Miners retreat to fight another da
Socialist Organiser1987 1987-09-03Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 5 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 5
Preparing for future battles: Photo: IDAF/Renort Socialist Organiser no.326 3 September 1987 Page 5 The miners' strike in South Africa ended this Sunday (30th) with the NUM ordering its members back to work and accepting a small increase in fringe benefits. The mine bosses made no concessions on the central issue of wages and have not guaranteed all the strikers their jobs back.
Anne Mack looks at the outcome.
For three weeks some 320,000 black miners held out. It was the greatest strike in South African history. But in the end the miners were defeated.
They faced terrible odds. They had to do battle with the guns, tear gas and armoured cars of the police and mine security. The miners had only sticks, spears, pangas and machetes.
And the mine bosses had an even greater weapon than brute force the threat of mass sackings. Though the strike was legal, so too were the mass sackings carried out by the Chamber of Mines, In the last few days of the strike Anglo American — the largest mining house in the dispute - threatened to sack some 44,000 miners.
The sackings, and the big recruitment of scabs in South Africa's "homelands" and in the neighbouring black state of Lesotho, placed tremendous pressure on the strikers.
Yet thousands of miners were still prepared to face unemployment, poverty and hunger in the rural areas rather than break the strike.
Mass sackings late last week turned the tide against the NUM.
Earlier in the week the Chamber of Mines had been forced to negotiate with the NUM. But after the strikers rejected the Chamber's offer, the mine bosses quickly switched to a more aggressive stance.
The strike was not helped by the fact that during the second week of battle the NUM was unable to pull out the majority of the 75,000 miners working for Gold Fields of South Africa.
That halted the NUM's plan to gradually increase the number of miners out on strike, and meant that some of the country's richest mines had not been hit.
The NUM had to fight alone. Though small groups of workers like the building union CAWU promised to black all work on the mines for the duration of the dispute, there was never full scale solidarity action from COSATU, the giant black union federation.
Organising solidarity for the miners was no simple task.
Isolated groups of workers on the docks or the railways risked having their action declared illegal and the force of the state deployed against them if they took action such as a boycott of coal and gold shipments.
Isolation could have been avoided by a general strike. But that had problems, too. It could quickly catapult the workers' movement into an all-out, all-or-nothing conflict with the power of the state.
The balance of forces was not favourable for such a revolutionary showdown. The South African state has an almost complete and un -challenged monopoly of the means of violence, and few political restraints on using it.
In South Africa today, no general strike can be called lightly or without serious preparation including military preparation.
But if piecemeal solidarity was difficult, and a full general strike premature, what was the alternative? Could the miners hope to win on their own, simply through their economic pressure on the mine bosses' profits?
The dispute became a test of strength between the Chamber of Mines and the NUM. But the Chamber had a number of cards -mass sackings, large-scale scabherding and further state interventior - up its sleeve. The NUM had nc further cards to play - especially after it had failed at Gold Fields of The only way the miners could have given themselves more cards to play was by campaigning to make preparation for solidarity action -up to and including a general strike - part of the preparation for their strike.
In the circumstances the NUM found itself in towards the end of last week, the union leadership was right to call off the action with the union intact rather than risk "a painful process of disintegration"
But it would be wrong to draw the lesson that the unions should avoid all big confrontations and, for the indefinite future, | stick to cautious small-scale action. The state will not allow the unions to build up strength gradually and peacefully for ever. Unless the unions prepare and organise for decisive battles now, when the ruling class is still in some disarray, they could find all their hard-won gains wiped away by repression.
It is possible to draw the conclusion from this defeat that the miners fought at the wrong time. The NUM leadership should have tried to postpone the battle for a few more years until more miners were organised and the union stronger.
But workers' struggles cannot be planned with the precision of a military campaign. The spontaneous, burning militancy of the miners drove towards confrontation.
Workers' Liberty magazine wrote five months ago:
*Neither the NUM nor the Chamber of Mines have yet squared up for an all-out confrontation.
To a certain extent such a confrontation would not be in the interests of the NUM or the mine bosses. Anglo American, for instance, is anxious to maintain its 'liberal' and "antiapartheid' image, while the NUM has built itself through sectional, guerrilla action, utilising at times the already existing tribal/communal structures in the compound.
This pattern can't go on forever.
No matter how cautious the NUM leadership is, it is difficult to see how, at a certain point, it will be able to avoid a full scale confrontation, spurred by the appalling conditions that mineworkers face.
In order to face such a confrontation the NUM will have to learn the lessons of the major defeat of the African Mineworkers' Union in 1946.
And the central lesson is that an all-out confrontation in the mines poses, at least implicitly, the question of who rules South Africa. The NUM has to prepare for such a confrontation."
In a few years' time the general political climate may be less rather than more favourable to the unions.
The miners could have won a limited economic victory this time, though the odds were weighted against them. They certainly had the Chamber of Mines very surprised and worried.
If the union leaders had continued to postpone a battle with the Chamber, it could well have undermined the confidence of rank and file mendez24B nigra bowleen ship and Chamber of Mines. The - 00-11 wages, but offers to double death benefit from two to four years-pay pampe 01.0 leave.
600 miners gather in the centre of Johannesburg outside the Chamber of Mines bulding chating "We demand 30%" and with the "Away Chamber of Mines'.
Ultimatums to the miners to give up the strike continue. Anglo American give another 10,300 miners one day to give up or face the sack.
180 workers at Anglo's head office go on strike demanding the right to leave the company's staff association and join the NUM.
Anglo claim that significant numbers of miners are returning to work.
Wednesday 26 August NUM strike committees meet and vote to reject the Chamber's offer despite the fact that union leadership made no recommendation for against the offer.
NUM general Cyril secretary admits tha negotiations, the union leadership "modified" the original demand for 30% across-the-board wage increase. According to the Gurdian, the NUM leadership put forward the figure of 27% during the negotiaDOnS TS CHEC that Ramaphosa in fact favoured a settlement on Tuesday and had been overruled by other members of the NUM -Africa's omies sotte muders. IS -10 include a boycott of all work related to the ming industry. Cyril mayosa hits at the pessibility-of queeral strike. Hanga is detainedas he arrives home amibian atiners* leader er a visit to Britain toraise suppert + striking Namibian miners.
ale admit that weekers who ta Lirned to work on Tuesday wa ex-track out on strike artwo of the arpany's shaûs.
Thursday 27 August Anglo American announce they are sacking 20,000 more miners. GENOk also--wonace then they we sacking 20,000.
In response -000 miners Western meets stage a sia underground after mine security try to drive them back to work at gunDOLE.
Her of ties swimme wishes for mess saudings Me Tocitient of that the mine owners are "bent on destroying Place oded state"
that te strike is costing the mine bosses E10 million a s-says that