Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Women workers' muscle

Socialist Organiser no. 325, 27 August 1987 · scan pp. 10–11 · about 1,896 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 10 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 10

YEAR OF REVOLUTION From page 8 resolution. By a majority off two votes the Kiev Soviet adopts a SocialRevolutionary-Menshevik resolution. By a majority of two votes the Kiev Soviet adopts a Social Revolutionary-Menshevik resolution on the conference. A general meeting of soldiers of the 2nd Reserve Infantry regiment in Petrograd supports Finland's right to self-determination and condemns the Provisional Government's intention of shutting down the Finnish Parliament. An extraordinary meeting of the Camara Soviet drops proposals to call a demonstration in opposition to the Moscow State Conference.

The Elabuzhsky district commissioner appeals to the provincial commissioner to send troops to put down the peasant movement. The Moyovilikh Soviet condemns the Moscow State conference and the Provisional Government's repression of socialist tendencies. The Presidium of the Belorets Soviet condemns as illegal a strike by workers in the local iron and steel works, and demands an immediate return to work.

Tuesday 15 August The Central Committee of the Bolsheviks issues an appeal in connection with the Moscow State Conference calling for disregard of rumour-mongering and refusal to react to provocations, and for no demonstrations unless sanctioned by the Bolshevik Central Committee. The Petrograd Bolshevik paper "Proletarian' commences agitation for the Petrograd Duma elections of 20 August.

The Helsingfors Soviet passes a resolution opposing any attempt to dissolve the Finnish parliament. Officers on the Western front are instructed to confiscate and destroy all copies of the socialist paper Trenches Tocsin". A mass meeting of 4,500 workers of the Kharkov General Electricity Company demands dissolution of the Moscow State Conference. Workers, soldiers and peasants demonstrate in Poltava, and demand dissolution of the Moscow State Conference at the concluding rally. A 3,000 strong soldiers' meeting in Samara condemns the Moscow State Conference.

Wednesday 16 August The Executive Commission of the Bolshevik Petrograd Committee appeals to all members to step up activity in preparation for the forthcoming elections to the city Duma. The Bolshevik Central Committee issues a leaflet appealing to soldiers to vote for Bolshevik candidates in the Petrograd Duma elections: "We shall fight for the defeat of the bourgeois counter-revolution and for the transference of all power into the hands of the worker and peasant poor".

The Vasileostrovsky regional soviet (Petrograd) condemns the Moscow State Conference and any dissolution of the Finnish Parliament. The Kronstadt Soviet passes a resolution of protest against the Moscow State Conference. The Druzhkov Soviet expresses its opposition to the Moscow State Conference and calls for an end to the war.

110,000 leatherworkers in Moscow and surrounding districts go on strike for a minimum wage, two weeks holiday per year, and workers" control over sackings. The Mogilev soviet demands immediate abolition of the death penalty at the front.. Thursday 17 August The Bolsheviks Petrograd committee publishes three leaflets, each with a printrun of 100,000 directed at soldiers, women and citizens in general, appealing for support in the forthcoming Duma elections.

In the Vendensky Duma elections the Bolsheviks win 14 seats, the Social Revolutionaries 12, and the radicals and national-democrats 5. The Executive Committee of the Kiev Soviet of Workers' Deputies sets up a committee for defence of the revolution, with representatives from the Soviet of Soldiers' Deputies and the Ukrainian Central Council. At an extraordinary meeting of the Yaroslavl Soviet the Bolsheviks call for the establishment of Red Guards to combat counter-revolutionary activities.

The Executive Committee of the Manglisi garrison soviet confiscates copies of the Bolshevik newspaper *Caucasian Worker". The Stavropol provincial governor requests the despatch of 350 soldiers and 150 Cossacks to crush peasant unrest.

Socialist Organiser no.325 During the Second World War women entered industrial jobs in the US at a rate never seen before. But as SUE HILL explains in this second part of an article begun last week, the unions wer tied by outdated sexis ideas, and after the war women had to fight to hold on to what rights they had won.

Within the trade union movement the initial reaction to new women workers, particuarly those in traditionally male jobs, was one of hostility and resistance. A large number of union branches made unsuc= cessful attempts to exclude women.

The influx of women into the large industrial unions did however lead the labour movement as a whole to an increasing concern with the problems of women workers. The left wing unions were the most responsive.

Positive

Ohe third of the United Electrical, Radio and Machine Workers organising staff were women. But that was atypical. It was the United Auto Workers which tackled the sexual discrimination most vigorously. It had a quite successful equal pay policy; it sought to end separate seniority lists for men and women; and it drew up a model maternity clause for its contract negotiations.

One of the most positive aspects of organised labour's relationship to women workers was the movement's support for equal pay. State and Federal governments had taken up the issue in a limited way. The trade union movement had at first been mainly concerned to maintain male rates of pay in the face of the influx of women. They weren't bothered about women's right to equal payBefore Pearl Harbour and the stepping up of war production, the UA W had even tried to exclude women from male jobs, to maintain rates of pay. After Pearl Harbour, the UAW demanded from General Motors "equal pay for comparable quantity and quality of work' . Naturally the greatest advances were made where women took over male jobs because the men did not want low paid competitors for their jobs and thus the interests of male and female trade unionists converged.

Some war industry capitalists had endorsed the principle, their resistance undercut by the financial security given them by government cost-plus contracts which guaranteed profit. Their security was increased also by the small effect such government rulings had in practice, since sex-based job classifications went unchallenged, and women were rarely found working on the same job as a man at the same time. In practice they could thus support the principle of equal pay, without having to pay men and women equally.

Face up

Because the trade union movement did not really face up to the problems created for the existing equal pay policy, of the sex-based jobclassification system, women carried on earning less than men even in the new industrial jobs. Some unions even allowed jobs to be reclassified to 27 August 1987 Page More power to her elbow stop women receiving the same rate of pay as the men who had done the same job before.

While the trade unions did not challenge the entire structure of job segregation, women could only benefit from equal pay policies where their immediate interests coincided with those of the men. The trade unions failed to take the issue of women's pay beyond the parameters of the government's guidelines.

Women also lost out in seniority arrangements. Some union contracts operated separate lists for men and women employees, others limited the seniority privileges of women -especially married women - to the duration of the war. In others, seniority was applied only to traditional women's jobs after the war. So women who had transferred to "men's jobs" during the war gained seniority only on their old jobs.

Such a lack of commitment to women's seniority indicated that the unions were committed to women members only for the duration of the war.

Where women's seniority rights were violated openly — such as where one General Motors plant put all its women workers on the midnight shift - women were inadequately supported by their union. The labour movement turned its undivided attention to the problems of inflation, strikes, internal struggles and impending anti-labour legislation.

Because working class women were not in a position to mobilise, the trade union movement ignored their grievances. The best channel for unifying working class women's interests would have been through the organised labour movement, that is the industrial unions. But tragically it was a movement still inherently sexist and racist although the basis of industrial unionism had supposedly been to organise all the unorganised.

The majority of women workers at the end of the war wanted to keep their jobs. But women were disproportionately targeted in the lay offs. A month after the end of the war 600,000 women had been laid off. Women were laid off at a rate 75% higher than men. Revealingly, the highest voluntary quit rate for women was in the traditional female sector of the labour force. The women in the higher paying "men's! jobs" wanted to keep their jobs.

Women workers in the Detroit area actively disputed their exclusion from the post-war auto labour force. They picketed both plant employment offices and the headquarters of the UAW, in a partly successful protest. The women emphasised that the violations of women's seniority threatened the whole basis of the seniority principle for all workerswho were then coming under attack as the bosses, now that the war was over, made a big drive to take back advances won by the workers.

Recognition

But despite some national recognition of the legitimacy of the protests, discrimination against women in lay offs continued. It was management which attacked the women workers, but the UAW's dilatory response indicated that the Union did not seriously consider fighting the sexual stratification of the workforce.

With the reconversion of industry to peacetime production, the new workers taken on were overwhelmingly men. Industry wide, most of the laid off women were able to find jobs, but only after a period of unemployment had persuaded them to accept lower paid jobs. Women's average earnings dropped as they moved back into traditionally female jobs in light industry, land into work!

the clerical and service sectors.

The war period had presented an opportunity to challenge the sexual division of labour. But for a challenge to have been organised a greater class consciousness would have been needed in the labour movement. Organised labour would have had to take on board the concerns of the specially oppressed women and be prepared to fight on them.

The issue should not have centred divisively on men's or women's rights to jobs (or as it came to be seen, women's right to jobs versus the right to work of the veterans returning from the war), but on the right of all workers, women and men, to jobs in a full-employment economy When laid off, women went to the United States Employment Service seeking similar industrial jobs to their wartime positions. But women had never been considered permanent workers in the new industries they had entered.

So these women were often denied unemployment benefit because they were said to be limiting their employability by seeking unsuitable employment! Theoretically, claimants had the right to refuse jobs outside their previous occupational classification, but officials had definite preconceptions about what was 'women's work' , and decided accordingly.

With the onset of the 1950s a positive public image of women workers was lost once again - to society in general and to women themselves too. The working class women who had been employed before the war and still could not indulge themselves in the 'pleasures' of domesticity were once again faced with only the option of low pay. Such women were joined by increasing numbers of married women taking jobs in the burgeoning service and clerical sectors.

Scan page 11

Industrialu SE HEUGA ly good

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 325

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →