Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

the left went off the track

Socialist Organiser no. 331, 22 October 1987 · scan p. 4 · about 934 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 4 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 4

The Campaign Group of Labour MPs, the Socialist Society, and the Conference of Socialist Economists, have called a Socialist Conference in Tony Benn's constituency of Chesterfield for 24-25 October. It will be a welcome chance for the left to take stock. John Bloxam looks at why the left has had setbacks since its peak in the early 1980s, and draws some conclusions. In 1980, after the democratic reforms were pushed through the Labour Party, Socialist Organiser commented: "It is one of the most important political breakthroughs for the labour novement in decades: but at best it is half a revolution: the opening half. We would do well to remember what Saint-Just said during the French Revolution: Those who make a revolution by halves only dig their own graves.

Seven years later, we are living with the consequences of the left's failure after 1980. The left flopped in local government, in the Labour Party the left has been driven back. In the unions the left is weak.

The movement to democratise the Labour Party, and with it the unions, could have changed the shape of politics in Britain. But it lacked a political perspective; it lacked socialist ideas; and that lack was the root of failure.

For that reason, it is excellent to have conferences like that in Chesterfield, to discuss and clarify socialist ideas, and so avoid future mistakes.

Here and now, there is a felt need for an alternative to 'Kinnockism'. Both in the Labour Party and the unions, there is a continuing shift to the right, and in the wake of the most recent Labour Party conference there will be further shifts under the guise of' the "policy review'. The need for a coherent alternative has helped make the Chesterfield conference such a big event.

Moreover, many of the briefing papers that are to be discussed show a good beginning. The paper on the EEC rejects the narrow British nationalism of the traditional left. On Eastern Europe, there is a healthy anti-Stalinism. And there is a useful statement of the basic strategic relationship between the working class and socialism.

This should also provide the model for an alternative method of discussion. The Labour leadership's policy review will take place behind closed doors, with hand-picked committees, tightly controlled by Westminster and Walworth Road. Open, grass roots discussion — genuinely open -can be counterposed to this bureaucratic style.

Tony Benn has described Field as not a Labour Party conference; it's a conference of socialists." And it is good to involve a broad range of socialists, including those outside the Labour Party.

But the Labour Party is and will be central to any socialist strategy in Britain. Of course many people will be repelled by the actions of the Labour leadership, and to draw them in to joint activity a sensitive approach will be necessary: they are, in any case, right to be repelled.

But the course that many will advocate at Chesterfield, of voluntary *self-exclusion from the Labour Party, is a sectarian one. Labour is an integral part of the labour movement as a whole — it is the trade unions' political wing.

One of the main causes of our problems today was the failure of many socialists to fight seriously in the pp Labour Party in the past. It should be a lesson of the period since 1980, for example, Socialist ideas and a fight for democracy in the labour movement need to be combined and integrated. If in the early '80s we had a democracy movement that was politically rudderless, it would be a disaster now to have coherent socialist ideas without a fight to change the labour movement organisationally.

It is wrong for a section of the left to turn their backs on 'mere constitutional change' in the name of socialist ideas. Accountability has to remain a major issue. We need to create a leadership accountable to the rank and file.

There is an understandable mood in the movement to forget the politics of denunciation' , or a 'theory of personal betrayal', and of course reflex accusations of sell-out as explanation of the situation are utterly inadequate. But it is not 'personality politics' to recognise that the class struggle is fought, in a sense, by individuals. Leaderships do lead, and often badly. We do need a leadership willing to nght for and stand by democratically-decided policies.

Clearly, the argument for democratising and changing the Labour Party has less force now than it had when people had recent experience of a right-wing Labour government ditching party policy. But it is no less valid. Vladimir Derer is quite right to warn that the "left's response must be to improve its effecriveness, not to abandon political struggle.

What does the left in the Labour Party need to do now? Certain. democratic demands inside the party remain to be won - in terms of women's organisation and black self-organisation. And we need to revive the campaign for democracy in general.

The mechanisms of mandatory reselection exist, despite the leadership's success in weakening them. Labour MPs should be made to give regular reports to aggregate meetings, to establish a link between the selection/reselection procedure and the body to which the MP is accountable.

The left shoud urgently consider having a candidate or candidates for the leadership election next year. There is no principle that insists of us that we have a candidate each year. But our failure to do so since 1983 has helped the Kinnock leadership consolidate itself, and rendered a left-wing challenge on policy less credible. 'Put up or shut up' has been

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 331

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →