Wins for free-market Labourism
Socialist Organiser1987 1987-09-24Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 8 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 8
Tony Brown reports from Sydney on t big Labour election victories in Austra *Scottish mandate. It is a pity that unworkable.
Despite all the hot air rhetoric Scotland that they would refuse to about fighting the poll tax to the last pay the poll tax themselves.
dominated Convention of Scottish local authorities off the hook, and Local Authorities of 28 August transfers the burden of fighting the agreed to open talks with the Scottish poll tax from the councils to the inOffice on implementation of the poli dividual electors. It is the equivalent tax. of expecting council-house tenants Some local authorities had not not to buy their own homes after even made a pretence of putting up their councils have failed to oppose serious opposition to the poll tax. Tory-imposed rent increases and Labour-controlled Strathclyde Tory legislation that councils should Regional Council, for example, has sell off their houses. up for compilation of the Communi- therefore be campaigning for: ty Charge Register — right down to withdrawal of local authorities from the minutiae of where the desks of co-operation in drawing up the Comthe team which will compile the munity • Charge Register; local register will be sited in which offices. authorities to refuse to pay the bill The poll tax is unpopular. Refusal from the Secretary of State; elected by local authorities to help compile Labour representatives to pledge to the register, and a pledge not to refuse to pay the poll tax; local cooperate, could raise the level of op- authorities to pledge to refuse to colposition to the poll tax and make it lect in the poll tax in April 1989. The Labor parties in Australia and New Zealand have recorded historic election victories. Bob Hawke led the Australian Labor Party to its third consecutive term since 1983, the first time this has happened in Australian In New Zealand, David Lange led the New Zealand Labour Party to its second consecutive term, also a first.
These are not the only similarities between the two parties. Both have consciously set out to systematically change the popular understanding of what Labor stood for. Both have implemented policies that Thatcher has made the hallmark of her government.
Despite a national swing of 1% against Labor, it increased its majority to 24 seats. Large swings were recorded against the ALP in safe Labour seats, while in the marginal seats that ultimately determined the result, there were either very small swings to and against Labor.
This is all the more remarkable considering that household consumption declined in Australia by 1% over 1986/87, the first such decline in thirty years. A number of protest candidates stood on either single issues or as part of an attempt to establish the groundwork for a 'new party' • They hoped to capitalise on the disillusionment felt by many Labor voters, but failed dismally. In only two seats did protest candidates to the lett of Labor poll more than 5%.
In the Senate only two protest canOn Monday 14 September local authorities throughout Scotland began preparations to implement the poll tax, due to come into effeet in Scotland on 1 April 1989, The poll tax is a straightforward case of making the poor poorer and the rich richer. It is a flat-rate tax to be paid by each adult. The rich industrialist living in a mansion will pay the same amount as his employee on poverty-level wages in a slum.
Households with an income of t558 or more per week will benefit. In other income groups there will be more losers than winners.
Young householders aged 18-24 will be worse off by an average of E3 and New Zealand didates were elected, the anti Nuclear candidates Jo Vallentine in Western Australia and Robert Woods in New South Wales, and both of these were the last elected after an exhaustive distribution of preferences. Expelled Labor members George Georges and Bill Hartley both polled extremely poorly. The new party proponents have learnt nothing from the results.
The SWP (Socialist Workers' Party - like Socialist Action in Britain, but more Stalinist), retreated from their shrill denunciations of Labor and ALP members in the last week of the campaign. They had earlier called for a vote for protest candidates, Australian Democrats and then Labor. But three days before the election headlined their editorial with "Return Labor and prepare to fight". The SWP weren't alone in this 'change as the CPA and International Socialists also changed their tune in the last week of the campaign.
Within the ALP there was no questioning of the government's record or platform. The parliamentary left have either become complete captives of the right wing majority or in some cases latter day converts.
Hawke and Keating have not only hijacked Labor party policy but also stolen much of the Coalition platform. Since March 1983 they have dramatically changed the face of what many still believed to he a refor.
In the last decade central government grants to local authorities Scotland have been cut from 75% of their expenditure to 55%. Local authorities already face penalties if the government considers its rates too high. Now central government has the power to intervene and fix the level of the community charge if the Tories consider it too high, Moreover, control over business rates will be lost by the local authorities to the government, who will thus end up having control of ming party in the style Whitlam's 1972-75 government.
In that time they have changed party policy to allow for the mining and sale of uranium, deregulated the finance system and floated the SA, launched a comprehensive restructuring of the tax system with the biggest cuts going to companies and salaryearners above $35,000/year, massively cut back social spending reducing the goverment deficit from slo billion in 1983 to balance in 1987/88, and cut real wages by 3% in that same period. -This has all been done in order to let the market determine economic priorities. An almost mystical belief in market forces has led to open hostility on the part of Labor ministers to unions and working conditions and wages. The steel, vehicle and textile industries have been restructured with the loss of thousands of jobs. Legislation has been introduced to restrict the right to strike under the threat of massive fines.
Working days lost in the year to May 1987 are the lowest since 1968. The 1.3 million days lost were 20% lower than in 1986 and 71% less than the last year of the Fraser government.
Now Hawke has indicated that he wants to privatise large sections of public enterprise in order to reduce the call on capital funds by the public sector, and introduce a compulsory national identidy card. Included in the privatisation list is Qantas, the Commonwealth Bank, the profitable sections of Telecom, Australian Airlines and others, all of which were established by Labor governments.
The experience in New Zealand has been much the same. Lange has used the banning of US nuclear powered ships from NZ ports as a cover to a masssive attack on working classs living standards. - The goals have been the same as in Australia although the method has varied. Whereas Keating failed to introduce a VAT style consumption tax, Lange's Finance Minister Roger Douglas managed to introduce a 10% tax. Douglas has also managed to privatise a number of NZ public enterprises, and cut into social spending and wages.
Underpinning these policies is an ideological offensive aimed at arguing that this is in fact the traditional Labour Party. Keating and Douglas have been the main 'theorists' in their respective parties pushing this line.
Douglas in his book Toward Prosperity argues that living standards would fall if the economy continues to rely on large scale public works. He argues that the social goals of the old Labour Party which set up the N welfare state in 1931 are still the same today.
Keating argues that the period between 1950 and 1975 was a aberration. He wants to recast the pre-World -War Il Labor governments in his own image. Central to his theme is that the ALP between 1950 and 1975 took wealth creation for granted, whereas previously its creation was the fundamental issue. Therefore measures aimed at ensuring profit and growth are the cornerstone of the Labor programme and only then can some redistribution occur.
The parliamentary left have been disarmed. They have no alternative. They also believe that restoring profitability is the foundation stone. they only disagree on the method. They simply argue that more government spending is the cure without recognising thet many of these areas are seen as being inefficient, impersonal and bureaucratic.
Keating on the other hand has offered a 'radical' alternative to the large internal and external debt. While it has been largely at the expense of working people, many see it as being necessary. The lack of fight by the left and the unions has left workers believing that there is little At no time have the left questioned how the social surplus should be increased or how it should be distributed. More importantly there has not been any questioning of how decisions about this surplus or production itself should be made.
The ruling class are comfortable and confident with both Hawke and Lange. While New Zealand almost knocked off the Nationals in the richest north shore Auckland seats, Douglas' majority in his blue collar seat of Manurewa was nearly halved.
In Keating's working class seat of Blaxland there was a 6% swing. Labour's traditional supporters are not yet as convinced as the rich.
So, too, would public declarations by all Labour MPs and councillors in To raise slogans such as "Poll Tax We Won't Pay" instead lets the Labour Party activists should