Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

[Jim Denham reviews 'I'm All Right Jack", shown…]

Socialist Organiser no. 327, 10 September 1987 · scan pp. 9–10 · about 1,200 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 9 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 9

Jim Denham reviews 'I'm All Right Jack", shown on BBC-1 last When the Boulting Brothers made I'm All Right Jack in 1959, they had just emerged from a protracted demarcation dispute with the film technicians' unions at British Lion studios.

The film is a conscious piece of anti-union propaganda made by people with a rather considerable axe to grind. It is also brilliantly cast and acted, very funny and - like all the best propaganda — contains some incidental grains of truth.

The BBC's decision to screen this old British classic on the eve of the opening of the TUC Congress was surely not a coincidence. The late Peter Sellers plays Fred Kite, chairman of the work's committee at Missiles Ltd., and the embodiment of just about everything repellent and ridiculous about traditional' British trade unionism: he is a pompous, ignorant, hypocritical, cowardly, bureaucrat.

Into Kite's little world wanders one Stanley Windrush, (lan Carmichael), a naive, good-hearted, upper class twit. down on his luck and forced to take a job as a fork lift driver at the factory.

The film is a parable about the irrelevance of arcane industrial trade unionism to fair minded individuals untainted by class prejudice.

There are, also, some interesting secondary themes running through the main plot: an anti-male/trade union cross-class alliance of women (Windrush's aunt, Margaret Rutherford and Kite's wife, Irene Handl) and the thinly veiled racism that lies behind both Kite's half-digested anti-imperialist rhetoric and the bosses' patriotic posturing. 1 Formally, the film is even handed: management come over as badly as the unions, and the members themselves are, in Windrush's words, "first class chaps" In fact the bosses ought to come over a great deal worse than the unions as it turns out that the strike was provoked by management as part of a massive swindle and any way what Missiles Lid are up to behind all their 'patriotic humbug about 'export or die' is selling arms to the highest bidder.

Compared to this, Fred Kite's bureaucratic excesses ought to look pretty small time. But somehow it doesn't work out like that. What is memorable about the film is not the suave corruption of managing director (Dennis Price) or the shitty manoeuvrings_of capitalist/spiv Dickie Attenbrough, it is the pompous bloodymindedness of Peter Sellers' chairman of the works committee.

Partly this is a tribute to the wonderful acting abilities of Peter Sellers, but it is also clearly the main intention of the film - the title itself is a phrase always associated with trade unionism, althoug! it could be more appropriately ar, lied the capitalists.

There are, however, just a few moments when - whatever the intentions of the Boulting Brothers - we sec another side to trade unionism as represented by Fred Kite.

In one marvellous scene carly in the film Kite and the works committee confront the works manager (a seedy ex-army type played, inevitably, by Terry Thomas) to protest about Windrush's presence on the shop floor. Terry Thomas immediately proposes the obvious solution. "We'll sack the bounder!"

Kite, plainly taken aback by this, asks if he may "withdraw and confer". He returns to solemnly announce that a sacking would "constitute victimisation" and the works committee would have to "consider industrial action" . It had dawned on him that he was in business to protect jobs, not to lose them.

A little later, Windrush innocently demonstrates to a time and motion man how the job could be done twice as fast with half the workforce; "but we need the money" protests another worker. That thought hadn't occured to Windrush.

All sorts of half baked messages run through this film, but central to it is the idea that 'traditional' trade unionism (and 'outdated' notions of class conflict that go with it) is the main obstacle to sensible. harmonious industrial relations where bosses and workers can cooperate with each other on an individual basis rather than collectively. I wonder if Eric Hammond was watching?

Scan page 10

YEAR OF REVOLUTION From centre pages Monday 4 September. A mass meeting in Petrograd of 800 delegates representing 20,000 workers calls for transfer of all power to the representatives of revolutionary workers, soldiers and peasants. The provisional Government orders the dissolution of local organs of struggle against the Kornilov mutiny on the grounds that they have lost their significance. A joint meeting of the Executive Committee of the Moscow soviets of workers' deputies and of soldiers' deputies sets up a central staff as the leading organ of the Red Guards. A meeting of the crew of the Republican" cruiser in the Black Sea fleet demands the arrest of the leading counter-revolutionaries and the shutting. down of counter-revolutionary organisations and papers. In Ekaterinburg leaflets produced by the "Urals Union of Kornilovists", appealing for support for Kornilov are stuck up around the town. In the elections for the Executive Committee of the Krasnoyarsk Soviet, the Bolshevik slate wins a majority of votes. The Tashkent Soviet demands withdrawal off Kerensky decree of 1 September. Tuesday 5 September. Mensheviks and Social- Revolutionaries vote down a Bolshevik resolution at the Executive Committee of the Petrograd Soviet advocating fresh elections for the Executive Committee. An inter-regional conference of Petrograd Soviets resolves to ignore Kerensky's decree of September, and calls for fresh elections for the Petrograd Soviet Executive Committee. The Vyborg regional soviet (Petrograd) condemns Kerensky's decree of 1 September.The Bolshevik "Workers' Path" newspaper publishes a list of the 17 workers' papers shut down by the Provisional Government between 5 July and 5 September. Meetings of the Soviets of Revel, Rostov and Kostroma endorse the Bolshevik resolution on state power adopted by the Petrograd Soviet on 31 August. The Taganrog Soviet votes down a simlar resolution. The central staff of Moscow Red Guards resolves to campaign for the donation of a day's pay from Moscow workers to finance the Red Guards. In Penza and Saratoy workers' militias are set up.

Wednesday 6 September. The Kronstadt Soviet approves the recruitment of women to the local Red Guards and orders special instructors to teach them the use of firearms.

The Moscow committee of struggle with counter-revolution, set up to combat Kornilov, resolves to dissolve itself. The Klin district soviet passes a resolution calling for all power to the Soviets; a mass meeting of 11,000 workers of the Sobinsky factory demands transference of all Voznesensk Soviet condemns the concilia- DOWer the SOVICLS The Ivanovotionist policies of the Central Executive Committee of Soviets, and criticises its convening of a "Democratic Conference" rather than a congress of Soviets In Egorevsk the Revolutionary Direc tory set up at the time of the Kornilov hope and confidence.

That in turn requires us to conduct ourselves in a way that will help to build solidarity around the popular struggles that take place, and unity around the policies we. advocate. splinter group politics cannot be the basis for advance, even though we must treat with respect the ideas of all socialists, and vigorously oppose ideological expulsions. We aim, therefore, at Chesterfield, to make a ment, the peace movement, the blac community, the greens and others about their methods of working and about their own successes and. failures.

It is certainly not our intention to

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 327

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →