Materialism and miracles
Socialist Organiser1987 1987-10-29Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 9 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 9
Science and religion have often been considered antagonists (though many scientists would dispute this). Historically, this has been because science has limited the claims of religion by providing materialist explanations for supposed miraculous occurrences.
As Marxist scientist, JBS Haldane once said:
"Religion is still parasitic in the interstices (gaps) of our knowledge which have not yet been filled. Like bed-bugs in the cracks of walls and furniture, miracles lurk in the lacunae of science". This has given rise to the idea of the "god of the gaps"
These gaps may have been reduced a tiny bit by the discovery (and patenting) of a simple method for making paintings and statues weep. A Californian physicist, Shawn Carlson, was "inspired" by the reluctance of the Greek Orthodox Church of St. Nicholas in Chicago to allow scientists to examine a picture of the Virgin Mary that began weeping continuously.
Carlson uses salt crystals for his rears, dmeonstrating his "miracle" to the Committee for the Scientific Examintion of Religion with the aid of a reproduction Mona Lisa.
Carlson will not reveal his technique as he plans to market weeping icons as a novelty (he has suggested a Tammy Faye Bakker doll with running mascara). However, he claims the method is simple enough to have been used for centuries of miracles.
The response of some religious people, including many scientists, is to accept that reality obeys scientific laws but that the laws themselves are defined by a god.
One fashionable "Theory" is that ine universe is ruled by some "anthropic principle. This holds that conscious life has only been able to evolve because the fundamental physical constants (the speed of light, the values of the gravitational and other forces etc) have the values that they have. It is then further alleged that they have these values because a god made them so.
If true, this still leaves unanswered ine questions of the nature of such a god and of its intentions benevolent, malevolent or neutral. When asked to speculate on the mind of God as evidenced by "His" creation, Huxley is supposed to have replied that God must have an inordinate fondness for beetles, having created more species of them than any other living thing.
Another fashionable direction for some theoretical physicists has been to draw parallels between the nature of reality as revealed by relativity and quantum theories and certain Eastern philosophies. Links have been suggested between the Eight-fold Way of Tao and the eight types of fundamental particle while Buddhism and Hinduism have been claimed as the forerunners of the "New Physics". There is a preoccupation with number (the two classes of particle, the three or four fundamental forces, the six types of quark etc) which seems to hark back to an ancient mystical fascination with number (the Christian trinity, the pentagram, the six pointed Star of David, Plato's religion of perfect shapes, etc).
Other physicists have shown a distressing willingness to believe in paranormal forces, including the ludicrous spoon-benders. In one well-known case, spoon-bending children were studied in the laborator, Claiming to be unable to do it while being watched, they were left alone and, Lo and behold. the spoons bent!
his cons inced end aminent physicisn but, in a repeat performance, hidden cameras revealed the children to be bending the spoons in the normal manner.
Yet other eminent physicists believe there is something unique about consciousness, particularly human, that places it outside of the realm of physical laws and allows it to modify them. One recently wrote of his theory that, even though radioactive particles break down at random, it is possible for human thought to affect when a particular particle breaks down.
But how can this be? Radioactive decay involves the weak and strong forces whereas thought involves the electo-magnetic force - and not very much of it. The sort of energies needed to artificially break down a particle are only found in massive particle accelerators (such as CERN in Switzerland). If the microscopic quantities of energy in the human brain were to affect radioactive decay, then quantum theory, one of the best tested scientific theories ever. would have to be completely wrong.
suppose this illustrates the marvellous ability of the human mind Believe all soris of pines thing before breakla supper Marxism, even thoug IST PUMPETE Largerst faise consciousn Socialist Organiser no
Scan page 10
Behind the news Behind the news (