The left, Iran and the Gulf war
Socialist Organiser1987 1987-10-29Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 8 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 8
SUBSCRIBE!
Get Socialist Organiser delivered to your door by Rates(UK) £8.50 for six months, £16 for a year, Get your copy!
Organiser no 332. Thursday 29 October 1987 Page 8
An issue of increasing impor
tance for socialists is our attitude towards various relatively powerful "Third World' regimes. The Gulf War has been a case in point since it started in September 1980. From the beginning, all too many socialists rushed to 'defend Iran' — usually on the spurious grounds that Iraq was fighting a "proxy war' for imperialism.
The Iranian revolution was still fresh in our minds — an immense popular insurrection that had toppled the Shah in February 1979. Most socialists were slow to lace up ic what the revolution produced, including, in retrospect, Socialist Organiser, although we were more measured than most.
Most of the left, if not all, have since sobered up to the realities of Khomeinist barbarism. But as the US has become more and more embroiled, plenty of erstwhile devotees of the Islamic Republic have breathed an anti-imperialist sigh of relief. Now it's all change to 'defend Iran' again.
Socialist Action, whose editorial board includes a vociferous minority who have remained infatuated with the "revolutionary potential" of Islamic fundamentalism through thick and thin, intoned: "The US inSolidarity with workers in the Eastern bloc!
Meetings to argue the case f the 7 November Solidarity Cr ference Wednesday 28 October: 7.45, Wallasey Unem:
Centre.
Thursday 29 October: 1pm, Liverpool Unive Student Union. workers' liberty, East and West. We aim to help organise the left wing in the Labour Party and trade unions to fight to replace capitalism with working class socialism. SOCIALIST SOCIALIST: NICARAGUA ORGANISER Uister cops did shoot to kill The Tories new homeless Clive Bradley tervention in the Gulf is aimed at dealing blows against Iran...In these circumstances socialists must defend Iran against imperialist attack."
'Workers Power' declared: "In the continuing conflict between Iran and the imperialist navies we stand unequivocally for the defence of Iran." And if Iraq should 'again' start fighting a "proxy war" for the US, "the defence of Iran" in a more general sense "would, once again, be Paced on the agenda, " (October what is missing from these ringing declarations is any real understanding either of the character of the present war, or of the current "phase of For sure the US and its allies want to tame a troubelsome enemy. But their enemy is not our friend. The Khomeini regime continues to be a bitter enemy of the workers and the poor - and of the oppressed nationalities of Iran such as the Kurds.
So tar, nothing has happened to change the essential character of the war. It remains the same Gulf war it was a year ago — or 7 years ago -although with more direct US involvement.
If the US made a serious attempt to 5pm, Manchester University Student Union. 8pm, Stockport (phone 061-429 8101 for venue Friday 30 October dinnertime, Salford University Student Union. 7.30, Millstone pul Central Manchester Wednesday 4 Camberwell, We want public ownership of the major enterprises and a planned economy under workers' control. We want democracy much fuller than the present Westminster system — a workers' democracy, with elected representatives recallable at any time, and an end to bureaucrats' and managers' privileges.
Socialism can never Name Address One 6/12 months sub!
Please send Socialist Org aniser, PO Box 823, conquer Iran — or at least to invade Iran, overthrow the government and install a puppet regime — we would be obliged to 'defend Iran'. But that has not happened; and it is extremely unlikely that it will happen.
Iran is a regional big power, a subimperialism. Its national rights are not at stake. What US imperialism is attacking is not ran, not the Iranian people, but the Iranian regime.
Socialist Worker has tried to be a bit more balanced, maintaining its criticisms of Khomeini. Yet it too nas declared, "As Americans have become more deeply committed to the Iraqi side in the war, socialists have had to alter the emphasis of their arguments." (October 24). In other words, tone down the harsh words against Iran, lest they play into imperialism's hands.
Enemy
SW have gone further than that. "Socialists will be happy if Iran gives struggle for liberation from Nicaragua to Palestine will see its enemy weakened."
Every struggle? Including the struggle of the workers and oppressed of Iran? Or do they no longer count? For the fact is that an Iranian London.
Klebanov Nikitin By John Cunningham £1.25 from Kingsdown Bristol BS1 in one country alone. The workers in every country have more in common with workers in other countries than with their own capitalist or Stalinist rulers. We support national liberation struggles and workers' struggles world-wide, including the struggle of workers and oppressed nationalities in the Stalinist states against their own antiI enclose 2. To:
London SE15 4NA. victory will be very bad news for those who Khomeini oppresses.
Socialist Worker has for many years considered itself politically distinct from "orthodox Trotskyism" with its obsession for 'antiimperialism' . A recent analysis of the Iranian revolution published by SW, in the book Revolutionary Rehearsals" , gives eloquent warning to the pitfalls of any 'anti-imperialism' that isn't genuinely socialist. Yet when it comes down to it, SW can collapse into the same framework as the most 'orthodox' of "Trotskyists' framework that divides the world into two, imperialism and the rest, and draws political conclusions accordingly.
Significatly, Socialist Worker commented on September 12 that "The Iranian left's failure to understand that its main enemy is at home led it into fatal support for the mullahs at the outbreak of the war. Yet they themselves had a pro-Iran position for a period after the start of the war.
To relate to the world ofthe 1980s, socialists have to break out of that primitive framework. We have to oppose imperialism and defend the interests of the workers and oppressed nationalities and peoples of the Third World independently of reacitonary 'anti-imperialist' governments like Khomeini's.
IDEMONSTRATEI
At the Soviet Embassy Wed 25 November 18 Kensington Palace Gardens 1.30 to 3.00 socialist bureaucracies.
For full equality for women, and social provision to free women from the burden of housework. For a mass working class based women's movement.
Against racism, and against deportations and all immigration controls.
For equality for lesbians and gays.
For a united and free Ireland, with some federal system to protect the rights of the Protestant minority.
For left unity in action; clarity in debate and discussion.
For a labour movement accessible to the most oppressed, accountable to its rank and Tie, and militant against capitalism.
We want Labour Party and trade union members who support our basic ideas to become supporters of the paper - to take a bundle of papers to sell each week and pay a small contribution to help meet the paper's deficit. Our policy is. democratically controlled by our supporters through Annual General Meetings and an elected National Editorial Board.
YEAR OF REVOLUTION From page Thursday 19 October The Central Executive Commitlec declares the previous day's meeting of Petrograd garrison representatives un constitutional and convenes a new meeting; a majority of delegates declares the meeting unconstitutional as it has not been called by the military section of the Petrograd Soviet. Kerensky and the commander-in-chief discuss contingency plans in the event of an armed uprising.
The Moscow regional soviet Executive Committee advocates the arming of workers and poor peasants by Red Guards and an immediate transfer of power to the soviets. The Smolensk Soviet calls for all power to the Soviets. More Cossak troops arrive in Kaluga, attack a meeting of the soviet, and arrest its members, A meeting of the Ist Grenadier Corps on the Western front resolves to begin fraternisation with the Germans. In the Rostovo-Nakhichevansky Soviet Executive Committee elections Bolsheviks win 16 of the 30 seats. A meeting of the 17th Orenburg Cossak regiment refuses to obey orders to move from the SyrDaryinsky region to Tashkent to crush unrest there.
Friday 20 October The first meeting of the MilitaryRevolutionary Committee is held in Petrograd and declares that no weapons may be removed from arsenals without its permission. The Minister of War reports lo the Pre-Parliament of shortages of food, shoes, and warm clothing on all fronts in the war. The commander of the Petrograd military district issues orders to increase the numbers of troops stationed at strategic buildings in Petrograd.
In Vorouichi soldiers in the 174th regiment arrest their commander for refusing to obey the orders of the regimental committee, and take over the station and telegraph office. The SushchenskoMarinsky regional soviet (Moscow) resolves to organise Red Guards. The Archangenisk Soviet Executive Committee votes down a resolution to set up Red Guards. Bolsheviks win 8 of the 13 seats in the Byshny-Volochek Soviet Executive Committee elections.
A meeting of the 47th Infantry regi ment on the Rumanian front calls for soviet power. By 126 votes to 16, with 11 abstentions, the Samara Soviet adopts a Bolshevik resolution on soviet power. Saturday 21 October The Petrograd Soviet issues an appeal to Cossak troops not to allow themselves tc be used by the enemies of the people to attack workers and soldiers. The commander of the Petrograd Military District refuses to obey the orders of the Military Revolutionary Committee. By an overwhelming majority a meeting of delegates of the Petrograd garrison votes to take orders from the Military Revolutionary Committee, not the Petrogral military district commander.
Bread rationing in Petrograd is reduced from three-quarters to half a pound per rations coupon. A meeting of the Moscow provincial soviet resolves not to obey any orders of the Provisional Government of an undemocratic character.
The Shuya Soviet declares that only seizure of power by the soviets can end the food crisis. A general strike begins in Ivanono-Voznesensk, pickets are armed, and factories are taken over by the workers. The Vladivostok Soviet publishes a statement that it has assumed Tull power and that failure to obey the soviet will be regarded as a counterrevolutionary act.
Meetings of the Erorevsk Sovier. Rezhitsa Soviet, Mariupol Soviet, Atkar sk garrison, and Far East regional congress of trade unions pass resolutions in avour of soviet power Continued on page 10
----- pull-quotes -----
STAND Socialist Organiser stands for
Britains death squad exposed-
November: 7.30, Station pub,
John Cunningham 12 Thomas Street,
FREE VLADIMIR KLEBANOV Free Trade Unionist