If this is Trotskyism, then
Socialist Organiser1987 1987-08-27Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 3 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 3
work!
*Factories shut down by their owners to be taken into public ownership without compensation and run under workers' control.
*A programme of public works, under workers' control and at trade union rates of pay.
Within this framework a workers fight for jobs for all without discrimination is possible. This is better than appealing to multinationals.
and the British state to give more favour to Catholics - an approach which, with unemployment already very high even among Protestants, is likely to make communal tension worse and class politics more difdon SLATE 4NA 17960 Tear re post Monday or by phone, Monday evening Editor: John O'Mahony Typesetting: Upstream (TU)
Published by Socialist Organiser, PO Box 823, London SE15 4NA.
Printed by East End Offset (TU), London E2.
Registered as a newspaper at the Post Office.
Signed articles do not necessarily reflect the view of Times to the Morning Star, carried mocking articles about the meetings held in London by different fragments of the "Workers' Revolutionary Party" to commemorate Leon Trotsky on the 47th anniversary of his death under the ice-pick of Stalin's assassin, Mercader.
*Marks and sparks at the start of a new party" headlined the FT in its light relief" report on page one. WRP splits three ways to mark Trotsky's end" chortled the Stalinoid Morning Star.
The humour was weak and feeble, to be sure. But there was no mistaking the common basic feeling of triumph from their different angles, that Trotskyism had been reduced to a joke.!
Now the declining Morning Star is itself the result of a recent split in the Communist Party. It depends for its survival in part on the practical support of the heirs of Trotsky's murderer - over one-third of its small sale is to Eastern Europe and the USSR. It is easy enough to jeer back at them.
Yet the stark truth is that it is impossible not to concede that they, and all the others who stopped to Gerry Healy: giving Trotskyism a bad name jeer, have a point. Not about "Trotskyism" as Trotsky would have understood it and as it should be understood - but about the vast range of sects calling themselves Trotskyist.
The "new party" referred to by the Financial Times is the Marxist Party" which has just been launched by Gerry Healy (75 going on 6) and Vanessa and Corin Redgrave. It's a silly little personality cult around an old scoundrel.
The truth, of course, is that in the 47 years since Trotsky's death, almost everything weird and wonderful in politics and on its fringes -- including varieties of Stalinism - has been absorbed or annexed by people who want, for various reasons - in Healy's case for personal pride and perhaps sentimentality - to call themselves Trotskyists.
The mere name has ceased to have any precise meaning - except as a historic reference point.
A whole wide range of vastly different politics has been evolved by people more or less honestly trying to base. themselves on the politics of Trotsky and the early Communist International, and apply them and develop them in the practical politics of the half century since Trotsky's death.
IT Militant, for one example, or Socialist Action, for another, are Trotskyist, then Socialist Organiser isn't, and vice versa.
What Trotsky knew as "Trotskyism" is still irreplaceable to the working class movement - if it is ever to be master of society - of a democratic socialist society in which wage slavery has been abolished and the power of the state drastically cut down.
Today it has to be defended against many people who call themselves Trotskyists. It has to be developed in analysing and understanding the world. That's why we publish Socialist Organiser and the magazine Workers' Liberty. 1900000 Phem Next year he plans to launch the Daily Sport in direct competition with the Sun and the Star.
Murdoch is obviously worried. His transport firm TNT won't handle the Sport and the Sun refuses its advertising.
The Sunday Sport is a vile, sexist publication but having more topless models than the Sun or the Star doesn't, in my opinion, make it inore sexist than those "respectable" publications.
And strangely, what little editorial comment the Sport contains is usually relatively inoffensive. It has never come close to the filthy racism, homophobia and all-round bigotry of the "Mills" column in the Star or some of Kelvin McKenzie's Sun editorials.
I do not, of course, wish the Sport well, but I don't wish it any worse than the Sun or the Star.
Mind bending The famous bender of spoons, Yuri Geller, this week takes to the skies in a hot air balloon to radiate a beam of concentrated psychic energy across the land. It is his greatest ever experiment to demonstrate the amazing power of his mind Yuri has chosen to exercise his mind control techniques on the minds of Sun readers! The Sun predicts "some incredible things are bound to happen" but does not specify what. Perhaps sales of the Guardian will leap to three million overnight. Now
Scan page 4
Bad deal council house sales Klebanov and other working class activists The case of Klebanov highlights Inside the NUM, Gormley, then the urgent need to build a cam- president, raised Klebanov's plight paign inside the British labour with the Soviet trade unions, but and trade union moment to foolishly accepted their explanations establish solidarity with all op- made up mostly of slanderous perpressed workers in the USSR and Klebanov's 30 year sonal attacks on members of the FTUA which are not worthy of menstruggle for worker Klebanov, whose struggles have been His successor, Arthur Scargill, well documented, particularly in refused to discuss the matter, instead John Cunningham's excellent pam- urging people like Cunningham, who phlet, was a Ukrainian miner work- trade unions in the raised the issue with him, to concening in one of the most productive coal trate on human rights violations mining regions of the USSR, the elsewhere in the globe like Latin America. (This is a favourite Stalinist During the 1950s, Klebanov trick - shifting the grounds of became increasingly concerned at the declining health and safety condi- From around 1973, Klebanov, as a tions in many mines in the area. result of his frequent trips to Much of the decline had to do with Moscow, now began meeting other Much of the reluctance of the TUC the chronic underinvestment in the disgruntled workers from other bran- and unions to support the FTUA region by Moscow, but also because ches of Soviet industry who shared stems from the continuing strength of the mine managers were cutting cor- ners to reduce costs and boost pro- many of his concerns and disenchant- ment with the existing trade unions. movement. Other factors cannot be Stalinist ideas within the labour ductivity. For instance, Klebanov discovered that many miners had to around 43 other people established In February 1978 Klebanov and ruled out, like their bureaucratic hostility to independent, unofficial share one pit lamp when themselves into their own indepen- organisations - it took the TUC This is the liberal press's view South dent trade union, the Free Trade months to recognise Solidarnose and with the local trade unions which Klebanov took up his concerns In their founding statement they then only because they realised it was. a movement of some 10 million The contras' friends supposedly existed to protect miners' interests. After a series of letters and listed their aims as fighting for free trade unions, independent of the workers and their position was lookpersonal visits to see local officials state and run by the workers In the build-up to the conference themselves, along with the right to on November 7, we should remember the struggles of figures like Klebanov The FTUA was initially open to all whose case is probably symbolic of Soviet workers irrespective of region hundreds of such struggles or industry. Its full membership at throughout Eastern Europe. We need to ensure that in future, such strugThis is not surprising because in Not surprisingly the KGB moved in gles do not go unheeded and unsupthe USSR, unions are not indepen- and arrested Klebanov and other ported by the British labour and dent organisations. They are run by leading members of the FTUA and the government and act as one of its whisked them off to a mental institu- For, if organisations like SMOT arms, policing workers and sorting and FTUA are to develop into mass Small factory union busting On their release, Klebanov and his organisations like Solidarnosc they Klebanov's personal crusade, group of supporters attempted to get which enjoyed the support of his col- publicity for their cause by hastily arleagues, increasingly annoyed the ranging a press conference with some mine management and he was sacked Western media representatives in in 1964. In a country where the state controls all property, this was very While on his way to the press conserious indeed and meant enormous ference, Klebanov was picked up by hardship for both himself and his agents of the KGB and detained in*However, despite three years Very little has since become known unemployment, Klebanov continued of his whereabouts. All we know is his struggle now both for his own that Klebanov has been transferred reinstatement and for decent health from one psychiatric hospital to and safety conditions for his another and has been subjected to workmates. His activities soon came horrific mind-bending drugs by the to the notice of the Soviet secret Soviet authorities in order to finally police, the KGB. In early 1964 and 1967 he was incarcerated in a Some sources suggest that psychiatric hospital for a short time Klebanov still remains incarcerated in a Soviet mental institution. If this is The use of such disgusting institu- so, then we should launch a camtions is a favourite device used by the paign immediately demanding his Kremlin bureaucracy then and today release. Other sources suggest he is under Gorbachev, to cow and beat dead. Amnesty International say he is down the resistance of any opponents More than 85% of British month (R394). The In 1968 Klebanov was reappointed What was the response of the companies operating in University of South by the mine authorities, not in his old British labour and trade union moveSouth Africa are paying Africa estimates the job, but in a more administrative ment to Klebanov's heroic struggles? some black employees poverty level at R482 a below the official poverty month, and the trade Whereas the CGT and a number of level union federation The average minimum COSATU reckons that a their French unions recognised the Conner Hai RedEton wage reported by British minimum living wage is FTUA and called for an end to its -- anas was f017,a 18850,. - persecution, the TUC and its affiliates literally ' sat on their hands Eocfalist Organiser Wơ.325 27 August 1987 Page 4 • * Still reckon it's a good deal to buy your council house or flat? Consider the experience of Mrs Debbie -Parker of the Avondale Square Estate, South London.
She bought her flat in -1982, and now she has to pay £3,695 a year in service charges to the estate landlord.
The estate is run, not by some *loony left" *wasteful', Labour coun-cil, but by the City of London Corporation, which is elected by the bankers and financiers of the City.
miners' strike Israel, Brunei, South Korea, Saudi Arabia, Singapore, and South Africa - that was the rogue's gallery of governments approached by the US administration three years ago to send money to the contras.
Perhaps for the first time since the Industrial Revolution, small factories have been displac ing large ones in recent In 1979, 41% of all workers in manufacturng in Britain worked in actories employing more han 1,000 people. By 982, those big factories accounted for only 35% of the workforce!
Similar trends have been observed in bther But recent figures from the National Institute for Economic and Social Research indicate that the trend has more to do vith class struggle Poverty wage Like many other estates of the 1960s, it is built in huge concrete blocks of flats. Big building firms put a lot of pressure on councils to build that way, because it enabled the firms to make most profits, quickest. But those 1960s blocks now need a lot of very expensive maintenance.
Of course some council house-buyers have been lucky and got good, problem-free houses very cheap. Which is all very well - except that it means that there is less good, cheap rented housing DO I HEAR 30%?
< 00p.
Israel refused, Brunei sent $10 million, and Saudi Arabia sent $25 million. South Africa seemed willing, and talks began, but - according to the latest revelations from the Irangate investigations the calculations than changes in technology.
The NIESR finds that in 1979 productivity in factories employing more than 1500 was 23% higher than in factories employing 99 or fewer.
So it was not the least efficient factories that were shut or run down.
Moreover, big factories have increased their productive superiority over small ones since 1979:
in 1984 they were 35% more productive.
Large factories were closed or run down because they were less profitable. They had lower profits despite higher productivity available, and finding, a home becomes a choice between buying (for those who have the money and can offer the necessary guarantees to get a loan) and sordid, run-down estates (for the worse-off).
Mrs Parker's experience shows that homeownership isn't the univercure-all. So do the rapidly rising numbers of homes repossessed because of mortgage payments not being met, and of owneroccupied houses in bad condition because the owners can't afford to pay for repairs. NHN Dombass.
Reagan government decided not to do a deal.
It would cause too much trouble if it came out that the US's favourite 'freedom fighters' relied on support from the world's most hideously racist regime.
because they were more vulnerable to union organisation, strikes, and wage rises.
The shift to smaller factories is much more to do with union-busting than with new family.
technology.
Pyromania Six per cent of secondary-school teenagers see "little or nothing wrong" in setting fire to buildings, according to a survey reported in the Observer last Sunday.
-Nine per cent think torturing cats or dogs is more or less OK, 34% can't see anything very bad about vandalising bus shelters, and 64% think damaging plants in a garden is acceptable.
But why? The role.
teenagers put the blame on unemployment and the lack of things for young people to do. The over the issue, miner Vladimir Eastern Europe. tion here.
rights and for free Soviet Union. no replies to his frequent letters, only visits from the KGB. debate when you are cornered). underground. Union Association (FTUA).
Wing increasingly ridiculous.
nothing was done.
Undeterred, he took up his case strike. with the national union in Moscow.
Still, he got no joy.
this time was approximately 200.
trade union movement. tion for a few months. out the labour market.
need and deserve our solidarity.
Moscow.
definitely for interrogation. beat down his resistance.
Solidenity with workers by the authorities.
in the Easteri don still alive and was seen this year. of the regime.
A centerence November 7 In short, a disgrace. 11-3 Despite this victory of sorts, he continued his personal one-mancrusade writing now directly to the Square,Jondon /Cl Central Comm ittee and Brezhnev himself. Not'su prisingly He feceived
Scan page 5
• Labour Partyl
----- pull-quotes -----
HIM that would make me a believer.. i Organiser no.325 27 August 1987 Page 3
case of Vladimir Klebanov
Tony Jain tells the story of Ukrainian