The left.o
Socialist Organiser1987 1987-09-03Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 10 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 10
Hi The Zionist historian David Cesarani wröte, in the 'Jewish Chronicle on 3 July:
Was it worth all the fuss? Had the play gone on, it would have been seen by around 2000 people.. and then disappeared"
The whole issue is only one example of the general case made in Socialist Organiser. It was perfectly right and necessary to respond to "Perdition'. Leaflets, pickets, and so on, would have been perfectly in order. The fatal error lay in allowing the matter to appear as a question of free speech The affair is not finished. It seems. that there may be attempts to stage it or hold 'readings' at certain colleges. It is still possible to learn the lessons of the business so far.
There are two main arguments put forward as to why Jews should campaign to ban such performances.
• To let it be staged or read peacefully, with its poisonous message, will generate so much hassle for Jewish students — especially those who do not know what time of the political day it is — and create such an atmosphere of witch-hunting 'anti-Zionism' (where do you stand on Zionism?"), that it would be better to try to get it banned.
Not so. There will probably be anti-Zionist' witch-hunting anyway, once a group of students decides to stage or read the play. To try to ban it is to give them the banner of free speech. It will give them the support of waverers, and deflect attention from the arguments and issues.
David Cesarani made this point in the 'Jewish Chronicle' . "Attempts by journalists and historians to expose the play were caught up in a political dogfight: calm, objective criticism was inexorably turned into polemic."
Educate It is far better, if hassle is unavoidable, to fight on the issues by way of leatlets, counter-meetings, and pıckets — without appearing as suppressors and enemies of free speech and democracy.
Arguing and debating the issues will politically educate and inoculate thinking students, and will therefore be a better defence, and a less costly one, than a ban.
• The issue can be neatly and efficiently dealt with by a majority vote at a student union General Meeting to ban the play.
It simply isn't true. The 'minority" will be able to deflect attention from the content of 'Perdition' to the issue of free speech. This general approach, anyway, leads to the ludicrous spectacle of tit-for-tat bannings, according to whoever, even accidentally, has the majority. Each college has its own 'majority dietatorship' Free speech and argument, and vigorous protest where necessary, are far better.
Free speech is important for itself. And in this case defence of free speech is also the best way to deal with those who abuse it to promote Judaeophobic demonology. Effective use of free speech is the best reply to them.