[The SO editorial entitled 'Castrate Rapists?' concluded: "Anderton…]
Socialist Organiser1987 1987-10-22Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 10 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 10
The SO editorial entitled 'Castrate Rapists?' concluded: "Anderton may have done us one good turn - by showing those on the left who want heavier sentences for rapists where such ideas lead"
Nowhere in the preceding 436 words did you offer any objective evidence to back up your conclusion. =l for one would like to see heavier sentences for rapists. The taking away of two years of freedom, even in the archaic conditions of a British Victorian prison is not a big enough punishment for an atrocity such as -I do not support the castration of rapists, the chopping off of the hands of thieves or the death penalty for murderers. These are, for sure, a barbaric step backwards. And it is beyond my comprehension as to why my support for heavier sentences, in the here and now will automatically lead me one day to the conclusion that what society or one of its agents should be doing is removing the balls of rapists.
The imprisonment of serious offenders — offenders who endanger, menace and take the lives of others is the best available answer within this rotten system. Various rehabilitation programmes within this context have their place, but rehabilitation under capitalism for rapists, by drugs or some liberal therapy group will never work.
The editorial is correct to suggest that there are a whole series of changes required. And part of those changes needs to be tougher sentencing. Better design and lighting of streets will do more to deter the mugger than the rapist - because contrary to popular belief most rapes don't occur by some mad aminal-like stranger in a dark alley.
And while it is vitally important that the legal and police procedures surrounding rape cases are treated more sympathetically, and sensitively, as this will certainly lead to more women feeling confident and strong enough to report the crime, it won't deter the rapist!
Using the logic of the editorial, I could just as easily say that your arguments will lead us to a point where no one is imprisoned for any crime — because prison brutalises. So what's the drug we give to the cold, calculating murderer?
The question we have to ask is why certain criminals should be imprisoned? Is it for retribution, protection, deterrent or rehabilition? Well retribution is a dodgy one in and of itself. It is the principle of "an eye an eye'. Society wanting its
Scan page 11
Idustriall SSH