Or the Left?
Socialist Organiser1987 1987-10-15Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 5 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 5
socialist Orsiniser no. 350. Thursday 15 Ocober 1987 Page S it will be good enough if it is just a discussion conference producing more discussion. We need to be much more positive.
At Chesterfield 1 think an alternative perspective to that of the Labour Party leadership has got to be put forward. We must discuss all the issues, clarify them, developing socialist ideas.
There is no objection to bringing our ideas up to date and modernising them. All that is important. But what we need now is a wider base for a socialist programme around which people inside the trade unions and the Labour Party, and some outside the Labour Party can unite and fight in the next few years.
I think we need a revival of something like the Socialist League which existed in the 1930s. A United Socialist League - something of that kind. It does not have to be too rigid. Perhaps it could be something like CND which people could join in their localities to work together for the socialist policies that are required.
The Socialist League existed in the '30s after Labour Prime Minister Ramsey Macdonald betrayed the Labour Party and helped the Tories form a so-called 'National Government'. Although the whole Labour Party moved to the left it was felt you still needed a really strong socialist propaganda organisation. They united with the then Communist Party in a unity campaign - and with the Independent Labour Party, which had then left the Labour Party. They organjsed around a minimal programme on which to fight within the movement to advance socialist ideas. It was led by people like Cripps and included people like Nye Bevan and George Strauss.
Nye Bevan, Cripps and Strauss were all expelled from the Labour Party at one stage - although we now hear how good they were. I am not saying that we should put ourselves up for expulsion, but we do need that sort of organisation to bring people back to the movement, and who the genuine people are.
Neil Kinnock describes the new NEC as a 'marvellous NEC. You stood again and didn't get on. Your vote declined. Audrey Wise got kicked off. Gould and Livingstone got on with quite high votes. What's your assessment?
I think the vote I got was about the the vote of the clear left within the Party - the real left. People voting for me knew who they were voting for. They voted for someone who had stood up and clearly, publicly walked off the platform on the question of Liverpool. Not just Liverpool but a whole series of issues. It is not a personal thing, but in voting for me they were voting for someone who epitomised the left who has stood against the drift to the right. That is not to denigrate Tony and Dennis, but both were not in the situation I was in.
In relation to others, there is a lot of opportunism about. It is interesting that some people were on both lists - the LCC lists and the Campaign Group list. The so-called soft left centre are really a kind of Praetorian Guard for Neil Kinnock, so if you are really on that list you cannot be considered to be too serious in fighting what has been going on. In other words you are going to compromise and go along certain lines.
The leadership made it quite clear last year that I was the one they really wanted off. I believe they made it equally clear this vear, through MPs. and so on.
The kind of vote a got, around 200 CLPs, is the figure we have got to work from to rebuild the left - that reflects the strength of the left within the Party.
The shift to the right was basically delivered by the block vote, which was fairly solid throughout conference. The CLPs were generally on the left. The block vote was put very much in the service of Kinnock. I agree absolutely. One of the most interesting things was the vote on Felicity Dowling's appeal against expulsion. The overwhelming majority of the Constituency Party delegates, having heard the case and not already being mandated by their CLPs, voted against the expulsions. But overwhelmingly the unions voted for expulsion.
In the public ownership debate on a show of hands even rank and file union delegates voted for the NUM resolution, which was not exactly revolutionary, but it summed up Party principles. It was carried on a show of hands. Then the block vote was wheeled out and it was defeated.
Increasingly the block vote is being used as it used to be used in the old The analysis has been put forward by Vladimir Derer that this year's Conference saw the end of a whole period. That period, started with the campaign for democracy and reached its high point in the early 1980s. Since then we have suffered cumulative defeats. This year even a reaffirmation of Clause 4 and mandatory reselection was with the OMOV proposals Part the analysis is that sections of the left were ultra-left in the past. It says we now need to focus on 'political struggle"
I think it is quite right to say that it is the end of an era, that's clear. Also, in all movements there is a danger of ultra-leftism. But ultraleftism has not been a serious danger in my opinion. It has been there amongst some groups and individuals, and expressed itself in speeches and some resolutions. But that has not been a problem.
The serious problem has been the fact that the left has been broken up and divided, and that a section of the left has moved rapidly to the right. The genuine left has been isolated.