Angela Fraser locks bebbed the leadiues CHILD ABUSE: Beyond the hysteria
Socialist Organiser1987 1987-08-13Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 10 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 10
The last 2-3 years has seen an increase in the number of reported cases of child abuse - both physical and sexual. The ages of children treated by paediatricians, psychologists and psychiatrists range from infancy to adolescence. (An NSPCC spokesperson recently announced that babies as young as 3 months old can be victims of sexual abuse).
Abused children not only suffer from the actual abuse itself, but can also suffer further physical and health problems such as VD, drug and alcohol problems and severe psychological problems.
Childline, with all its faults and limitations (that I don't intend to go into here) receives 8-10,000 calls a day and helps to support the NSPCC's claims that three or four children a week die from child abuse. (The NPSCC claims that 3-4 children die each week from abuse yet because of misdiagnosis it goes unnoticed. In July it announced a 137% increase in reported cases of sexual abuse).
It is clear that child sexual abuse in the family is far more widespread than the sex exploitation, like child prostitution and pornography, that the media has always tended to highlight. Sexual abusers are nearly always portrayed as predatory lunatics, hiding in alleyways, whereas in actual fact most sexual abuse takes place within the home and the family.
The Cleveland affair shows just how adept th media is at taking away attentir irom one issue and making anotner issue paramount. In this case, making individual social workers and doctors look incompetent and overzealous, and child abuse within the family, a small problem. Dr. Marietta Higgs Dr. Marietta Higgs ends up looking like a sexually frustrated, warped individual, in need of penis therapy herself, instead of a (probably) caring, experienced, specialised worker in child abuse.
The media chose to ignore the fact that, since the Jasmine Beckford Report, 16 extra social worker posts for specialists in child abuse were created in Cleveland in the last year; that those workers set about clearing a backlog of suspected cases and as everyone knows, the harder you look for something the more likely you are to find it.
For most of the children involved there were signs of sexual abuse. The really worrying thing, though, is that the most common forms of sexual abuse are fondling, masturbation and oral sex, which leave no outward signs. This would suggest that, in reality, the Cleveland workers have really only uncovered tip iceberg.
Care - a form of abuse Taking children into care can be very damaging in itself - even if the child is a victim of abuse. Those children are usually scapegoated by their families, who deny and cover up their own emotional and sexual problems. The child blames itself for the problems — otherwise why have they been taken from the family home?
Taking children into care can then be seen as a form of abuse in itself. Clearly it is better for children to build on relationships they have got rather than break up families, but what are social workers to do? It is ironic that on the very day that Greenwich social worker Martin Ruddock (Kimberley Carlile case) faced an inquiry as to why Kimberley was not removed from the home sooner, Teesside social workers were being accused, in the courts, of intervening too soon in suspected child sex abuse cases. Nothing illustrates more clearly the dilemma facing social workers.
But need care be such a 'bad thing? The rich have always had access to care for their children. They can afford to employ nannies and au pairs or pack their children off to boarding schools. It doesn't appear to do their children any harm (well | suppose that's debatable).
The fact of the matter is that taking children into care is used as a form of punishment for those erring families who happen to have been found "lacking' , instead of care being seen as a service to which families and children are entitled. Many families actually ask for their children to be taken into care, hoping to protect their children, only to find they are unable to get them back afterwards.
At the moment, social workers are faced with the dilemma of choosing between the lesser of two evils whether the effects of taking a child into care outweight the effects of abuse.
Personally, I thínk we have to argue for the care option. But as socialists we have to raise the issue of free state care being a right to which all families are entitled: to use as and when they feel they need it - not as now, as a form of punishment to families and as protection for children.
The Cleveland affair is likely to have increased the stigma attached to cae and will put families off even more. By raising the issue of free state care, linking abuse with poverty, unemployment and bad housing, we can start to remove the guilt from parents and social workers and thus make capitalism responsible for child abuse.
Parents' rights More resources need to be put into training social workers, doctors, etc., in order for them to be able to accurately diagnose child abuse. Because one of the factors that has come out of the Cleveland affair is that specialists have disagreed on diagnosis. It is still, so 1 am told, very difficult to distinguish between buggery and the effects of a severe case of constipation.
Many parents claim they have been wrongly accused of battering their children. Brittle bone disease was once thought to be a rare disease, but due to research carried out by Dr. Paterson, a bone specialist in Dundee, it has been shown to be more common. It is thought to be induced by highly modified baby foods, which contain unnaturally high iron content which prevents absorption of copper.
Parents, with the help of Dr. Paterson, have been able to regain access to their children.
Parents who have voluntarily