Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Workers stand and fight

Socialist Organiser no. 324, 20 August 1987 · scan pp. 6–8 · about 2,932 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 6 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 6

It is difficult to put together an ac- across the whole of Southern Africa.

The union leadership's reasoning was a half weeks into the strike - it ap- organise effective pickets to stop curate picture, but so tar — one and It also makes it very difficult to simple. Previous strikes on the mines pears that the vast majority of miners scabs. Picketing has already had to have been badly defeated when the have not returned home. Though be organised in some places. superior physical forces of the mine rather more South African than bosses and the state have been "foreign"" miners have done so. mobilised to force miners back to The cost tor many who come from on miners to go home but have inwork. The heroic miners' strike of Mozambique or Maláwi may be too stead decided to stand firm by great. They fear that if they return to COSATU's policy of self-defence in The cramped conditions at the their distant homes they might lose the face of management and state mine compound provide a situation their jobs. Their anxieties have been in which it is relatively easy to force increased by the agitation of the repression. miners back down the shafts or pro- white miners' leaders for a ban on :€ • of The in their New Year message to VOKE "foreign" miners because oi the members: white miners *We have to organise our own Maltreatment of | black The union leadership hoped to may well have been a gamble on the defence to protect ourselves and our mineworkers by white miners is avoid these dangers by instructing the part of the NUM leadership to force many areas COSATU workers are common. Assaults and verbal miners to return home — either to the further concessions out of the "homelands" inside South Africa or Chamber of Mines at the eleventh starting to defend themselves. We abuse often characterise instructo neighbouring black states - and hour when it became clear that the have to strengthen this a hundred tion: "kaffir or boy are our to ensure that the strike was of some battle was likely to be a protracted times over...No one else will defend names" , was the way one worker duration. one. our struggle. We must do it." put it, "this is how the whites adMany people were surprised by the NUM leadership's call to the striking miners to pack up their bags and return home for the duration of the strike. 1946 was defeated in this way.

strikers are trapped. AIDS epidemic in Africa.

The call for miners to return home There are other problems with the proach. It makes it very difficult to involve the rank and file of the union in the strike when they are dispersed It seems that most NUM strike committees have decided not to call As the COSATU leadership argued are increasing the number of black team leaders, in the long term to reduce the wage bill, given the statutory protection of white minres and their artificially high wages, and also possibly to assist in driving a wedge between supervisory black miners and the general workforce. At Western Areas Gold Mine, for example, team leaders have fairly good quarters, TVs and somewhat better facilities. Although co-option is possible, it is an area which will be contested, especially where team leaders are active in the union. Economic improvements will not be sufficient to co-opt when the majority of blacks are denied political rights and when institutionalised racism remains all-pervasive in the mining industry.

Relationship with

Scan page 7

ers fight back repression The power to destroy apartheid. Photo: IDAF Organising conditions differ from mine to mine. But what is becoming increasingly prevalent is the self-organisation of mine workers themselves.

Although they realise that unionisation is legal, management remains hostile. Victimisation and harassment of union activists is meant to disorganise and demoralise workers. Besides the threats of dismissal, one favoured form of victimisation is to send surface workers underground.

For years the induna system was used to "settle" grievances, and later the works committee, but both have been decisively rejected by mineworkers. Unionisation has filled the gap.

There are several reasons NUM's rapid growth:

*the success rate of strike action by the union;

*the immense publicity it has received, which workers have read about;

*participation of workers as recruiters and organisers;

*general awareness amongst mineworkers;

*the general political climate.

Many of the recently unionised are young workers - militant, articulate and. extremely confident - who understand the value of organisation. Although the leadership of the union is predominantly surface employees (e.g. clerks) - sections which management often attempts to co-opt - this has not inhibited the militancy of the union. The structures of branch, region and national executives, combined with rank and file shaft steward committees have ensured democracy, participation and accountability at all levels. And the union is still youngSevere criticism from senior industry spokesmen of "irresponsibility" is to be expected. Mine unionisation has unleashed a social force which is seriously challenging management's domination. From the South African Labour Bulletin. face Do the mine bosses organised in the Chamber of Mines want to use the current strike to weaken the NUM? The answer must surely be yes.

Gavin Relly, the "liberal" head of Anglo American the largest employer affected by the current strike - has already made it clear that the independent black unions can expect strong action from the state because of their opposition to the "free-enterprise system"

Over the last few months there has been a worrying escalation in the number and intensity of physical attacks on the workers' movement.

The three most dramatic are:

*The state's attempt to hang the metalworkers' union general secretary Moses Mayekiso. His! "crime" is building a democratic community organisation in Alexandra township.

*The shooting of six trade unionists during the recent rail strike.

*The bombing of COSATU headquarters by "persons unknown" during the same strike. At the moment the bomb went off, making the building unusable, a policeman a few blocks away was heard to say "There goes COSATU"

There are scores of other cases of detentions, beatings, torture and murder of trade unionists carried out by black vigilantes and/or the security forces. COSATU meetings, campaigns and publications have been banned. Many union offices have been raided or vandalised. Over 750 trade unionists have been detained over the last year.

conference.

10.00 am -5.00 pm Saturday 19 South African National Union of Sheffield City Town Hall, Surrey Street Entrance, Sheffield, Yorks.

On top of all this there has been talk from government ministers, including Pik Botha, about the need for "tough" new labour laws to curb the political stance and militancy of Many of these attacks have been directed against the NUM, In one incident thugs from Chief Buthelezi's "peaceful" quasi-fascist tribal organisation Inkatha, walked past mine security and shot dead an NUM official in his office.

However, it is not at all clear that either the Chamber of Mines or the government have a coherent strategy to deal with the workers' movement.

They have vacillated between reforms and concessions on the one hand and repression on the other.

It seems that their aim is to weaken and discredit the NUM. Hoping to soften it up for further attacks in the future.

The massive support for the strike so far (70% more than the NUM's target figure of 200,000 strikers) must surely worry the mine bosses.

In this situation a full-scale clampdown on the South African workers' movement - on the lines of martial law in Poland in 1981 - would be a major gamble for the ruling class. A gamble that they are unlikely to take right now.

The bosses will become more willing to contemplate drastic action the longer the strike goes on and the more it hits their profits.

If the state uses the tactics it deployed against the township revolt of 1984-6, then it is much more likely to sit out the present battle - looking for opportunities to bash the NUM where that is possible - and hope that the present wave of industrial militancy which has swept South Africa reaches its own built-in limitations.

To stop that happening the black workers' movement will have to work out how to consolidate the gains that have been made during the present unprecedented strike wave and move on from that basis to work out a strategy for the seizure of power by the working class.

Writing some 67 years ago Gramsci, the great Italian Marxist' described a situation very similar to South Africa today - of working class militancy facing a mobilising reaction - and commented:

"The present phase of the class struggle in Italy is the phase that precedes either the conquest of political power by the revolutionary proletariat...or a tremendous reaction by the capitalists and the governing caste. Every kind of violence will be used to subjugate the agricultural and industrial working class."

That is the situation which now faces the South African workers' movement.

The outcome of the present miners' strike will be extremely important in shaping the conditions in which the South African workers face up to that task.

8 sees Teer tues, 0s

Scan page 8

in Last January the Royal Court Theatre cancelled at the last minute a scheduled production of a new play "Perdition", by socialist writer Jim Allen.

Perdition dealt with the Nazi massacre of the Jews. Its central message was that the Jewish nationalist Zionist movement had "collaborated" with the Nazis in the killing of hundreds of thousands of Hungarian Jews in 1944.

It had an immediate political target - Allen boasted about it publicly - see below - the state of Israel, whose founders were thereby held to share responsibility with the Nazis for the murder of six million Jews.

Publicity in the Guardian and elsewhere, about Perdition's message led Jews and others to demand that the play should not be produced. Max Stafford Clarke, the Royal Court's artistic director finally decided that he did not have sufficient faith in the play to produce it in these circumstances and cancelled the production.

For quite a while now the idea of Zionist-Nazi "collaboration' has been creeping into the body of accepted wisdom shared by most of the "Trotskyist" left -though in fact it originated as part of the Stalinists' antisemitic campaign in the late 1940s and 1950s. Naturally those who shared Allen's views rushed to his defence, denouncing the "ban" on Perdition.

The campaign to present things like that has been very effective: on Monday 17 August when BBC Breakfast Time TV announced noteworthy events of the day it mentioned reading of Perdition due in Edinburgh that night, describing Perdition as the "banned" play...

Now Ithica Press have published a heavily revised edition of the play, together with some of the criticism made of it and two long essays by "experts" to back up Allen's thesis.

STAN CROOKE reviews the published version of Perdition and explains the issues.

PERDITION

A contingent of deportees leaving for the Many socialists have reacted to the controversy surrounding "Perdition' with a crude kneejerk response. Reactionary people in the Establishment, like Lord Goodman and Bernard Levin, and arch-Tory papers like the Daily Telegraph, have condemned 'Perdition' as antisemitic. "Therefore" the Left must rally and defend the play.

This is not only a crude response, but also a wrong one. socialists should develop their own analysis of the play, from their own political standpoint, rather than simply putting a tick wherever reactionary individuals and newspapers put a cross.

Play

The play takes the form of a libel case brought by "Yaron" , a surviving Hungarian Jewish leader, against Ruth Kaplan, the author of a pamphlet accusing him of collaborating in the destruction of the Hungarian Jewish community in 1944. In versions one and two of the play (the text contained in the Ithaca Press edition of the play is the fourth version), Jim Allen's treatment of this episode is certainly pretty dubious.

For example: • Yaron is portrayed as an agent of Zionism, and his alleged "collaboration" as "Zionist collaboration" yet most references in the play to his motives attribute his "collaboration" to a desire to save his skin. • Zionism is portrayed as something outside of the Jewish community, as the machinations of a small and alien minority, rather than as what it was (and is): an organic part of the Jewish communities. • The play fails to adequately porJim Allen of women in Israel; • Racist stereotyping of Jews (**the all-powerful American Jewry", "the road to Golgotha [the place where Christ was crucified!! (which) passes along Park Avenue"); • Lengthy passages on Zionism and the origins of the state of Israel.

In the fourth version of 'Perdition', the expression "collaboration" has often been replaced by "cooperation" . There are also numerous additions. Essentially, Allen has incorporated many of the criticisms of the first three drafts into the fourth to make it appear less one-sided.

Jim Allen has lamely explained DIOCESS "'necessary creative process". Given the extent and significance of some of the changes, this is a very weak defence. And the changes in the play's text are a flat contradiction of Allen's earlier insistence that everything in the previous versions of the play was true and accurate. it is".

Someone who goes into battle trumpeting such a message cannot allow his critics to rewrite him, as Allen has done, without implicitly admitting a great deal.

The contents of 'Perdition' are inseparable from a particular political view of the conflict in the Middle East today. Jim Allen wrote the play because he is concerned with the Middie East today, not Hungary in 1944.

The conventional wisdom on the left about the Middle East conflict is that the 'solution' is the creation of a 'democratic, secular state of Palestine'. Given that much of the site targeted for this new state is present-day Israel, this demand is inevitably a denial of the Israeli Jews" right to self-determination.

Instead of the entirely justified demand that the Palestinian Arabs should have the right to their own state, free of Israeli oppression, it is proposing that the Israeli Jews must be overrun and made, at best, a subject minority in an Arab state.

This bigoted attitude is justified by redefining Israel as a 'Zionist state" created by Zionists in 'collaboration" with the Nazis. It must be 'smashed" if the original sin of 'Zionism' is to be purged.

Demonology

This demonological view of Zionism' was at the heart of earlier versions of 'Perdition'. The unexpurgated version referred to "Eichman's Trojan Horse, the Zionist knife in the Nazi fist" Yaron's lawyer asked rhetorically, "Why not go the whole hog and accuse the entire Israeli cabinet of colthat "it can be argued that Israel exists today as a direct result of the actions of David Ben Gurion and men like Doctor Yaron" . That is actions to help Nazis murder Jews.

Kaplan's lawyer asks her: "Did the Zionists fight Hitler?" She replied, *No. That was not their function"

By the fourth version of the play, however, Allen has discovered that Zionists did fight the Nazis. The new interchange between Scott and Kaplan reads: *Did the Zionists ever fight Hitler?" "Many did, as individuals, yes, but not the leadership". And all the passages quoted above have been deleted entirely. It is pushing credulity rather too far to believe that such deletions are merely part of the "necessary creative process"

The earlier versions of the play were inseparable from a thoroughly reactionary view of Zionism - that is of most Jews and of the identity events have shaped for them in the 20th Century - and of the current Middle East conflict. They were as reactionary as the conventional left wisdoms about the Middle East.

What of the current, fourth, version of the play, taken as a whole? What hasn't change, is the 'message' of the play, its underlying thesis. Nor has its political purpose been changed. For all the deletions, the basic argument of the play remains unchanged: while not welcoming (!) the Holocaust, the Zionist leaders sacrificed diaspora Jewry because in some unexplained way this helped the creation of the Israeli state. Israel therefore remains the product of Zionist-Nazi collaboration.

Deletions

After Allen's deletions, this message is not as explicit as in earlier versions. But it remains the central point of the play. And, despite all the deletions, it is still sometimes explicit.

*Perhaps without men like Doctor Yaron, there may not have been a Jewish state" (Kaplan's lawyer); "To him (Yaron), this act of collaboration was justified in terms of building the Jewish Homeland" (Kaplan); *The Jews of Hungary were murdered not just by the force of German arms, but by the calculated (sIc) treachers of their own Jewish leaders" (Kaplan's lawyer).

So we should continue to condemn the play. But we should not support it being banned. (Though, of course, it has not been banned!) On the contrary, however shabby and pernicious the play may be, socialists should defend its right to be performed while making our criticisms clear.

But the precondition for socialists providing an accurate criticism of the play is that they rid their analysis of the Middle East conflict of all elements of Arab-nationalist demonology and revanchism masquerading as 'anti-Zionism'.

This article was given out as a leaflet at the "Reading"-cum-political-meeting in Edinburgh.

----- pull-quotes -----

SANCTIONS AGAINST SOUTH AFRICAN COAL A one day delegate

September Speakers include Cyril Ramaphosa, general secretary.

laboration?" The judge conjectured A unique and ReviewsO

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 324

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →