Don't give up on COSATU
Socialist Organiser1987 1987-10-22Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 10 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 10
that the Stalinists dominate com- Stalinists. within the framework of the two- socialists in South Africa need their stage theory of revolution is regarded own programme but we do not In this analysis there seems to be a Stalinism, dismissal of the COSATU far too blanket identification of the left and a celebration of NACTU ANC wing of the liberation move- provides a coherent starting point. YEAR C YEAR OF RE OL ITION A recent article in Workers' Liberty by a South African socialist active in the unions made a number of claims with which we take issue.
First, the claim that "the National Council of Trade Unions (NACTU) represents the only hope for the growth of the non-Stalinsits to place socialism firmly on the agenda" is both unsubstantiated and unlikely to be true.
Our knowledge of NACTU is limited but we know it is a loose federation which includes many unions which are far more conservative and bureaucratic than any union in COSATU, and that it is held together in part by a black consciousness ideology which falls short of COSATU's principle of non-racialism.
It may be possible for socialists in NACTU to organise themselves and grow but it would be equally possible for socialists in NACTU to be drawn into an ill-defined, right-wing "antiStalinism"
second, the claim that the COSATU left are "paralysed and incapable of leading a socialist struggle" seems to us to be a half-truth which ignores the real advances made by socialists in COSATU, as for exrion today Me hat une from Cad. sia Man bester's police Ana, is that serious and WU. NAAWU. UMMAWOSA and MACWUSA to create a powerful, militant and explicitly socialist metal union, NUMSA.
The fact that socialists in COSATU have suffered certain setbacks in the recent period is no reason to write them off. The real issue is not to counterpose the NACTU left favourably to the COSATU left but to organise the trade union left generally so that it can act as a coherent force. We have been given no reason to believe that this should be done under a NACTU rather than a COSATU banner.
Third, we have a problem with the comrade's analysis of Stalinism. He writes that a workers' party would be impossible because *the Stalinists would eliminate the leadership of a workers' party" , that "they are not going to tolerate any opposition to their claims to monopoly contro pletely and that "Anything that is not as counter-revolutionary"
ment with "Stalinism", a lack of precision about what Stalinism is (it certainly can't be identified with the the physical of action-police A driven by un- controllable sexual chief Anderton urges.
Three giris and violent films for the increase in *the most appalling rime that can ever be And he blamed Page • do so, then ought to be everets punished and sbould ved by some remov al urge and he coa sesuni out of the sheer beatre committed."
The chit constable of sen Castrate rapists?
that drue in mini than when see pound of flesh for the crime committed. But I'm not convinced that for crimes that do endanger, menace or take the lives of others there shouldn't be some element of retribution in the penalty, although I'm not saying a big element.
As for protection, it is undoubtedly true that imprisonment does sometimes protect - first and foremost it protects those vulnerable from the offender and in some cases protects the offender from society -in the case of child sex offences and Some rapes, On the issue of deterrence, the argument that says, with the support of statistics, that imprisonment (and therefore tougher imprisonment) doesn't deter, doesn't convince me!
A survey done in the US of a thousand men on rape and pornography asked the question: Would you enjoy raping a woman if you thought you could get away with it? Almost three-quarters of those taking said that they would enjoy raping a woman if they thought they could get away with it. This is not a crushing argument but neither is the opposing argument.
And finally as for rehabilitation, prisons under capitalism are unable to rehabilitate on any useful scale. In some respects it even seems that to rehabilitate within this rotten system is merely papering over the cracks, it is not dealing with the real problems.
Together retribution, protection, danger that in the name of "antiStalinism" the left might find itself drawn into an unprincipled alliance with the right, at the expense of its own socialist independence.
This analysis also implies that the whole of the leadershp of COSATU is made up of one undifferentiated Stalinist bloc.
Anti-Stalinism is too negatíve a slogan to provide the basis for a positive alternative based around non-racial, democratic socialism.
The degeneration of the Pan Africanist Congress is a tragic example of where such "anti-Stalinism" can lead.
For far too long the South African left has defined itself reactively by being "anti-Stalinist", and "antiANC" rather than by developing its own viewpoint and agenda and in the Chu mauverenuiy mirroring the and inadiartantu mineanino We agree with the writer that believe that a combination of antiCLIVE BRADLEY BOB FINE TOM RIGBY for ra ists?
Taking things eart rm not e pambi JOHN ASPINALL: PETER de SAVARY. cally prevent ASPINALLS, the Mayfair casino noirolled he coming John Aspinall and or Who sutters? Does the borahe deterrence and rehabilitation (not necessarily in order of preference or importance) all play a part in dealing with those criminals who threaten, intimidate, menace or take the lives ala ALICHaCC YVO of others.
I'm not satisfied that the list of demands for better design of street lighting, better police and legal procedures and self defence is complete.
Men are generally bigger and stronger than women. Any honest self defence expert will tell you if the victim is caught unaware and relaxed ten sne is automaucany disauvantaged.
Being able to poke him in the eyes or giving him a swift kick in the groin is not always the best answer — often fighting back will endanger the victim's life even more.
A minimum sentence of, say, five years, would be a heavier sentence than the average sentence currently bestowed. This along with better design of street lighting and better legal and police procedures and self defence taught to all women is what is required now.
A permanent form of punishment is not the answer. Rape will still exist. A fundamental change in the position of women in society and of male attitudes towards women is, as the editorial states, a necessity.
But can women, all of whom are potental rape victims (this includes baby gırls of six months and elderly women in their nineties) wait for this fundamental change? No!
I can't see any conflict in supporting, indeed demanding heavier sentences for all rapists and strongly I'm not a wishy-washy liberal or a Christian. If supporting heavier sentences for rapists this side of the rainbow is using an eye for an eye principle then I must be a would-be feminist - silly me - I thought I was a revolutionary socialist.
MOUNTFORD
----- pull-quotes -----
ntences for rap CASTRATE
RAPISES' i A proper course
Aspinalls casino sold in £90m deal
opposing such barbaric penalties as castration.