of the expanding market and to be first with new products and methods. Businesses producing machinery and equipment gear up to meet the resulting demand., Sooner or later production begins Eo outrun consumption. Companies cut back on new investment. Demand for machinery and equipment slumps. Businesses in that sector lay off workers or even go bust. That, in turn, reduces consumer demand further. The economy spirals down into a slump.
The credit system - of which the stock market is basically part — helps When the stock markei one direct way! -hipanies become much less able to raise money for new ventures by issuing new shares.
The indirect effects, however, are more important. Selling shares is only one way for companies to raise cash. Another way is to borrow from banks. Or they can sell bondspieces of paper on which they promise to pay interest rather than dividends.
It is easier to raise large sums of money quickly by borrowing or selling bonds than by selling shares. It is also more risky. If a company sells El million worth of shares, then that fl million is the company's, safe and sound. If the company can't pay dividends and the share price falls, that does not subtract a penny from the company's £l million. It is just the shareholders' bad luck.
If a company borrows El million from a bank, or sells El million worth of bonds, then it will have to repay that El million at some fixed date. It will also have to make fixed interest payments at dates tixed in advance. If the venture for which it borrowed the El million fails, it is in trouble.
Because of this, companies are restricted in how much they can raise in loans and bond sales. They need to have share capital to back up their borrowing and convince lenders that their money is safe.
Now that billions have been wiped off companies' share capital, billions have also been wiped off the amount they can raise in loans and bond calec Credit is tighter, so investment fall Worse: when credit hecamed tight, and people start demanding cash on the nail, dozens of risky ventures collapse - ranging from those which were bold but sound enterprises in the days of easy credit to downright swindles and embezzlement. The bigger and brasher the previous boom, the more such risky ventures there have been, and the bigger the collapse.
Thus the stock market crash can lead to a slump in real, material business investment. It can also lead to a slump in consumer demand. People who last week had £10,000 worth of shares now have only €8,000 or less. They are £2,000 worse off. So they spend less; and the stock market crash feeds into a slump in demand and oulput by another route.
----- pull-quotes -----
background and prospects of 198
Why do share prices up and down?