Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Women and class

Socialist Organiser no. 323, 13 August 1987 · scan p. 12 · about 950 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 12 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 12

the new sources of foodstuffs - • the cattle...

The fact that human labour could produce a surpfus above what was necessary for bare survival also gave an impetus to making slaves of prisoners taken in war. These slaves belonged to the men who had captured them, thus further raising their status and power.

This power gave men more status than women in society: The desire by men to pass on their wealth and power to their descendants led to men's overthrow of the female order of inheritance in favour of father to son inheritance.

Class

Engels saw this overthrow of "mother right' - inheritance through the female line - as the world historic defeat of the female sex. The man seized the reins in the house also, then woman was degraded, enthralled, the slave of man's lust, a mere instrument for bearing children' Women thus became the world's first oppressed class.

However, within this structure of (primitive) society based on ties of sex, the productivity of labour develops more and more; with it, private property and exchange, differences in wealth, the possibility of utilising the labour power of others, and thereby the basis of class antagonisms... until, finally... the old society, based on ties of sex, bursts asunder in the collision of the newly-developed social classes; in its place a new society emerges, constituted as a state... a society in which the family system is entirely dominated by the property system...

*Recorded history - the history of class struggles — shows the continuing effects of the "world historic defeat of the female sex" interweaved with and subordinated to class relations of exploitation.

Engels was aware that there were gaps in his account. He could not explain how 'mother right' had been replaced by domination by the father. His work can also be corrected on at least three other points.

Later researches by Marxist and other anthropologists alike have established that a system of tracing descent through the mother does not necessarily mean female dominance over men. Most researchers now think that no period of female dominance over men ever existed.

The development of society from primeval horde to kin group to family is also unsatisfactorily explained by Engels. Following Johann Bachofen, Engels saw this as primarily brought about by women, who found sex with many different men 'degrading and oppressive', ', and who thus wanted marriage with one man only. This seems to be a case of applying contemporary morality retrospectively. After all, biologically. women's capacity for sexual enjoyment is greater than men's.

Engels also cannot explain why the sexual division of labour developed the way it did, or even at all. All known societies have some division of labour, though what it is, and how rigid it is, varies. But the point is — why have one at all? Engels cannot explain it.

Knowledge

Later writers and theorists have tried to fill in the gaps and have come up with different theories. What distinguishes Engels's account is that he tackled it to prove that women's oppression was not 'natural"

He wasn't just trying to increase the store of human knowledge for the hell of it. He was trying to arm people with knowledge they could use to fight back against oppression.

Later writers have built upon that work and gone further. But if they have seen further, it was because they stood on the shoulders of a giant — Engels's pioneering work pointed the way.

The emergence of men's domination may never be clearly understood, since the evidence available for study is so fragmentary, and is often clouded by the prejudices and beliefs of those interpreting the data. But Engels's work did establish that women's oppression is not dictated by nature.

He also showed that it was not the result of of a male conspiracy or of a cataclysmic sex war, as some people would like to believe even today. He showed that women's oppression arose out of the development of early societies in the same way that classes, states, and private property emerged from those developments.

Since then, class and sex oppression have been so closely intertwined that teasing out the strands has become impossible. For sure, the underpinning of women's oppression in most societies has been the family plot of land, handed down from father to son. The woman is an indispensable part of the family, for children are an economic necessity, but her role is a secondary one.

Subordinate

Jewish, Hindu, Chinese and Christian ideologies all defined women as subordinate. Traditional Chinese usage bound women's feet. Ancient Greece was particularly ruthless at imprisoning women in the home.

Ancient codes of law punished female adultery severely, while not touching male adultery.

Probably feudal Western Europe was, of all major pre-capitalist civilisations, the least harsh in its oppression of women. The sexual division of labour was not rigid. Women workers were frequently paid the same as men for the same work. Women, though their economic activity was more centred on the home, played a large role in social life.

Women dominated important trades, such as ale brewing. A widow could engage in trade as the equal of men. Women at the head of convents were important people, Still, women were clearly subordinate. They could not hold any public office. Generally, they could not appear as independent persons in court. Rape, for example, was not treated as a crime against a woman's body, but as a crime against a man's property. Lords could rape peasant women with impunity!

Women's property was likely to be seen as dowry to attract a husband. The household was headed by the father. Women were advised to try to

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 323

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →