Making class central to our strate
Socialist Organiser1987 1987-10-22Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 5 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 5
Evolving local people will rebuild the left.
The Chesterfield Organising Committee's practical proposals — for a Socialist Directory providing assistance in campaigns — could provide real assistance in this.
The defence of local government services and jobs will continue to be a major concern for the left. But as once again the Labour councils themselves fail to present a clear strategy for resistance to the goverment — or any strategy at all — we should be clear that it will be necessary to support workers in struggle against local councils. Working class people should not be asked to accept cuts implemented by Labour councils in a supposedly benign way.
The Chesterfield conference could provide a forum to put the left back on track. Ideas can start to be thrashed out. We can begin a comradely debate. We need to make sure that we develop a clear direction for the future. some of these Eastern bloc fat cats, and by the fact that they seem to get on better with the Tories than with Labour: but he regards them as an authentic voice of socialism and Marxism.
Now it is the business of diplomats to talk to politicians, and politicians to talk to diplomats. But Tony Benn's reluctance to support Solidarnosc must have something to do with these long-standing contacts. And if you see the USSR as socialist, then it is difficult to move from rejection of existing capitalist structures to advocating working class democracy. The most important section in the Briefing Document for the Socialist Conference on 24-25 October is the one on 'The working class and socialism"
Briefly, but carefully and without dogmatic bluster, it explains why the working class must be central to socialist politics. Important as women's and black struggles are, they cannot substitute for class struggle. "The working class (which includes both women and men, black and white has a special position in the capitalist system which gives workers both the most direct interest in opposing capital and the greatest capacity to do so." Only the working class can make socialism.
Centrality The document, however, is a collection of papers by different authors, of varying political colours. This generates an interesting variety of ideas and questions, but it means that the idea of the centrality of the conflict between capital and labour cannot structure the document.
Thus the section on Production, Jobs and Services' - which should be pivotal — is a series of disjointed chapters. They are all valuable in themselves, but they do not add up to a strategy.
The casino economy of international finance is condemned and exchange controls are proposed. The increased mobility of capital, and its more ruthless use of cheap labour both in the West and in the Third World, are analysed. Increased arms spending is shown to have sucked up a big proportion of high-technology development.
The possibilities are discussed for workers to redesign technology to meet their needs rather than capital's. Campaigns are proposed for shorter working week and safer work conditions. The increased inequality created by the Tories' policies is condemned, especially as it affects women and young people. Problems of public ownership and democratic control are discussed.
The difficulty is that each topic is discussed separately, with a focus on what can be done to get improvements on that particular front. This piecemeal approach is especially unsuitable for dealing with the central struggle between labour and capital - which is what Production, Jobs and Services' is all about. The tiger of capital cannot be skinned claw by claw.
The basic objective of labour in its struggle against capital must be the overthrow of capital — the replacement of production for profit by production for need. That means a planned economy under a regime of workers' democracy, workers' control in workplaces, and public ownership.
Partial measures have to be located in relation to that basic objective. Marxists discussing this in the Third International, with Lenin and Trotsky, put it like this: we should take up those "demands, based on the deeply rooted needs of the masses, which are such as will organise the masses and not merely lead them into the struggle.
All concrete watchwords originating in the economic needs of the workers must be utilised to focus and stimulate the struggle for workers' control of production, which must not assume the form of a bureaucratic organisation of the social economy under capitalism, but an organisation fighting against capitalism through the workers' committees as well as through the trade This approach - based on the self-liberation of the working class, or "socialism from below' — gives us some pointers about key demands today. Work-sharing without loss of pay, under workers' control; expansion of public services under workers' control; a charter of workers' and trade-union rights — these are "such as will organise the masses and not merely lead them into the struggle.
In this perspective some of the ideas in the conference document seem not so much wrong as just offbeam. Workers' cooperatives and local enterprise boards may do useful things, but they are side-alleys fromthe main road of class struggle. A workers' government in Britain, if isolated, would have no choice but to impose exchange controls, but exchange controls in isolation are not socialist at all.
The answer to the international casino economy should be international workers' unity. The briefing document's section on 'Europe and the EEC' is far better on this "Purely 'national' perspectives for socialist change" such as the old Alternative Economic Strategy are, it argues, ineffective. The emergence of the EEC as a semi-state is a reality which cannot be ignored by the labour movement". Instead of the old nationalist cry 'Britain out of the EEC' we should propose, not support for the EEC, but "demands for an alternative "social Europe' ... West German level dole payments, Dutch pensions, Danish social security payments..."
The practical internationalism of this section, and the clear class focus of the section on strategy, should form the basis for a new, integrated perspective for the left.