Why women are oppressed
Socialist Organiser1987 1987-08-13Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 12 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 12
at how it all began, and what that implies for fighting oppression LAST MONTH we looked at the history of women's struggles against their oppression, at how women began to organise to fight back against their lot. But we didn't look at how or why women came to be oppressed in the first place.
As long as recorded history has lasted, so too has women's oppression. To many people, it just seems natural that women are worse off -it's because of women's smaller size or their capacity to bear children. Men comfort themselves with the thought that women need looking It's hard to combat that when history shows that not just the present capitalist system is to blame: in feudal society, and in earlier societies too, women occupied second place to men.
But late last century, work of anthropologists began that assumption.
Engels
Early anthropologists began to speak of an earlier time when women, not men, ruled society. Friedrich Engels gave a Marxist, that is, a materialist, analysis of the "woman question' in his pioneering work, The Origin of the Family, Private Property and the State.
Engels wanted to trace the prehistoric roots of women's oppression, so he could prove wrong those who claimed women's inferior status was 'natural'. Drawing on the work anthropologist Lewis Morgan, Engels argued that a 'predominancy women generally obtained in primitive times'. Its 'material foundation' was the 'communistic household' headed by women.
In these times, descent could only be traced with certainty through the mother, since women were not tied to any one man, and indeed, men's role in procreation was for a long time unknown.
This household became threatened, according to Engels, when domestication of animals developed. The breeding of herds meant that human groups no longer had to live hand to mouth. They could now possess fixed wealth, in the form of animal herds.
But to whom did this wealth belong? Originally, undoubtedly, to the gens (kin group). But private property in herds must have developed at a very early stage.. On the threshhold of authenticated history, we find that everywhere the herds are already the property of the (male) family chiefs.!
Divisions of Wealth came into these men's hands because of a sexual division of labour that had existed previously. A division of labour by sex alone does not mean oppression will follow. Probably the earliest divisions of labour occurred for reasons of convenience - men and women did different jobs because of different physical capacities.
But, according to the division of labour then prevailing in the family, the procuring of food and the implements necessary thereto, and therefore, also, the ownership of the latter, fell to the man... Thus according to the custom of society at that time, the man was also the owner of get a 'good' husband as available course for them.
Oppression does not always mean rebellion and women's oppression in feudal times produced no women's rebellion. There was no arena where women could gather collectively. Instead of rebellion, oppression of women meant women sought consolations for their lot, such as the mediaeval cult of the Mother of God.
The growth of industrial capitalism did not abolish women's household drudgery. But it changed the nature of it. The home became a sphere sharply cut off from social labour. In earlier times, the household was the basic economic unit, with most production done in or around the home. In the new capitalist order, the factory became the centre of production, and it brought together people from thousands of different households.
Liberation
Capitalism continued women's oppression, but it changed it. Women were brought into the work force as independent individuals. However underpaid or overworked the woman factory or office worker may be, in the workplace she is not part of any man's household, but an individual, independent worker. In this way, capitalist laws have given a slight measure of formal equality with men.
Capitalism did not create women's oppression, but it did create the conditions for the rise of the women's liberation movement. Women now had an arena for organising collectively, so the possibility of winning equality through change in society became realistic.
Women will never be liberated while class oppression exists, since so many women suffer from class oppression as well as sex oppression. Middle class women do suffer from general sexism too, but their compensating class privileges greater wealth, better access to education and health care, freedom through wealth from sole responsibility for child care or housework - force them to side with their class rather than with working class women struggling for liberation.
De Beauvoir The knowledge that women's oppression has not always existed, and thus that it can be overthrown, may seem old hat today; we may take it for granted. But many women today draw the wrong conclusions from that knowledge, so it is important to reiterate the ideas first expounded by. Engels so that we can use those ideas positively, to fight for change.
Many women today still blame men solely for women's oppression. They see the answer in men voluntarily giving up their power over women. Others see the only solution as living in complete separation from men. Even more drastically, some women see women's oppression can only be gained by the *final solution' of eliminating men altogether.
Simone de Beauvoir thought that was a bit drastic, and she was right. All the above 'solutions' provide no way for women to fight back against their oppression. Waiting for men to give up their power is passive (and utopian). Lots of women don't want to live separately from men. And mass extermination of men is not an option.
The ideas of Engels state that women's oppression comes from societal structures. These can be fought. Women are oppressed in this society, and have been oppressed in earlier societies, because it suits society economically that it should be so.
change society. To change that, we have to fight to