Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Medium without message

Socialist Organiser no. 332, 29 October 1987 · scan p. 9 · about 803 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 9 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 9

Belinda

Jacket"

Weaver

"Full Metal Stanley Kubrick has masses of movie technique, but he hasn't got anything to say. His latest film, 'Full Metal Jacket', is just a lengthy rendering of the old saying 'Life's a bitch, and then you , set in Vietnam to give "meaning' to the despair and nihilism.

In this world, everything is taintedThe Marines have volunteered to fight for idealistic reasons, but that gets battered out of them at training camp. They're trained to kill, nothing more. The Marine, like the Mountie, must get his man.

Vietnam just offers disillusionment. The South Vietnamese don't seem to want the US there; they're not grateful. Comrades in arms get killed. And everyone back home thinks the war is unwinnable.

Kubrick condemns the Vietnam war. But the film is not an indictment of US imperialism. It is a long whinge about the nastiness of war.

Kubrick knows how to use a camera, so it all looks beautiful. Some of the scenes have a lot of power, so they cover for the ones that are just a mess or that don't add up.

The film has its moments that go way over the top, too. At training camp, one of the recruits snaps under the strain. But he's a stock character psycho, showing more white-of-eye than even Jack Nicholson in Kubrick's earlier "The Shining'. . The whole training camp sequence is just a bore. Clint Eastwood uttered the same insults in 'Heartbreak Ridge" and we've seen Marines climbing ropes and crawling along the ground in about ten thousand other films.

The scenes are just there to show how the Marine is formed. He's treated like vermin; he's broken down so that he can be built up again as an efficient killing machine. But since only the whacko puts any energy into the killing instinct, it all falls a little flat.

When the Marines are finally in combat, they seem to be loosing off rounds of ammunition out of sheer terror, rather than from any implacable killer instinct. The real Vietnam The film follows the career of Private Joker. He becomes a correspondent for "Stars and Stripes" the forces' newspaper. But he wants to report on real combat, so he ends up in the firing line after all. Joker is a stand in for Kubrick. He's the voice of the artist. He gets to do a few voice-overs and make a few cracks to show he's fully aware of all the ironies of life, war and the human condition.

He wears a peace badge on his lapel, which contrasts strangely with the 'Born to Kill' stencilled on his helmet. He explains to a superior officer that it's there to express the duality of man, the Jungian idea. Joker is not a plausible character.

The part is pretty unplayable, so you can't blame the actor too much. Kubrick piles so much on Joker that he just collapses, in one of the final scenes, Joker is all tensed up over whether or not to kill a Vietnamese sniper who is wounded and dying slowly and in great pain. To complicate matters, the sniper is a teenage girl. The most humane thing he can do is kill.

Joker screws up his face to convey all the layers of meaning here. And then? We cut to a large group of Marines all marching along together singing the theme from the Mousketeers, while Joker muses that it's great to be alive. Presumably, dispensing death gives life a certain savour.

Vietnamese

What can we make of all this? In the film we don't see the NLF and the only South Vietnamese we see are pimps, whores and thieves. They don't get any sympathetic handling.

The Marines grumble all the time about how unwelcome they feel. But when you see the Marines lumbering along, with their masses of equipment. they look utterly alien. No wonder the Vietnamese the 'elephants".

Kubrick got all caught up in the ironies of Vietnam, and it clouded his vision. He's tried to produce the definitive version of the roll'n'roll war. But just showing Marines in uniform while Nancy Sinatra sings on the soundtrack can't do the trick.

When Joker is interviewed and asked why he enlisted, he smiles for the camera, and replies, 'I wanted to see exotic countries. I wanted to see Vietnam, the pearl of Asia. I wanted to meet people of an ancient culture and kill them'. He's grinning.

And that's all you get. Kubrick does convey the derangement of war. We see men with the 'thousand-yard stare', the eyes of men who have been in battle too long. But there's no message. There are all the pyrotechnics and thrills Kubrick can muster up, but the technique substitutes for a message rather than serving one. IMPRKERS' IBERTY st chev -

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 332

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →