Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Pacifism turned upside down

Socialist Organiser no. 323, 13 August 1987 · scan p. 6 · Colin Foster · about 975 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 6 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 6

Aspartame consists of three aminoacids (building blocks of protein), one of which is phenylalanine (Phe). Though natural and even essential, Phe has neurotoxic effects in high doses, i.e. it damages the nervous system. Therefore the brain must efficiently remove excess Phe. It does this with the enzyme phenylalanine hydroxylase (Phe-OHase).

small proportion of . people are unable to do this. They have inherited two faulty genes for Phe-OHase from their parents. Unless their diet is strictly controlled, they will suffer from phenylketonuria (PKU), which results in severe mental retardation.

But there are also people with one normal and one faulty gene for Phe-OHlase. They can cope with normal amounts of Phe but the safety margin is narrower. Up to 2% of the population fall into this group of "PKU-carriers" . Worries thai such people might suffer ill-effects from aspartame were originally dismissed.

Now, research shows the worries have some justification. Doses equivalent to 12 cans of diet drink per day for any eight stone person made volunteers perform worse on tests of basic brain functions. They also complained of headaches and dizziness.

In PKU-carriers, blood levels of Phe rose higher than in normal subjects and at just 8 cans per day brain waves were slowed. Maintaining high doses for weeks raised Phe levels above permissible limits for pregnant women in one-third of carriers but also in one-seventh of normal people.

The doses in these experiments are high but not uncommon and suggest that products with aspartame should carry warnings and guidance on avoiding excess intake. There must be concern for children whose lower body weight makes it easier to exceed danger levels. (Info: Scientific American).

Socialist Organiser no 323 13 Emile de Antonio tracked down leaders of the Weather* Underground, who had spent years in hiding from the US police for their bomb attacks on big corporation and government buildings, and made a film with them. He then defied US governiment pressure to stop him finishing the film, and it was shown last Thursday on Channel The Weather Underground (its name came from Bob Dylan's line "You don't need a weatherman to know which way the wind blows") came from a split in the US radical student movement around 1970.

"Students for a Democratic Society" had been formed as an offshoot of the feeble and very unrevolutionary US Socialist Party in 1960. Through the '60s, with the Fair Play for Cuba campaign and the black civil rights protests, it became bigger and more radical. From February 1965, the US started bombing North Vietnam, and The Movement' went onto the streets in ever-greater numbers.

In many other countries industrial militancy grew around the same time as the student radicalisation and the Colin Foster reviews Emile de Antonio's film 'Underground' shown last Thursday, 6th, Channel 4.

Vietnam movement. But in the US much of society remained politically as it had been in the Cold War '50s. As radical students progressed from protesting about single issues to wanting a socal revolution, they talked a lot about the working class, but doing anything about it was difficult.

From the early '60s, SDS had been active in community projects. But still the US bombed Indochina. Still racism flourished. The methods of liberal protest politics were helpless, and the mass of the working class was apathetic or hostile to the radicals.

SDS fell apart. Some gathered round Progressive Labor, a Maoist group which wanted to go to the workers and "serve the people Others found this approach onedimensional, and anyway so slow as to be a cop-out.

They wanted to express their anger" (as the Weather Underground leaders explain it in this film). They bombed monuments, corporation headquarters, official buildings. They were soon on the run.

In the film - in 1976 — Bernardine Dohrn and the other Weather Underground leaders are subdued and reflective. They insist that being underground is not just a regrettable necessity, but a positive part of their strategy. They say it will be a long haul, and they criticise some of their own previous approach as too hectoring, strident and sloganistic.

They express complete faith in 'the people' (usually it is 'the people' though sometimes they say 'working class'), and draw inspiration from the Vietnamese victory against US imperialism in 1975.

Trotsky once remarked that a revolutionary terrorist is a liberal with a gun. SDS was targeting 'corporate liberalism' as its hated enemy before it had got beyond liberal aims itself. One of the Weather Underground leaders in the film explains how she visited Cuba shortly before the US invaded (the 'Bay of Pigs' , April 1961) and found herself applauding a military parade. She was shocked, because before then she had been a pacifist; but the Bay of Pigs' invasion convinced her that the weapons were necessary.

To a large extent the politics of the Weather Underground were pacifism and liberalismturned upside down -into armed-struggle-on-principle and rejection of all constitutional politics as complicity with the racist pig power structure'. : It was a blind alley: the leaders interviewed by de Antonio do not know how to connect with 'the people' (and I think they know they don't know), and they must have suffered bitterly when post-revolutionary Vietnam disillusioned them (700,000 refugees to date).

Revolutionaries in Britain have it easier than in the US. We have a relatively open and left-wing labour movement. It's not difficult in Britain to avoid the blind alley that the Weather Underground ended up in.

But British left-wing politics has its own blind alleys. Just as US radicals angrily rejected pacifism and liberalism without fully understanding them, and thus ended up saying no where the pacifists and liberals said yes, and yes where they said no, so some British radicals end up as negative images of reformism. The Revolutionary Communist Party' and (less consistently) the Socialist Workers Party are examples.

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 323

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →