Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

[YEAR OF REVOLUTION Mike Grayson reviews 'Comrades'. The…]

Socialist Organiser no. 329, 1 October 1987 · scan p. 10 · about 615 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 10 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 10

YEAR OF REVOLUTION Mike Grayson reviews 'Comrades'.

The Tolpuddle Martyrs were six Dorset farmworkers who were deported to Australia in 1834 for forming a trade union branch.

The blanket laws against all trade union organisation, the Combination Acts, had been repealed in 1824, but the ruling class still wanted to keep trade unions down. The mushroom growth of the Grand National Consolidated Trades Union, led by the socialist Robert Owen and pledged to a general strike for an eight-hour day, alarmed them.

The Tolpuddle Martyrs were convicted of taking an illegal oath of solidarity. Mass demonstrations and a petition of 250,000 signatures protested against their sentence, and they were eventually allowed back to Britain in 1836.

They stand as a symbol of the fact that workers have won our rights to organise not by generosity of our rulers, but by class struggle and defiance of capitalist-made law.

So it was with high hopes that I set off to see 'Comrades' , the new film about the Tolpuddle Martyrs. Having read a couple of very favourable reviews, I was confidently anticipating an enjoyable evening. I was wrong.

Comrades is a long film — about 2½ hours, but it feels longer. This length is pure self-indulgence on the part of the makers: a large part of the time is spent on very pretty, but ultimately very meaningless shots, which are no doubt intended to evoke an "atmosphere"

Maybe - but after the sixteenth view of sweaty toilers in the fields, my brain tends to switch off. In the first half of the film in particular, the plot clips along with all the speed of a slug with lumbago.

Again and again the audience is shown that rural life in the 1830s was an endless grind of squalor and misery for the labouring, classes. Grimy yokels queue for their weekly pittance; an over-the-top vicar preaches at them about the natural order of Rich and Poor; a smarmy landowner reneges on his promise to The workers are presented as just add an extra shilling to the wages., So heavily are we fed this angle that when six men are finally arrested for trying to organise a union, the event has no impact whatsoever. It's just one more unfair misfortune in the lives of people who seem to suffer nothing else.

The film's second half, with the Martyrs now transported to New South Wales and Tasmania, is a tad more lively. But we see little of how their families and community are faring whilst the Martyrs are in suffering, with little picture of a fight back uffering, with little picture of a fight Australia. We catch a bare glimpse of the campaign being waged in Britain to get the men's sentences revoked.

All rather suddenly, the men are back together in England, appearing at a rally of their supporters. One of them gives a speech which I suspect may have been intended to end the him in a stirring manner. After 2% hours of this tedium, it doesn't work.

None of the characters reaches beyond the level of stereotype, with the upper classes and their agents coming off worst of all.

And just what is the point of this travelling 'magic lantern' man who keeps cropping up in various guises throughout the flim? I can't for the life of me see what is intended by the use of this figure. No doubt it's something awfully clever really, "Comrades' could and should have been a good film, given its subject matter. That it has been turned into a bore, and an excuse for a lot of (supposedly) impressive visual effects, is more than just a shame - it's a crime.

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 329

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →