[This year's Conference sees the end of a…]
Socialist Organiser1987 1987-10-15Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 3 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 3
This year's Conference sees the end of a story which began in the seventies. It is a story about the advance of the rank and file and programme.
It is the history of the efforts of the rank and file to ensure that this programme was carried out by the 1974-9 Labour Government. Its failure to do so led to the introduction of democratic reforms designed to make pcialist organiser O Box 8215, DATOR SEM:
63917965 Latest date for reports: first Way gi Editor: John O'Mahony. Typesetting: Upstream (TU) Y 358184n.
Published by Socialist Organiser, PO Box 823, London SE15 4NA.
ENcoreet (TU), London E2.
Registered as a newspaper at Signed articles do not HerberTon the PLP more accountable to the Party and to bridge the gap between Labour's programme and the Labour Government's actions.
The story since then is one of defeat. First the newly-won rights of the rank and file to participate in the Party's policy determining processes were undermined. The potentiality of further developing accountability was thwarted by the widespread adoption of shortlists of one and the failure to make the leadership contest a routine annual event.
The forward march of Labour's right started with their gradual capture of control of the NEC and ended at this year's conference with the destruction of the accountability of Labour MPs and the explicit renunciation of Labour's socialist aims. For, in the last analysis, this is what the introduction of the local electoral college and the rejection by conference of Composite 36 (which reaffirmed the Party's commitment to Clause IV) amounts to, For good measure Conference also voted to close down Labour Weekly, failed to support Labour women's demands, confirmed the sentence on Sharon Atkin and expelled Felicity Dowling.
It is clear that a large part of the party's membership and the trade union leadership has so far failed to digest the lessons of the 1987 election, as well as those of the 1979 election. These were: that capitulation to the capitalist status quo as practised by the last Labour government and now vigorously promoted by the present leadership, neither produces Labour governments nor does it help them to remain in office.
Still, the illusion that it does persists. This, however, is not because the 'new' individualistic ideology peddled by the present leadership has a powerful appeal, but rather because the left was not up to the task which confronted it after its victories in 1979-81. Its failure to adopt a strategy appropriate to the situation created by the 1979 defeat and subsequent disunity ensured the left's marginalisation, Now many of those on the left who misguidedly supported the present leadership or opposed from an ultralett position are having second thoughts. This has already led to the beginning of a dialogue between sections of the left who previously would not speak to one another. The setting up of Left Labour Liaison (LLL) and the joint statement of four members of the executive of the Labour Coordinating Committee and three officers of LLL is among the most recent examples of this.
Another is the cooperation established between the Campaign
ry
Group of MPs, LLL and CLPD which this year produced a joint left slate for the NEC elections. The left's losses in the women's and trade union sections are obvious, but are offset by the relative success of the left slate in the Constituency section. A significantly larger number of CLPs than last year voted for the whole slate. The previously secure position of Michael Meacher has been marginalised and Tam Dalyell, who owed his election last year to his inclusion on the left slate, has lost his seat. The left must build on this modest success.
It has been suggested that the defeat of Audrey Wise and Eric Heffer as well as the left's candidates in the Women's Division was due to slating. This view ignores that, unlike the left, the Party's right has for years successfully organised. The left must do the same. If it does not it will suffer a similar fate in the Constituency section to that which has befallen it in the trade union and women's sections.
With the introduction of OMOV, conflict between the right and left in the constituencies will be intensified. Now that the right has had its way on OMOV the left's response must be to improve its effectiveness, not to abandon political struggle. If it accepts this challenge then the 1987 conference may be merely the end of a bad chapter, not the end of the story. Page Three calendars featuring "sizzlers the whole year through." Congratulations Well done, Isabel Horn, landlady the Trafalgar Hotel, Blackpool!
This splendid woman decided she had had enough of a boorish man who left her a rude note about his sheets and was upsetting other guests. The final straw came when he arrived back at the hotel in an excited condition at three a.m. and kicked up a rumpus because he'd been locked out.
Quite rightly, Mrs. Horn kicked him out. The unsavoury character in question turned out to be former "rent-a-mouth" Tory MP Peter Bruinvels, whom the wise electors of Leicester East had also kicked out at the last election. Since then he has found his true vocation — as a Sun columnist.
In his (predictably abysmal) column last Saturday, "rent-a-mouth" had the cheek to lecture seaside hotel keepers on how they "must ensure that standards remain high if we are to attract tourists to resorts like Blackpool. " Surely, that was exactly what Mrs Horn was doing when she ejected him?
Congratulations (2)
Another journalist has been sacked from the 'new look' Star - chief leader writer David Buchan.
Buchan's crime? He described the paper as "nothing more than a soft porn rag" at a Labour Party conference fringe meeting. 330. Thursday 15 October
Scan page 4
On 24 and 25 October, the Campaign Group of MPs, the Socialist Society and the Conference of Socialist Economists are sponsoring a "Conference for Socialists' in Chesterfield. 1000 are expected. Over 100 CLPs and many trade union organisations have already registered delegates. We reprint below the Conference.
The Socialist Conference in Chesterfield has been convened by those who believe that it is now necessary to establish a strong and independent initiative to renew the ideas of socialism in Britain, and bring such ideas up-to-date in order to meet the needs of today and the 21st century.
The sharp swing to the right that has taken place in Britain, and in most other Western industrialised countries, has destroyed many of the gains made in earlier years by the labour, socialist. and trade union movements, and has re-created mass unemployment, undermined essential public services, local democracy and civil liberties. It has created militarised societies which have contributed to the threat to world peace; and socialists have been forced back on to the defensive everywhere.
What we are now witnessing is the re-appearance, on a national and international level, of the crudest form of class politics, instigated by those who now wield economic, industrial and political power. This initiative is designed to enrich their privilege and influence and to suppress any form of challenge.
Socialist ideas offer the only practicable alternative, and have their roots in the experience of working people. They have been expressed mainly through the trade union movement and the Labour Party; they have also been argued for by those in other socialist parties and radical movements; and a number of non-aligned socialists and intellectuals have combined to develop and enrich them, in the process of making links throughout the world.
Great gains have been made: but the world in which we operate has seen capitalism develop also. The challenge to socialist ideas requires us to grow too; serious thinking is required if we are to see socialist ideas become dominant again and to offer a practicable alternative.
A theory personal betrayal not do.
One of the commonest explanations offered for the loss of socialist influence has been that a succession of individual Labour politicians and trade union officials have betrayed the cause of socialism when they have - personally — enjoyed periods in office.
Such theories of betrayal do not however, offer an adequate explanation for what has happened, since they are based on the (false) idea that socialism can be built from the top. This belief runs contrary to the most basic of all socialist ideas: that socialism can only be constructed by working people themselves on a wide and popular basis.
To draw up a list of heroes and traitors is, therefore, a gross and dangerous oversimplification, and diverts us from making the effort 2043.0 needed to create socialism by concentrating our attention on the actions of a handful of leaders, which constitutes a form of personality politics.
The movement needs leadership, but leadership also needs a movement and it is the re-creation of that relationship that is needed.
Electoral politics tends tics above strategy.
Another obstacle that has been identified as standing in the way of progress has been that short-term electoral considerations have tended to inhibit the long-term development of programmes and ideas.
From the time of the Chartists and the Suffragettes, it has been accepted that the vote should be used to seek political power through election to Parliament, or local authorities.
But it must be recognised that the price that has often been paid for that strategy has been that some didates for elective positions have argued that discussions or debates about the nature of socialism may harm their electoral prospects, and should therefore be discouraged.
No-one denies the importance of electoral victories, to defeat those who are opposed to the interests of working people and replace them with others more likely to be sympathetic to their needs.
But there is another position: we argue that widely heard discussions of socialist answers to the problems of unemployment, the environment, health, education and discrimination on grounds of sex or race, far from losing votes, are likely to provide a long term base upon which electoral victories can be built. In fact, arguments for socialism must be heard if socialism is ever to be achieved.
People will only vote for parties if they believe that the policies put before them are in their own interest, and the development of plans for vinningpower cannot be held up until the middle class can be persuaded to change.
One of the issues that has never been faced is that to win elections, socialists must be able to appeal to the 20 percent of the population, most of them standing to benefit substantially by the • adoption of socialist policies, who never vote because they do not see any advantage to themselves by doing so.
Whereas electoral factors are essentially tactical, the spread of support for socialism is essentially strategic, and unless that support can be achieved, electoral success can only bring office and not power. It must be obvious to all in the labour movement, after a succession of electoral defeats, that a deeper analysis is required.
It is, however, now being argued that electoral considerations are the only ones that matter, and that there can be no place for any public campaigning in support of socialist principles or of those in struggle; yet unless this is done people will never be persuaded that voting will lead to the adoption of policies that will meet their needs.
It is partly because there has been so little strategic thinking that Labour's electoral results have been so poor, and its prospects now look so bleak.
It has often been the same story in many trade unions where the important but tactical arguments about how to deal with a particular industrial situation has obscured the need for a deeper political analysis to discover the root causes of exploitation and how to end it.
In today's situation, compromise dictated by the need to advance within the limits of power that is currently available, however understandable, cannot be allowed to obliterate longer term thinking about ways in which society can be transformed.
The Chesterfield Conference The Chesterfield Conference provides us with an opportunity for moving forward in our thinking about socialism and to make explicit the policy issues upon which we should be concentrating.
We should also seek to agree on draft Aims and Objectives, to be discussed more widely, and arrange to set in hand policy work in areas where it is needed.
And we should also prepare a Socialist Directory, listing those who might be interested in this work.
We have now acquired an enormous amount of experience of the successes and failures of socialist policies and socialist organisations in Britain and in many parts of the world, and we have also witnessed the development of many new technologies that have transformed our own societies, and altered the nature of the working class.
We have also seen the emergence of important new campaigns: by women in pursuit of their rights, by environmentalists, by the peace movement, by the Black contmunities. But there has never been, alongside these, a strong and nonelectoralist movement of comparable influence devoting itself to the advocacy of socialism. This gap cannot be filled by fierce personalised, internal battles within the socialist parties and between them.
We should be looking at society as it has developed; at the needs that have emerged; and providing up-to-date socialist policies to meet these challenges. We must also challenge the forces of conservatism by going behind their own lines and showing the fraud that lies behind the argument that market forces can distribute resources efficiently and fairly. The arguments of conservatism are little more than the use of state power to protect the rich.
Individualism and the pursuit of voters' individual interests is incapable of solving the complex problems of modern society. We cannot deal with the questions of poverty, wealth, health care, acid rain, nuclear power or women's rights by a policy which emphasises the primacy of individual rights and responsibilities. What are needed are collective solutions. And it is a fallacy to assume that individual share ownership is anything but a recipe for the continued concentration of economic power in private, unaccountable hands.
It may have been because of that gap in our structures that socialism has tended to be pushed off the agenda of the Labour and trade union movements, and hence off the national agenda.
Aims and objectives The Socialist Conference must not be regarded as a mere talking shop. If our aim is to contribute to the creation of a socialist Britain and an in Benn after his election ternational socialist order in our lifetimes, it is essential that discussion should be followed by concrete action.
Set out below are proposals on which the Conference will be asked to agree at the plenary session on Sunday afternoon. They include a set of draft aims and objectives: specific action proposals and a proposed means of carrying these proposals forward.
The Socialist Conference's purposes will include:
*The defence and extension of democratic and trade union rights, civil liberties, social justice and peace, both in Britain and in a worldwide context.
*To give practical support to organisations representing working people, women and oppressed minorities, in their campaigns for:
*useful work under good conditions and with a decent income;
*health care, education, homes, recreation and dignity in retirement, on the basis of social need and under democratic control;
*an end to poverty and inequality;
*an end to all discrimination based on sex, race, class, life-style or beliefs.
*To disseminate knowledge and understanding of the origins, history and experience of socialism, and how such knowledge can be spread through the creative arts and media.
*To maintain contact, and work with, all those in Britain and in other countries who share similar socialist objectives.
*To offer a realistic vision of the nature of a socialist society, and how it could be achieved by consent in our lifetime.
*To construct a new socialist programme, including policies and action, which could have as its main features commitments to end the drift to authoritarianism in Britain, and specific policies to create a fundamental shift in the balance of power and wealth.
Specific action proposals.
There is an urgent need for immediate action to implement these general proposals, if we are to put socialism back on the agenda of politics in Britain. Specifically, therefore, we propose:
*The creation of Policy Discussion groups on a wide range of subjects, whose tasks will be to create new socialist strategies, pespectives and policies for the 1980s and 1990s, including proposals for making such ideas popular and relevant. They will prepare papers for discussion and submission to the next Socialist ConTerence.
*To organise a vigorvus campaign throughout Britain in order to argue the case for socialism; the campaign should be constituted immediately.
*To create a Socialist Directory in order to put socialists and campaigners in touch with one another on a more regular basis.
*To hold a recall socialist conference, at an appropriate time and place.
*To resource, in practical ways, campaigns mounted by the movement, by giving advice, providing material, and organising support for struggles.
Implementation *Clearly, such a programme of work will not happen of itself. We propose, therefore, as an interim measure, that the existing organising committee should continue to work together for these purposes.
----- pull-quotes -----
the left in the Party, and of Labour's adoption of a radical
Organising Committee's statement to the Socialist Organiser no. serge? bursday 15 October 1987 Page 40.. our Partyl