Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Hark back to nowhere!

Socialist Organiser no. 322, 6 August 1987 · scan p. 9 · about 1,335 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 9 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 9

telly? Since each character in the film they couldn't go because the bus has a different favourite show, it doesn't stop there, or because the seems rather to have caused squab- club is closed for repairs. Allen is saybles over whose turn it was to tune in. ing, 'Yes, we were Jewish, but it was When we see Allen's Aunt Bea go- no problem, just another way of being on a radio quiz game, why is it ing quaint, no big deal."

prize game today, something funny and lively, in a wacky, anarBelinda Weaver *Radio Days", the latest Woody Allen picture, would probably gladden the heart of Ronald Reagan. It's a heavily sentimental look at the forties when radio played a big part in people's lives. Allen sets the picture in a family that is loosely based on his own, and there is a younger Woody called Joe as one of the main characters.

It depicts an America that Reagan keeps trying to hark back to — a supposedly sımpler, more innocent time. Allen presents it all polished up and pretty, but it's false from start to finish.

Lots of people have daydreams that look fondly back to childhood as if it were a magical time full of fun and romance. Even when we know it wasn't, it's sometimes nice to think so. But Allen gives these daydreams the status of recorded history. He doesn't seem aware that he's having himself on.

Kooks

His family are presented as a bunch of lovable kooks. They have their tiffs and troubles, but they are presented as if they were really all sweetness and light. It's a condescending look back by a successful man at his humble origins. He's touched that his folks were just little people' . It probably makes him feel better about how far he's travelled since.

In fact, everybody is treated the same way. Snotty sophisticates on radio, mafia hit men, school teachers - they're either brimming over with sugar or just mildly quaint. And the radio stars are even supposed to be a little tragic, because nobody remembers them any more. (Except Woody Allen, who is presumably rich enough to have time to sit around with his memories).

Allen troops out all his old radio favourites, and his family's too. What he forgets to bring out is their magic. What we hear coming out of the radio in the movie are programmes that seem as silly and trivial as much of what is on TV today. The radio stuff is just different; it's not better. Woody Allen invents the ideal family And a lot of the music is the big band/Glenn Miller sound we've already been saturated with in other 'nostalgic' films, so it sounds too tamiliar to evoke any longing:

Allen presents radio as if it were magical though. He seems to say that we lost our innocence when we turned from radio to TV. He may be partly right. TV brought graphic images into living rooms and brought many Americans face to face with bombings, killings, wars and other tragedies in a way that wasn't possible before.

If they lost their innocence because of that, is that a bad thing? It was seeing the Vietnam war on TV that got Americans out of living rooms and on to the streets to stop it.

Radio

Allen seems to say that radio brought people together in a way that we've lost. But is a family more united around radio than around a more cute and quaint than going on a Allen would abhor? Why doesn't he feel rooked that Bea only wins fifty dollars instead of the dishwasher/trip abroad blockbuster prizes of today?

It's the kind of idealising the past that American movies throw up when the present is uncertain. A whole crop of American films now are looking back to the fifties, the forties, in search of simpler times.

Gloss

But these times weren't simple. Allen glosses over that by making everything smooth and bland, but he's faking it.

His Jewish family in the film aren't specially bothered by Hitler's treatment of Jews — they just don't think Hitler is very nice. (This is 1944, too). When Allen's uncle tells his wife they couldn't get into the ritzy Stork Club (where all the radio celebrities go) because they're Jewish, it's stated as a simnle fact. It's as if he had said Allen's early films were at least chic way. But this movie is so weighed down with heart' that what humour there is gets squeezed out. And he even tries to bring a lump to our throats in a shameful way in the sequence where audiences all over America are tuned in to the live coverage of rescue attempts to save a little girl who's fallen down a well.

This sequence is meant to show Americans united in concern. But why is listening to that really different from the ghoulishness of people who flock to disasters and mess up rescue attempts? If he were honest, he might have presented someone calling out "Oh, turn that crap off!" That would be more realistic. But it might spoil his pretty picture.

Picture

"Radio Days" isn't a truthful piccure of anything, not of America, not of radio. It's just a sickly daydream. But the danger is that conservatives like Reagan hijack these daydreams and images and use them in the here and now to back up their plans and policies to turn the clocks back. There are many things to be learned from the past, but they can't be learned from lying images like "Radio Days". The USA is well-known for its commitment to humane methods in warfare, I don't think. This commitment is well-illustrated in the field of chemical and biological warfare where, as revealed under the Freedom of Information Act, the government tested drugs, poisons and diseases on its own people, civilian and military "volunteers". But even the USA banned testing nerve gases on "volunteers" some ten years ago.

In Britain, nerve gases continue to be tested on "volunteers" at Porton Down, the victims receiving the princely sum of £105 for two weeks work. These tests involve the gases sarin and soman, banned from use, like all chemical and biological agents, under a Geneva convention.

The Director of the Chemical Defence Establishment at Porton Down described the tests as being to find out if soldiers could still function at low levels of exposure to nerve gas. He also claimed that such tests are also carried out in other NATO countries, including the USA.

Sarin and soman are both organophosphorus compounds similiar in structure to some insecticides (Malathion, etc) and they work by blocking nerve impulses.

Nerve impulses are transmitted to other nerves muscles by a chemical messenger called acetyl-choline (ACL). In order for another nerve impulse to be transmitted, the ACL must be destroyed so that the target nerve or muscle can prepare itself for another message. This is done by a special protein called acety!cholinesterase (A Chase). Organophosphorus compounds attach themselves to the active part of the A Chase, preventing it from doing its job. The result is ghasly but effective.

Muscles remain contracted, in spasm. First, vision is imparied. Breathing, heart rate and blood pressure are affected. There is a loss of control over excretion and vomiting occurs. Finally there are asphyxiations, convulsions, coma and death. As little as a milligram of sarin can be lethal.

The Porton Down experiments also involve giving the human guinea-pigs drugs meant to interfere with the poison gases, thus increasing the survival rate a nerve-gas attack.

It is a matter of debate as to whether these are worthwhile aims. Is it likely that such gases will be used? Is it possible to administer these "antidotes" in the correct quantities on the battlefield? Do the gains in knowledge outweight any health risks to the participants?

----- pull-quotes -----

reviews Woody Allen's new film 'Radio Days'

ALes Hearn's Chemical warfare c humans

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 322

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →