Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Defend to tell the truth

Socialist Organiser no. 324, 20 August 1987 · scan pp. 3–4 · about 1,577 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 3 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 3

THE COSTS awarded against the Daily Star and in favour of Jetfrey Archer make scarcely believable reading.

On top of the £500,000 damages to Archer, the Star had to pay £700,000 in court costs. -What this shows is that the libel laws are a rich person's option. The rich have immense privileges. If you dare to publish the truth about someone rich enough to take you to a libel court, you must either retract -that is, lie under compulsion - and pay limited damages, or risk facing the sort of costs the Archer case totted up.

If you are sued for libel and you are too poor to mount a defence, you automatically lose. But to get even a minimal legal case mounted, you need a lot of money.

Establishment

It has nothing to do with the rights and wrongs of the case. Money decides. Together with the Official Secrets Act, the current libel law is a major bulwark of the secrets of the Establishment. —Every newspaper operates within these constraints. But working-class newspapers, which are poor and exist only through the sacrifices of their supporters, are at a great disadvantage.

Socialist Organiser might have faced costs like those the Daily Star will have to pay - or, anyway, costs that would have been crippling even at one-tenth of the Star's figure. A case of libel brought against Socialist Organiser by the actress Vanessa Redgrave is still on the court lists.

We want to appeal to the court to remove it from the lists. To do that we need your support. It is a question of support for the right to free expression.

Why were we sued for libel by Ms Redgrave? Ms Redgrave was a prominent member of the Workers' Revolutionary Party. The WRP (formerly SLL) was the major Trotskyist group in Britain throughout the '50s and '60s, and until the early 70s. But it was always organised as bX-823 kLondon SENTE 4NA. 01-3397065.

Monday evening.

Editor: John O'Mahony Typesetting: Upstream Ltd, 5531 JAn.

Published by Socialist Organiser, PO Box 823, London SE15 4NA.

End Oinet -AnK asia newspererOI neL necessarily reflect te views of wonganiser.

ocialist an autocratic sect, land in the '60s it progressively went mad until by the mid "70s it established friendly (and, according to much circumstantial evidence, lucrative) links with Colonel Gaddafi's Islamic dictatorship in Libya. It declined dramatically, etrectively withdrawing -from the labour movement into its own shell.

In 1981 it made a lurch back to the labour movement. That movement was in disarray provoked by Thatcher's election victory in 1979 How should the left respond in local government, where it held positions in the 'local state'?

Before Thatcher's victory, the left had a clear answer. The Socialist Campaign for a Labour Victory (SCLV), which started Socialist Organiser and had Ken Livingstone and Ted Knight prominent in it, said: *Freeze rents and rates. Use council positions to mobilise the local working class in struggle?

After June 1979 Ted Knight and others argued that lett Labour coun cils must raise rates to compensate for central government cuts. Our side of the SCL V and SO argued that such rate rises meant indirectly passing on the Tory cuts. To choose rate rises was to choose to manage the local state' within the limits set by the Tories, and to turn away from class struggle.

We won a big majority of SO supporters to our view, but we were in a minority within the broader left wing that had emerged after Labour's 1979 general election defeat. In early 1980 people like Ken Livingstone seceded from SO and founded Labour Briefing. With them went people like Labour Briefing editor Graham Bash, who believed that rate rises were somehow a necessary stage of a struggle for local working-class 'power"

The Labour local government left embarked on a course of trimming and fudging that culminated in col lapse, with maximum ignominy and confusion, in 1985.

Into this situation came the WRP. Ted Knight, leader of Lambeth council, was a former member of the WRP, who would soon resume an association with the WRP so close that it would have made no difference if he had rejoined. A labour movement conference was called by Lambeth council in early 1981, at which policy was to be thrashed out.

Knight was the pioneer of 'left: wing' cuts. He had proposed cuts in Lambeth as early as July 1979. By early 1981 he was talking defiance, but he needed to keep his options open. An earlier conference in November 1980 had taken a hard line. Knight faced defeat. So he made a deal with the WRP.

The WRP duly helped conference, and Knight's link with the WRP would soon lead him and his then close associate Ken Livingstone to start a weekly paper, Labour Herald, which was printed by the WRP press on terms that enabled it to survive with few paid sales and had WRP Central Committee member Steve Miller as executive editor.

In response to the sudden appearance of the WRP at the January 1981 conference, Socialist Organiser editor John O'Mahony wrote an article (under the Gaelic version of his name, Sean Matgamna) denouncing the WRP and explaining what it was. Under the title 'Gaddafi's Foreign Legion Comes to Knight's Rescue' the article referred to the WRP's links with Libya and condemned the WRP's regime and methods of operation in terms that a few years later would become commonplace, but were then unusually forthright.

The reference to Libya was ignored, but within a few days Matgamna was sued for libel by Ms Redgrave on behalf of the WRP. Other writs followed. John Bloxam, the organiser of the SCLV, was sued tor a circular to supporters explaining what the issues were; our printers were sued; and so on.

Socialist Organiser is able to appear only through the voluntary efforts of its supporters and those who work on it, none of whom are rich. Vanessa Redgrave is a millionaire. What were we to do?

We had no doubt that we were right in what Matgamna had written. So either we faced the risk of financial ruin, or we complied with Ms Redgrave's lawyers' demand that we publicly tell what we knew to be lies.

IFL.

Only one choice was possible. We could not tell lies to order and continue publishing SO as an honest newspaper.

So we decided, penniless, to fight Ms Redgrave in the libel courts. We launched the Labour Movement Press Defence Fund, with Jonathan Hammond, president of the National Union of Journalists, as its treasurer. We got a petition going. We took the issue to the NUJ. We proposed a labour movement inquiry instead of resort to the courts.

The case dragged on for years. The WRP had silenced other critics by the mere threat of libel action, but once defied they were not keen to go to court. We had assembled a number of witnesses to the WRP's methods. The WRP did not want those witnesses heard. For them, the court case was just a means ot harassing us, and of torcing us to pay out a lot of money to keep the legal proceedings ticking over.

Libya

In 1983 the BBC 'Money Programme' did an expose of the WRP's financial links with Libya. Sean Matgamna reviewed the programme in SO, and naturally he did not attack the BBC for saying things that he himself had said in SO long before.

There followed a two-month campaign against SO in the daily WRP paper Newsline. Every day a number of people would write articles and letters to fill a page in the paper. The labour movement's hostility to the bourgeois media was exploited to get Labour Party and union bodies to condemn the BBC i. and SO. month old child Riya, seeking sanctury in a Hindu temple in After that it would probably have been difficult for the WRP -however expensive their lawyers — to go into court. But still they held the court case over our heads.

Then the WRP broke up. In late 1985 its long-time dictatorial leader, Gerry Healy, was expelled. His opponents said that he had assaulted and raped female WRP members over many years. They said many other things, all of them backing up, providing detail for, and indeed going further than what Sean Matgamna had written in 1981.

Most important, they said, plausibly, that Healy had 'fingered' Iraqi Communist Party members to the Iraqi regime, which gave him money, and used the Newsline's photographers to spy on Iraqis in Britain. These activities had led to the murder of a number of would-be communists by the Iraqi state.

By the end of 1985 the WRP's case was in tatters. Vanessa Redgrave had gone with Gerry Healy. The end of the story? No. The built-in inequality of the libel laws still operates against SO. Vanessa Redgrave's case against Sean Matgamna and John Bloxam is still, more than six years later, on the court lists.

To get it off the lists - to get the case off our backs, and to recover the thousands of pounds we have already spent in legal costs — we need money. We need t1000.

Help us to raise the money and reestablish the right of free reporting and comment within the labour movement.

Send donations to: Labour Movement Press Defence Fund, c/o PO Box 823, London SE15 4NA.

Scan page 4

GRAFE

----- pull-quotes -----

Seeki deportation

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 324

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →