Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Humanising the Holocaust

Socialist Organiser no. 331, 22 October 1987 · scan p. 9 · Michele Carlisle · about 722 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 9 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 9

Socialist Organiser no.331 22 October 1987 Page 9 Schmattes, they called them. The Nazis dehumanised the Jews in the concentration camps in every way possible, even forbidding fellow Jews from describing the bodies of their dead relatives and friends as bodies or people or victims. They were wood or shit or schmattes, the Yiddish word for rag.

Claude Lanzmann, in his nine and a half hour film Shoah humanises the Jews again, He dispenses with the archive material of emaciated bodies, mass graves and jackboots to which many people have become almost desensitized and confronts the viewer with survivors and perpetrators, as they are now, recalling the massacres and the murders of the Nazi years. The film is historical evidence and Lanzmann sometimes literally had to force the survivors to appear, so that their testimonies would not be lost.

He takes them back to where it happened. In Chelmno, Poland, a total of 400,000 Jews were massacred. Because we can understand it better, the figure for survivors is more chilling — two. Just two. Simon Srebnik, who survived a bullet through his head, stands in a bare green field "Yes this is the place" To him, and to us, a field is so famniar that it is hard to believe that it had once been the scene of so much evil and destruction.

Srebnik was a singer as a boy and was known by the Poles who lived near the camp Many them Janek, Age 15'. Franciszek Jazwiecki remember him today. Many of them remember the Jews -and are glad that they are gone. The Jews killed Christ and suffered for it, the Jews were dishonest and exploited the Poles. One woman felt sorry for the Jews who were being transported in trucks to Chelmno. "But it gets on your nerves seeing that everyday".

Mordechai Podchelebnik was the other survivior of Chelmno. He was forced to unload the bodies of dead Jews from trucks. On the third day of doing this, he unloaded the bodies of his wife and children.

Lanzmann forced Podchelebnik to speak. He did not want to. He smiles all the time. "Why?" asks Lanzmann. The response comes through an interpreter. "What do you want him to do, cry?" And he cries anyway. slightly believable — it's deliberately silly that in all the various bloodbaths. against impossibly superior odds. Ness gets out without a scratch; it's deliberately laughable that a troop of Canadian mounties charging unprotected into a barrage of machine gun fire could do so unscathed...

Maybe. Yet shortly after the mounted cavalry come galloping to the rescue, Ness learns how bad it feels to kill someone. A note of seriousness (although it could be added that it's a lesson he immediately forgets).

Yes, maybe. could have misunderstood the whole thing Maybe it's all a joke.

But if that is so, it has to be said that it isn't a very good one. And for a joke it must have been fantastically expensive, as whatever else might be said, "The Untouchables' has a remarkably lavish period set.

Robert De Nero as Capone is a highpoint, giving a virtuoso performance. But Connery, who can be excellent, is pretty dire (he really should have made up his mind whether he was faking an Irish accent or not). And nobody else has a sufficiently developed character to require any acting.

A lot of hype for a load of tripe. George Breitman A new book celebrates the life George Breitman, an American Trotskyist who died last year. Breit man was the last of the generation that founded the American Socialist Workers Party in the 1930s.

He was an expert on black questions in the USA, and in particular the life and ideas of Malcolm X. Breitman was also one of the editors of Trotsky's works. But he was expelled from the SWP in 1984 as that party moved further and further towards Stalinism.

He spent his last years fighting the same cancer of Stalinism that he had fought in his youth, now reproduced within the party he had devoted his life to constructing.

The book includes tributes from a wide range of figures, and is published by the Fourth Internationalist Tendency, which Breitman supported. 'A tribute to George Breitman: Writer, Organiser, Revolutionary'. • FIT, PO Box 1947. New York, NY 10009.

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 331

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →