Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Greens go red in the face

Socialist Organiser no. 329, 1 October 1987 · scan p. 10 · about 1,009 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 10 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 10

among soldiers. A meeting of 8,500 soldiers in Gomet resolves to refuse 10 go to the front.

Tuesday 9 September By 766 votes to 688 with 38 abstentions, the Democratic Conference votes in favour of a coalition government; a majority of delegates from trade unions and workers and soldiers' soviets votes against this; a majority of delegates from peasant soviets and city dumas votes for it. By 813 votes to 183, with 80 abstentions, the conference votes against a coalition involving the Cadets and supporters of the Kornilov mutiny.

A joint meeting of the Central Committee of the Baltic Fleet and the sailors' section of the Helsingfors Soviet opposes the Provisional Government's order to dissolve the Central Committee of the All-Russian War Navy.

In the Moscow Soviet of workers" deputies Executive Committee elections the Bolsheviks win 32 seats, the Mensheviks 1, and the Social Revolutionaries 9. The military section of the Rzhev Soviet of soldiers' deputies calls for transfer of all power to the soviets. On the South-Western front soldiers in the 468th regiment refuse to obey orders.

In new elections for the Lugansk Soviet, Bolsheviks win 82 of the 120 places.

Wednesday September The workers' section of the Petrograd Soviet resolves to hold fresh elections on 23-24 September for positions on the Soviet Executive Committee. An extended meeting of the Praesidium of the Democratic Conference votes by 829 votes to 166, with 69 abstentions, in Turn to page 11 *GU 329Yes Hearn's COLUMN The Autumn issue of New Ground is now out, just in time for the Labour Party conference.

There, Labour's policies of nuclear disarmament and of phasing out nuclear power will be under attack in the supposed interest of attracting votes. An article in this issue of New Ground puts a whole new slant on the The article, by Nick Kollerstrom of the Green Party, is unlikely to win him many friends initially but his arguments deserve to be taken most seriously.

For Kollerstrom, the major obstacle to a permanent nuclear disarmament is the existence of plutonium. Something has to be done with it — it is highly dangerous, even apart from its role in nuclear weapons. One millionth of a gram, if inhaled, can cause lung cancer. Britain's 40 tonnes could kill the world's population ten times over in this way. It is also highly poisonous.

Being radioactive, it is slowly decayıng, but this process will make no difference to the present amount in the foreseeable future. With a half life of 24,000 years, "our" 40 tonnes becomes 20 tonnes after 24,000 years, I0 tonnes after 48,000 on!

Even if the plutonium is thoroughly mixed with concrete Or glass or something and buried under the seabed, it could still be dug up and extracted in usable amounts any time over the next 100,000 years or more. And all this ignores the greater amounts in the hands of the US and USSR governments.

Kollerstrom's "heresy" is in his solution to the problem. He proposes to annihilate the plutonium by feeding it into the sort of nuclear reactors that produced it in the first place. By changing the mode of operation of these reactors, they can use up a fuel of plutonium faster than they produce new plutonium. The more dangerous Fast Breeder Reactors could use up the plutonium even faster. The "breeder" part of the reactor would first have to be removed, of course.

This is indeed a choice between "a rock and a hard place. We would have to keep the nuclear power industry going for years, even decades. And this would produce even more highly radioactive waste, for which, at present, no safe method of disposal exists. As a sort of consolation, we would be able to get electricity from those former nuclear warheads — "bombs into light" , as. Kollerstrom puts it., This proposal will certainly provoke some heated debate. My own opinion is that either we follow Kollerstrom's logic or we think about shooting the plutonium into the sun - but in the latter case, we will need totally reliable rockets that are not going to explode in the Earth's atmosphere or get lost on the way to the Sun to reappear in our skies in the future like Haley's comet.

It may well be that the rocket solution is the only suitable one for the present piles of radioactive waste. It is certain that no-one has come up with any convincing answers to date.

New Ground also contains some unfinished business from the election, notably articles from the unsuccessful Labour and Green candidates in York. There it was, you may recall, that Labour lost to the Tories by 147 votes while the Greens took 637. This is particularly annoying since Labour's Hugh Bayley is a prominent socialist environmentalist and would have been a valuable spokesperson in Parliament for many of the causes supported by the Left and by the Greens. He rejects the idea of electoral deals with the Green Party though supporting joint action where possible.

Next comes a page of vituperation from Green Party members, incensed at a flippant dismissal of their policies in the election issue of New Ground. The Editorial Collective, which includes yours truly, are accused of lies, bolstering its self image, standing in the way of a flood of recruits to the Green Party from Labour and of being faithful servants of "Nuclear Jack" Cunningham, Labour's Environment spokesperson. For a party that prides itself on ts "spiritual" approach, the Greens' ine in insults matches that of the nore traditional labour movement. This is followed by Chartist Mark Douglas' explanation of his move from Labour to the Green Party! SO eaders will find his arguments ineresting, if unconvincing.

New Ground is available from 26 Underwood Street, London N1 for 50p plus p&p. Send 4 Ist class or 6 2nd class stamps for an introductory copyNew Ground Journal en Green-Socielism No. 15. Autumn 1487 60p Reds and Greens after the flood ?

REST •Animal rights • Rivers • Socialist video Pacific • Local Network • Canada

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 329

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →