Assembly is a diversion
Socialist Organiser1987 1987-09-03Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 4 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 4
In the aftermath of the General Election, the question of a Scot- The psychology and politics behind tish Assembly has now become a the call for an Assembly is not one of preparing for all-out battle with the major issue in the labour moveTories, but one of cutting and runnment in Scotland. In recent issues of Socialist Organiser lan Mc- Not "fight for an Assembly so as Calman has argued that we to better organise an all-out fight with the Tories" but "fight for an should support the call for an Assembly, to avoid an all-out fight Assembly. I think he is wrong.
There is no class-struggle case for The most left-wing argument for an Assembly — and no valid naan assembly is that it will provide a "pole of opposition" to the Tories"
I have no briet for existing attacks on the Scottish working class. capitalist borders. But Scotland is not But the Tories have got the same at- an "oppressed nation" (or even a natacks in store for all other workers as tion) in any meaningful, Marxist sense. There is nothing progressive in There will be no shortage of *poles the Scottish labour movement hived of opposition" to the Tories' attacks off from the overall British class in the period ahead — the poll tax; enforced council rent rises; conscrip- The idea of devolved government throughout Britain may arguably Either socialists are able to develop have some merits, but the isolated desuch potential poles of opposition in- mand for a Scottish Assembly to real ones - in which case, an panders to Scottish nationalism and Assembly won't help. Or the leaders is more of a diversion from than a of the Scottish Labour Party and route to working class struggle Scottish TUC will succeed in betraying the struggles — in which case they would also make sure that a Scottish of this year. Top officials. admit that workers living standards are falling. tion onto YTS; anti-union laws.. ing. struggle. Assembly led no struggles. with the Tories"
tonalist case either: against the Tories.
alleviate. only get that by changing society.
GERRY GILBERT, CAMDEN Send letters to Socialist CASEY, Organi ser PO Box 823, London SE15 Glasgow