Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

CPSA: where now for the Broad Left?

Socialist Organiser no. 324, 20 August 1987 · scan p. 11 · Martin Thomas · about 1,293 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 11 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 11

Engineers lobby CSEU. Photo Stefano Cagnoni, IFL In May this year the Civil and (CPSA) elected its National Executive Committee and the Broad Left won 19 of the 24 NEC places.

Rod Bacon is one of the Broad Left NEC members, a supporter of the Socialist Caucus - a left group within the Broad Left which Socialist Organiser supports.

Mike Grayson and Trudy Saunders talked to Rod about the new NEC and the recent ballot in which the CPSA majority rejected the proposal to strike for better pay.

The first question the new NEC faced was "where now for the pay campaign?" I think the NEC was totally right to call for an all-out strike ballot. There was, at that stage, no alternative.

The NEC did a lot of groundwork by going around the country and arguing for members to vote for an all-out strike.

The feed-back from the meetings showed a lack of confidence among members to take on a Tory government which had just won a general election, rather than disgruntlement with the NEC for calling a Denham We should have taken all-out strike action earlier. The Broad Left lost a motion at CPSA conference in May calling for all-out action. In May I believe most members would have supported all-out action. Instead the moderate/**Broad Left '84" motion won, which meant the selective action dragged on and members got demoralised.

We were also forced to hold a ballot during a holiday period which is always a bad time.

Perhaps the Broad Left was too complacent and didn't do enough groundwork in arguing in the offices for members to vote for all-out strike.

The Broad Left still needs to be built in the offices at rank and file level. If it's Just a matter of the Broad Left seizing the bureaucracy of the union and making socialist decisions without involving the ordinary members then it all becomes a bit meaningless.

therefore a victory for the left in the union". A victory for the left will only have been won when we have the majority of members positively supporting left wing policies.

In overcoming the demoralisation after the strike ballot there are basically two. priorities.

*Firstly we need to build up the Broad Left at all levels - branch level, area level, section level, regional level.

*Secondly we need to ensure that the NEC is not detatched from the membership. Members need to know what decisions are made at national level at regular intervals. The new 'NEC News' (a leaflet sent to all branches about what the NEC is doing) is a good start. We also need to draw together the activists in the offices and the union leadership, to ensure the NEC have regular contact with the ordinary members.

The Tory government is very confident. It wants to treat its own employees as an example to outside business of how industrial relations should be conducted. There are major attacks on members conditions of service in the form of casualisation of labour, privatisation of the civil service and the introduction of new technology which will mean job cuts.

The only way we can face this battle is to politicise it. It is no longer enough to say it is simply a battle between a trade union and its employer. It has to be a political battle. We must be prepared to attack the government on a political level.

Issues such as affiliation to the Labour Party have to be looked at in this light. It's not just a matter of saying that other unions are affiliated therefore we should be". We are the victims of the Tory government's policies. Affiliation to the ICSEU EU WHETTON'S Labour Party will help us fight them.

As long as the Broad Left is geared to organising members on a political level we can only go from strength to strength.

But if the Broad Left concentrates on winning elections it will go the way of Broad Lefts in other unions and disintegrate.

Within the Broad Left, the Socialist Caucus is much more than the conscience of the left — which is what we sometimes appear to be. We have solid policies of our own.

Our fundamental beliefs are rank and file activity and self-organisation for specifically oppressed groups among the members — women, blacks, lesbians and gays. This is the key to Socialist Caucus.

The Militant Tendency has a policy of winning the leading positions in the working class in order to bring socialism from above. The Socialist Workers Party are concerned with building their own "parWe have to go beyond that and argue that the fight for socialism within the trade union movement must come from the workers themselves through rank and file activity and self-organisation.

Socialist Caucus has always been in the forefront of this. We are the only group to consistently and positively argue for the yearly election of all full-time officials and that the salaries of all full-time officials should reflect the wages of the members. HAEBLE any ballot paper! Such interference is something we have been experiencing in Notts for the last three years.

The Notts NUM is in the middle of balloting on the disciplinary procedure, and no-one is being allowed to hold it on the pit premises. Some pits have had to hold the ballot at branch TUC's Martin Thomas reviews the agenda for this year's Trades Union Congress, due to take place in Blackpool on 7-12 September.

In 1977 researchers polled trade union general secretaries and other senior officials about how they saw the future for trade unions.

No-one, of course, said 'more militancy' or "fighting for socialism'. 47 per cent said "closer liaison with management" and 34 per cent said "closer liaison with government".

Union leaders' attitudes have changed dramatically since then. Now, only 10% see any mileage in "closer liaison with government", and a tiny one per cent hold out any hopes for "closer liaison with management."

Much of that change in attitude came in the two bleak final years of the last Labour government, rather than in the eight Thatcherite years since then. But faith in progress hand in hand with the bosses is still fading.

In 1981, 58% of union leaders thought profits were too low. Now only 19% do.

The disillusionment of the trade union leaders has not made them more militant, but more defensive, as the agenda for this year's Trades Union Congress shows The tone is set by a resolution from NUPE calling for "advice from specialists on improving the image of unions" "professional resources to improve unions' media coverage". and "advertising in the press and on television"

The GMB, which recently commissioned commercial designers to give it new initials, a new logo and a new slogan, backs up NUPE with a resolution about "pro. jecting values, Hages, services and benefits"

"Less policy, more action" was how the Financial Times headlined an article about the TUC's plans, and there are indeed a lot of good reasons why the TUC should focus on basic recruiting work TUC affiliated membership is nearly 3 million down on 1979, and still falling. It decreased 3.6% in 1985-6.

A GMB motion to the TUC says *less emphasis should be placed on the presentation of detailed economic submissions to a government that doesn't listen, and instead (there should be) a major programme of education, briefing and argument aimed at trade union members".

There is no reason why British trade unions should not use TV ads to recruit, as they do in the US. But (as they ask in the US) where's the beef?

----- pull-quotes -----

Over the next year we must consolidate our NEC election victory. It's not enough to say "we have won the NEC and

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 324

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →