Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

[DAF) tion of the black working class -permanent…]

Socialist Organiser no. 325, 27 August 1987 · scan p. 7 · about 1,272 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 7 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 7

DAF) tion of the black working class -permanent urban workers - known as "section tenners"

The aim was to create a buffer between the majority of blacks and the whites, a relatively privileged layer separated off from the mass of black workers.

One leading mineowner has since described the Weihahn reforms as "letting the genie out of the bottle"!

In a sense he is right. The unions utilised the state's reform programme to create a space for working class organisation.

At first the union movement was far from unanimous about how exactly to respond. This debate came to a head over the issue of state "recognition" , i.e.registration of black unions.

The more 'orthodox' trade unionists like the Council of Unions of South Africa (CUSA), which was aligned to the Black Consciousness movement, welcomed the state's proposals with few reservations and sought registration roughly on terms laid down by the state.

The General Workers Union (GWU) which was strong on the docks, argued that registration would mean the kiss of death for independent and democratic trade unionism and called for a boycott of any official machinery of state recognition of the unions.

The more nationalist trade unionists (like those in the South African Allied Workers Union -SAAWU) also rejected what they regarded as a recognition of apartheid and made an alliance with the syndicalists on a boycott platform.

The Federation of South African Trade Unions (FOSATU), which had Austrial umans in ta a test came nearer to a working class political perspective. They argued that new restrictions which registration threatened against independent unions — like a ban on the registration of multi-racial unions or unions which include migrant workers - should be boycotted; old restrictions on trade unionism to which registration makes no or little difference — like restrictions on strike and political affiliations - should continue to be fought against; and that new rights afforded by registration should be exploited by the independent unions vantage by the unions.

In practice this meant that FOSATU unions applied for registration on their own terms; that is, as non-racial unions comprising categories of workers. It also meant that FOSATU maintained their comworkers.

This strategy met with considerable success. The government gave in on the question of banning "mixed' unions and migrant workers from registration. Registration allowed the unions to side-step management excuses about refusing to recognise non-registered unions.

At the same time registration de facto did not subject the unions - • as some of the boycotters feared - to levels of control by the staté which would stop them being militant and The use of flexible and realistic tactics by FOSATU showed that most of the moralistic, middle class talk of "non-collaboration" with the apartheid state and its machinery of domination over black people represented a blind alley. It certainly wasn't a serious option for building a workers' movement.

Non-collaboration" for the trade union movement was as ridiculous as the idea that because socialists are against capitalism and the wages system we should not fight for higher wages.

The unions grew steadily in the early 1980s. There were strike waves in the car and metal industries in 1981-2. At the end of 1982 CUSA formed a miners' union (NUM) and appointed a lawyer, Cyril Ramaphosa, as its secretary.

The unions consolidated their position by fighting for small but winnable demands, often around issues like wages, hours, union recognition or maternity rights. Over time a considerable base of working class organisation was created.

The unions and politics The black townships exploded in the autumn of 1984. A nationwide urban revolt quickly developed. Initial issues like rents, racist education, and police brutality were soon subsumed into an all-out assault on apartheid. Township youth - the "comrades" - really believed that the state was about to suffer a gigantic loss of will, Mandela would be released and apartheid's days were numbered. This perspective was summed up in the Slogan of the school boycotters: *No education before liberation!"

In November 1984, black trade unions joined with student, youth and community groups in the Transvaal to call a two-day stayaway. Up to 800,000 workers parucipated. Moses Mayekiso, a trade unionist and socialist who now faces trial for his life in South Africa, was one of the stayaway organisers.

The unions were now drawn into politics all the way. This intensified the debate inside the unions between the so-called "populists" and "workerists"

The "populists" identify with the nationalist political tradition of the banned African National Congress (ANC), represented inside South Africa by the semi-clandestine and just legal United Democratic Front UDF) they tended to favour high profile political campaigning to build general community-based unions. They advocate a multi-class alliance of all forces opposed to apartheid.

The "workerists", though committed to the wider struggle against apartheid do not favour alliances with non-worker controlled groups in which the independent voice of the

Mother Loc.er

MAYEKISO

Workers strike for the release of jailed tradeunionist Moses Mayekiso. (Photo: IDAF), workers may be submerged. They stress the need for patient organising, educating and building. on the shopfloor.

In 1984-5 this debate was seen as a debate between different unions and union federations. Basically between those unions which were affiliated to the UDF and those which were not.

However, after the formation of the Congress of South African Trade Unions (COSATU) at the end of November 1985 this conflict has continued, though in a muted and less direct form inside COSATU.

COSATU adopted the organisafional methods - industrial unions, shop stewards structures etc - of the old FOSATU "workerist" unions. Its political policy was less clear cut.

Since early 1986 the COSATU leadership has gradually drawn the federation closer and closer to the "populist' ANC tradition. At its recent congress in July this year COSATU adopted the ANC's Freedom Charter - the banned movement's programme for post-apartheid South Africa.

In fact, as the township struggle has declined - as a result of state repression and popular exhaustion as it became evident that the state was not about to give up — more and more the trade unions have moved to the centre of the struggle. A massive strike wave has developed - in part as a response to employers' attacks, in part spurred on by other workers' victories - to create a situation where the unions are now the main, legal, open form of opposition to the apartheid regime.

COSATU has now clearly overtaken the UDF as the main opposition force to the government. It is now perceived as standing firmly in the Congress tradition.

Yet at the same time the development of COSATU has decisively discredited the old strategy of the ANC according to which South Africa was a fascist dicatorship and change could only come about through external pressure, from the guerrilla war or international sanctions.

The gravediggers of South African capitalism had risen up.

What is needed now is a clear socialist strategy to lead forward the mighty movement of the South African workers.

This lead can't and won't come from the ANC which is committed to an alliance with "patriotic" anti-apartheid bosses, including the mine It will have to come from those in the unions and elsewhere who are committed to a socialist future for A regroupment of working class forces is necessary to fight for this goal.

The populists are organised and determined to swing COSATU 100% behind the ANC line. The left in the unions and outside need to get organised.

----- pull-quotes -----

and, whatever the intentions of the government, could be turned to ad-

mitment to fight for unrestricted rights of free association for black

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 325

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →