Why "banning' is f
Socialist Organiser1987 1987-09-03Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 10 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 10
Socialist Organiser no.326.3 'September 1987 Page 10 DAST YEAR Socialist Organiser carried a discussion piece and correspondence about the question of free speech in student unions. We discussed how the left should handle those with whom we profoundly disagree.
Now the results of the campaign against Jim Allen's play 'Perdition' - a play which, in our view, is obnoxious propaganda - allows us a valuable chance to test our ideas. We think those results prove us right. The supporters of 'Perdition' have gained from being able to present themselves as the target of a 'ban', and their critics as opponents of free speech.
Last year we argued that on principle socialists must support free speech - and that in practice this means free speech for those with whom we profoundly disagree, or even those whom we detest.
We advocated counter-propaganda leaflets, mass pickets of odious gatherings, and so on, rather than blanket bans and proscriptions by student union authorities, for exam-l ple, or Labour-controlled councils.
Principle
Free speech is a matter of principle though there are other principles, like the principle that you do not let racists terrorise their targets. But we argued for our approach on tactical grounds too.
An attempt to ban anyone puts many who may detest the target of the ban on their side because they want to *defend free speech and democracy'. Timid supporters of the target of the ban can be encouraged to rally to them under the banner of free speech.
It is stupid - and doubly so in the political climate in Britain today -for the left to give the banner of democracy and free speech to our opponents.
One of the biggest anti-fascist rallies ever was organised by the Trotskyists of New York in 1939. It was not mobilised under the banner of 'no free speech for fascists', but under the banner of protesting against the fascists and defending their targeted victims, the Jews, the labour movement, and so on. It stopped a planned fascist rally from going ahead: and that shows that you do not have to brand yourself as an opponent of free speech and democracy in order to curb fascists' ability to What about 'Perdition"? In this play Jim Allen set out, to quote his own words, to deliver *the most lethal attack on Zionism ever written, because it touches at the heart of the most abiding myth of modern history, the Holocaust. [The play] says quite plainly that privileged Jewish leaders collaborated in the extermination of their own kind in order to help bring about a Zionist state, Israel, a state which is itself racist" J Allen's drama focuses on events in Hungary in 1944. His play takes the form of a libel hearing in a case brought by a former leader of Jane: Ashworata and. John O Mahony-look atthe rights and wrongs of the attempts-p stop Jim Allen: sipran about. Zionism.
'Peration, being pertormed Hungary's Jews against someone who has accused him of collaborating with the Nazis in the extermination of; his own people. "The Zionists' helped the Nazis kill six million Jews because that would help prepare the moral and political climate for setting up the state of Israel.
Allen's real concern here is not history but present-day Middle East politics — the attitude that socialists should take to the Arab-Jewish conflict in the Middle East and in the general debates about Zionism and Arab nationalism which grow out of that conflict.
Allen bases himself on the work of Lenni Brenner. Their message is this: Some of the victims of the Nazi race murder 'the Zionists' shared responsibility SOT attempted genocide, and therefore Israel, constructed by Zionists, does not have the right to exist. Zionism was always the central enemy not only of others, That is no small allegation! But neither Allen nor Brenner come any wnele near makig a senous or coherent case for it. It is a readingbackwards of today's commonplace demonisation of Israel on to the entire modern history of the Jews, and an attempt to smear israe with some of the responsibility for the blood of • • 86 0000-9-10 end all blood-libels!
COr Allen, like his source of wisdom Brenner, 'history' is just a quarry in which to mine material to back up a pre-conceived and one-sided polemic.
The play - like Brenner's work, but more crudely effectively said of Hitler's victims: "It was their Taul, or al least ine Taul or uneir leaders. And, look, the Zionists (this time the entire Israeli Jewish nation not only the Zionist leaders) are still pursuing the perverse racist doctrine which helped Nazi catastrophe down on their heads.
This can only be brought to a proper end if they consent to dissolve the Israeli Jewish nation or, failing that, they are overwhelmed".
In Brenner's historical writings, the trick is to blame the Zionist movement - presented as some sort of diabolical power outside the ordinary Jewish people TOL the Holocaust as if 'the Zionists' in Europe did not go to the death camps too. The argument ranges from the possibly reasonable point that if the Zionist movement had devoted all its energies to opening the doors of the USA, then that might have made a difference, all the way to the libellous nonsense that 'the Zionists' would rather have the European Jews dead than have them go anywhere but Palestine.
The Brenner-Allen school of thought is a left-wing part of a general movement known as Holocaust revisionism'. The rightwingers of this movement - who are often outright fascists - say that the Jews were not massacred in Hitler's death factories at all. The whole story is an exercise in 'Zionist' propaganda.
The 'blame-the-Zionists' revisionists say: yes, the Jews did die, but they died partly because of the machinations of their leaders whose successors now rule Israel. A candid anti-semite, indifferent to the massacre, might say: the Jews got what they deserved. The left 'antiZionists' say: they got what the leaders decreed, or at least connived at. The different versions are, of course, not identical, least of all in their motives: but the parallel exists independently of anyone's good intentions.
On the left, Zionist complicity in the Holocaust is now increasingly an article of faith in a movement which has adopted an attitude of comprehensive hostility to Jews, in Israel and outside it, who will not 'convert' to anti-Zionism and adopt the demand that Israel cease to exist.
The memory of Hitler's massacre of the Jews acted for a long time as a bulwark against anti-semitism, forcing it underground. Even today, in most circles, it dare not bear its own name. It disguises itself.
The attempt to put part of the blame for the Holocaust on Jews does more than attempt to discredit Israel and to buttress the Arab chauvinist case that Israel has no right to exist in any form. It breaks down that bulwark completely.
Ferment
Allen's play, like Brenner's books and the often hysterical anti-Zionist agitation of organisations like the SWP, is part of a cultural ferment which is generating a new 'left-wing' anti-semitism. That is not what they want or intend, but that is how things stand.
The left-wing Zionophobes of today may well be playing the same role in that ferment that 'socialist' antisemitism played at the turn of the century in the creation of the lethal racist anti-semitist that led to the slaughter of six million human beings.
So those Jews who were outraged had a right to be outraged. The version of the play due to go on stage at the Royal Court Theatre in January contained extremely crude denunciation of both Zionists and Jews.
This is a grievous matter. And for that reason it is a good test of the principles and the practicalities how such issues should be handled.
The play wasn't "banned'. The Royal Court just decided not to stage it. Nevertheless, a skilful campaign, backed by the left, presented the matter as if it had been banned.
The image was conjured up by the play's advocates of an immensely powerful 'Zionist' conspiracy against 'Perdition'. All subsequent difficulties experienced by the author and director in finding an alternative theatre were presented as proof positive of this conspiracy — and certainly some of the difficulties were in fact the result of the outcry, and probably of private lobbying.
Seven months after the outcry began, what is the result for the opponents of 'Perdition'?
Notoriety
A play which might have attracted routine reviews in the national press and the attendance of a few thousand people has been drawn to the attention of hundreds of thousands. It has been given an immense notoriety. It has been given the glamour of martyrdom as 'the banned play" (even the BBC described it thus), and bathed in the sympathetic light of defence of free speech and artistic freedom.
Anti-semites — including those too timid to come out openly - have been given an issue to focus on. A Jewish gravestone has been daubed with their new rallying cry: 'Perdition', A (drastically rewritten) version of the play in book form has been assured of a very big audience. It has been read to a capacity audience at the Edinburgh Festival. The play will have a big audience when it is produced, as it will be.
Most ironic of all, perhaps, is the fact that 'Perdition' is a far better play in its published (fourth) version than it was at the beginning - and that is because of the outcry.
The original version was full of crudities (**Zionist knife in the Nazi fist" , sneering comments about "the chosen people" etc.) which would have alerted people averagely concerned with this matter to the hostile propaganda that is the play's content. These have been cut.
True, the large number of changes amounts to a tacit admission by Allen that much that his critics said was true. You cannot nail your colours to the mast, as Allen did in his declaration that the play was "the most lethal attack on Zionism ever written", , and then make changes under pressure as he has done, without totally destroying the moral and factual basis of your own case. But to be aware of that you need to compare the texts.
The upshot of the whole campaign has been to make "Perdition' more effective as Zionophobic propaganda, give it an immense boost it would not have had otherwise, give courage to timid anti-semites to rally to 'Perdition' "in defence of free speech" , and to brand the Jews as intolerent, conspiratorial, and immensely powertul.
Is there any greater example of a campaign so helping its target and wounding the campaigners?