Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

How yuppie socialism

Socialist Organiser no. 331, 22 October 1987 · scan p. 4 · about 645 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 4 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 4

-rialist Organiser no.331 22 October 1987 Page 4reviews 'Out of the wilderness: diaries 1963-67', by Tony Benn. Hutchinson, £14.95.

These, according to Tony Benn, are "the diaries of a socialist-inthe-making"

In 1963, when the diary opens, Tony Benn was a middle-of-the-road Labour politician of long standing, an MP since 1951. In the period covered by this volume, he became, rs, Postmaster General and then of Technology in the 1964-70 Labour government.

In 99 cases out of 100, such experience of office drives middle-ofthe-road or even left-wing Labour politicians to the right. They identify with the job of managing capitalism.

They absorb the weary realism of the conservative civil servants who surround them. Their stance hardens as they defend decisions made in the corridors of power against criticism from the rank and file.

But Tony Benn, like a very few others, reacted differently. When he was frustrated by the inert resistance of the Establishment to even minor reforms - his attempt, as Postmaster General, to introduce postage stamps not bearing the Queen's head figures largely in this volume — his problem-solving mind turned to more radical conclusions.

Since 1979 Tony Benn has distanced himself decisively from the inner circles of Labour's leadership, and stood firmly with the left on issues like the miners' strike and the witchhunt in the Labour Party.

It is hardly a typical story of the makıng of a socialist: But it is an instructive one. Tony Benn sums up his conclusions in his foreword:

*One of the Labour Party's failings is that it has never seriously concerned itself with State power... State power, ...reflected in the organisation of the civil, military and security services, had prevented Labour Ministers carrying through any but minor changes...

The centralisation of power within the Labour Party in the hands of Labour Prime Ministers is another conservative factor. The economic power of industrialists and bankers, and the influence of the media, also protect privilege.

Thus "Britain is only superficially government by MPs and the voters who elect them. Parlamentary democracy is, in truth, little more than a means for securing a periodical change in the management team, which is then allowed to preside over a system that remains in essence intact"

Comparing these conclusions with the ideas that Tony Benn expressed in his diaries 20-odd years ago shows us that, despite everything, Labour's left has made some progress in those After being told by Harold Wilson that he would be Postmaster General if Labour won the 1964 election, Tony Benn wrote in his diary: *1 feel like a revolutionary who has been told by the insurgent general that when we capture London I am to take over the Post Office.' Such enthusiasm was common in 1964, even among those who stood much further to Labour's left than Benn. But the political substance of this "revolution" was nothing more than vague talk of modernisation, efficiency, and a bit more welfare.

The Benn of these diaries supports incomes policy. He enforces it against post workers. He is privately dismayed about Harold Wilson's attack on the 1966 seamen's strike as engineered by "communists", but has no doubts about the principle of opposing the strike.

He thinks that the Labour Party is held back by "the terrible handicap of trade-union leadership" , and that * The control of the National Executive of the Labour Party by the trade union leaders...is one of the sources of Conservative strength."

He sees the more middle class composition of the 1966 intake of Labour MPs as welcome evidence that *The Labour Party is in the process of transforming itself into a genuine national party"

He suggests to Harold Wilson that Labour should present itself as "the natural ally of the managers and the people who run industry" . He wants the Post Office broken up and freed from political control so that it can

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 331

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →