Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

[hester's police chief James punishments, was more brutal…]

Socialist Organiser no. 328, 24 September 1987 · scan pp. 3–4 · about 1,179 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 3 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 3

hester's police chief James punishments, was more brutal and underton, is that serious and per- lawless than modern society, not less streets; women's self-defence cl SO. legal and malina 1.

Socialist Organiser no.238 September 1987 Page 3 chester's police chief James Anderton, is that serious and persistent sex offenders should be castrated.

While it is difficult to take the mad-eyed prophet of the North West very seriously, the subject itself is a serious one, and a lot of people agree with Anderton.

Rape is a terrible crime, and horribly common. The psychological scars inflicted upon women who suffer rape can be deep and permanent.

So why not have a permanent form of punishment? In our society, rapists in fact often get off lightly: the severity of what they have done is not matched by a severe sentence. To protect women - and to scare off future rapists — is it not fair and just to have a penalty that fits the crime?

It is not so simple. Rape is barbaric, but so too is physical mutilation by the state. Castration would be as barbaric as cutting off the hands of thieves or killing murderers. And or anywhere else in the Eastern bloc, then Maggie Thatcher and others would have been screaming their heads off. But it is happening here. pessimistic attitude that says the lads are not ready for it. What happened at Frickley showed that to be wrong.

If we tighten the screw and then find that British Coal will still not relent, then we should be escalating the dispute into full-scale industrial action.

British Coal's attitude hardened when the NEC voted for the 'soft option' . It was then they started talking about breaches of contract and locking miners out. If we retreat or take the soft option, then that is the signal for British Coal to push.

I think we should push back by taking the hard line. I know that will give us problems in Notts, and no doubt elsewhere, but I do not see there is any alternative.

The UDM say they are going to put advertisements in all the papers trying to recruit to their organisation. I do not think they will have much sucThere are, nowadays, forms of "chemical castration', that is drugs whose effects are not necessarily permanent. But they can have horrific side effects. In the 1970s, some male sex ottenders were injected with female hormones, which produced breasts which then had to be surgically removed. But then they grew more breasts, which were removed, and so on, until doctors refused to operate, and the offenders' bodies were horribly disfigured.

Voluntary treatment by new drugs might be different, but the drugs would have to be properly tested -and even then, the case is not a clear one.

The principle of "an eye for an eye" is no less barbaric when used by would-be feminists than when used by Anderton. It does nothing to stop cess. The fact they are trying to recruit miners by breaking industria, action shows exactly what they are worth.

In Notts the NUM had a 92% mandate for action, and I cannot see blokes going into a ballot, voting yes to that extent, and then turning their backs on the union. We might lose a few members, then so be it. My own personal view is that if an NUM member is going to leave the union and Join the UDM because of an overtime ban, the he will not be a great loss.

The miners are taking action again, and I think the rest of the labour movement have got to look back at the lessons of 1984/5. Because other unions hung back on solidarity the miners were defeated. But it was not just a defeat for the miners, it was a defeat for the rest of the labour movement.

The trade union and Labour leaders are now talking about massive recruitment campaigns - but unless they show themselves willing to prorape.

Better design and lightin Better design and lighting of streets; women's self-defence classes;

legal and police procedures more sensitive to the victim; and extending the legal definition to include, for example, rape within marriage — all these would help. Fundamentally, we need to change the position of women in society, and male attitudes towards women, to wipe out the culture from which rapists grow!

Castration would not help do any of that. It would make society more violent, more medieval in its attitudes, more brutalised. Moreover, if we agree thta the state has the right to inflict physical mutilation on these sex offenders, it could be just the thin end of the wedge. What other 'sex offenders' might find that castration is the cure also for their 'illnesses'? Child molesters, all kinds of "perverts' , homosexuals...

Anderton may have done us one good turn - by showing those on the left who want heavier sentences for rapists where such ideas lead. tect working class people they might as well not bother. They might as well recruit amongst the middle classes for the Liberal Party!

The Labour Party and the TUC are there to protect and advance the interests of the working class, and it is about time they started to realise that and act accordingly.

I think the Labour Party needs to realise that the distrust of it that exists amongst working class people 1s of its own making. Time and again it's said on the doorstep 'they piss in the same pot' , 'they are all the same' We stand there and argue with them, but in our heart of hearts we know it is often true.

People become enmeshed in the parliamentary system, and they forget about the working class people who sent them there and the reason why they did it.

The commitment I want to see from the Labour Party conference is that they will stand by the working class, both now and when they get into office.

"snap, crackle and bonk' style.

Should they decide that an unprincipled, boorish, discredited Labour MP really is essential to the success of the paper, predict that they will ditch Ashton and make an offer to the boastful Mr George Galloway.

Just in time Conrad Black, the mysterious Canadian owner of the Daily Telegraph is said to be unhappy with editor Max Hastings Believe it or not, Black regards Hastings as a closet leftie, and has been looking for a more reliable Thatcherite/Reganite replacement.

Ironically, the row over Sir Alfred Sherman's invitation to French fascist Jean-Marie Le Pen to come to the Tory Party conference may result in a reprieve for Hastings, one of his first acts as editor was to sack one of the Telegaph's long standing chief leader writers — Sir Alfred Sherman. Back to basics The lessons of Wallasey's election campaign 50p Wallasey's socialist candidate Lol Duffy came very close to beating Tory MP Lynda Chalker. Read how they built an active, campaigning Labour Party. Available from PO Box 823, London SE15. 50p plus postage.

Scan page 4

Letters ISH

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 328

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →