Hard on 'Comrades'
Socialist Organiser1987 1987-10-15Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 8 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 8
Socialist Organiser no. 330. Thursday 15 October 1987 Page 8 resolution advocating soviet power its ecutive Committee resigns; Bolsheviks and left Social Revolutionaries win the fresh clections. A congress of soviets of the Tunkestan region supports the recent actions of the Tashkent Soviet and condemns the Turkestan regional soviet for failing to support the former.
Sunday 1 October The commander-in-chief on the Northern front orders the arrest of any soldiers spreading rumours about an end to the war. Soldiers and workers in Torzhok demonstrate under the slogans Down with the War, Down with Violence!, 'All power to the Soviets!' and 'No Trust in the Provisional Government!' in opposition to the dispatch of troops stationed in the town to the front. On the Western Front leaflets calling for an end to the war circulate amongst soldiers in the 2nd Army, and soldiers in the 513th, 514th and 711th regiments refuse orders to take up new positions. On the South Western front soldiers in the 4th Infantry Division fraternise with the Germans. The removal of the 45th reserve Infantry Regiment from Nikoleyev is ordered, due to their political activity among the population. In the Samara Duma elections 34 Bolsheviks, 32 Social Revolutionaries, 18 Cadets and 2 Mensheviks are elected. A meeting of Samara railworkers condemns the Vikzhel for prematurely ending the railworkers strike, and calls for an all-Russian railworkers' congress Monday 2 October The Basmanny regional Soviet (Moscow) passes a resolution to mobilise all forces. for struggle under the slogan All Power To The Soviets!' The Presnensky regional Soviet (Moscow) declares that only Soviet power can end the current crisis and calls for the convention of an all-Russian congress of soviets. The strike by chemists' employees in Moscow goes to, arbitration. In response to an appeal from the Rzhev Duma for troops to discipline revolutionary soldiers stationed in the town, the commitice of the 5th reserve regiment of the Staritsky garrison resolves not to permit the despatch of any troops to aid counter revolutionarics. A meeting of the Bryansk district soviet adopts a Bolshevik resolution that the Executive Committee be clected on the basis of proportional representation. Soldiers in the 7th and 8th Siberian rifles on the Western Front, and in the 466th Malmizsky regiment on the Rumanian Front refuse lo obey orders. Soldiers in the 147th and 148th infantry regiments stationed in Kutnetsk adopt a resolution calling for an end 1o the war and transfering of all power to the soviels.
0444 7201 3920 00 24 v020 Why does some of the lett always ind films like 'Comrades' hard to take? Don't comrades know that you can still make political films and also provide a beautifully photographed film which is not necessarily direct.
To describe the film-maker Bill Douglas as being self-indulgent is looking at films not as art but merely as communication. The excellent photography which sets the atmosphere so clearly and the stark difference between the stormy, windswept fields of rural England and the barren, harsh land of the Australian outback was a point in itself.
Douglas himself said the film was not political, however. Throughout, the film either directly or ambigiously brought out the political issues of the time. And in the end drew the conclusion and presented the Tolpuddle Martyrs not just as heroes of their time but of ours.
Workers' Ireland series. no.1 By Juta price €1,50 LL The 1987 general election and the Marxist left By John O Mahony, Jack Çles Martin Thomas A workers Liberty pamphlet 50p Comrade Grayson's description of the travelling lantern man and his guises as a bit of a waste of time is beyond me. It wasn't anything deep or clever. In fact probably one reason the director used the role was because during the 19th century the lanternist was a main source of entertainment and news for the labouring classes. And believe it or not comrade, the figure was actually quite amusing and linked the film from one scene to At the end of the film I felt that you can take up the issues of the 'working man' of the 19th century and bring it into relevance for today and the importance of solidarity amongst working people.
Douglas might have made more of the campaign which was taking place back in England, but I've yet to see a film that is 100 per cent revolutionary perfect. I enjoyed it and suggest other comrades should see it.
North London™ Mellroy!
----- pull-quotes -----
The new Anglo: Irish Treaty