The July Days
Socialist Organiser1987 1987-08-06Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 8 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 8
YEAR OF REVOLUTION Ivanovo-Voznesensk under Bolshevik slogans. The Smolensk Soviet condemns the demonstrations of 3-4 July and supports the CEC. The Kharkov Soviet votes down a Bolshevik resolution in support of the Petrograd demonstrations.
Counter-revolutionaries demonstrate in Kishinev under the slogan "Soldiers to the trenches, workers to the lathes!" • A meeting in Baku of the Proletarian Union of Women calls a demonstration under the slogans "All Power to the Soviets!"
and "Workers to the lathes, peasants to the ploughs and the bourgeoisie to the trenches!"
Friday 7 July The Chief Procurator signs the warrant to arrest Lenin. Members of the CEC and of the All-Russian Soviet of Peasant Deputies greet soldiers returning tO.
Petrograd from the front to maintain "order" . War Minister Kerensky issues a decree threatening with arrest any soldier agitating against the offensive and for orders to be disobeyed; a further decree declares the Tcentrobalt dissolved (a delegate committee elected by crews of ships in the Baltic fleet) and. orders fresh elections.
A meeting of the Central Bureau of Trade Unions and of the Central Council of Factory Committees in Petrograd calls for a strengthening of workng class organisation in the face of the government's offensive and condemns the attacks on Lenin and other leading Bolsheviks.
The workers' section of the Kourov Soviet of Workers' and Soldiers' Deputies.
condemns the withdrawal of troops from the town for the front. The Tula Soviet condemns the recent demonstrations in Petrograd. The Executive Committee of the Minsk Soviet condemns the repression of revolutionary organisations. By 81 votes to 2 a joint meeting of the Caucasian Soviets condemns the Petrograd demonstrations.
Saturday 8 July The CEC and the Executive Committee of the All-Russian Soviet of Peasant Deputies supports the dissolution and reorganisation of regiments who participated in the Petrograd demonstrations. The Executive Committee of the Petrograd Soviet endorses the government's action in opposition to the Petrograd demonstrations. The Provisional Government appeals to soldiers to continue the offensive, and empowers the War Minister to ban the distribution amongst soldiers of Pravda, Trenches Pravda and Soldiers' Pravda. General Kornilov, commander on the Southwestern front, calls for the reintroduction of the death penalty for soldiers disobeying orders.
The barracks of the Ist Machine-gun regiment are surrounded, the soldiers are disarmed, and escorted by Junkers to the front. Meetings of the Soviets in Archangelsk, Orel and Vladivostok condemn the Petrograd demonstrations. Officers in Vladimir threaten to use force against soldiers of the 82nd Reserve infantry regiment who refuse orders to go to the front. The Minsk Soviet calls for soviet power and condemns the government's attacks on the revolutionary press. Sunday 9 July A joint meeting of the CEC and the Executive Committee of the All-Russian Soviet of Peasant Deputies declares the Provisional Government to be the "government of the salvation of the revolution" and recognises it as fully empowered to restore discipline in the army. The Provisional Government sets up a pecial commission to establish which mitary units were involved in the letrograd demonstrations.
Point meeting of the Vladimir Soviet executive committee of the condemns the dispatch of Reserve protest at the attacks on demonstrations. 10,000 Taic Krasnoyarsk on the same The Baka Bolshevik paper, Baku condemns the conciliationist of the local soviet, but appeals to GETS to refrain temporarily from all respond when a militant minority of workers wants to run ahead of the populatio as a whole? This was the problem faced by the Russian Bolsheviks in July 1917. Many others facing similar problems have just denounced the minority. That's not what the Bolsheviks did. This extract from Trotsky's "History of the Russian Revolution" explains their approach.
Although the underlying mass of Russian Bolsheviks felt in July.
1917, that beyond certain limits it was still impossible to go, still there was no complete homogeneity of mood. Many workers and soldiers were at times inclined to estimate the developing movement as a decisive action.
Metelev, in his memoirs written five years later, expresses himself about the meaning of the events in the following words: *In that insurrection our chief mistake was that we proposed to the compromisist Executive Committee to seize the power... We ought not to have proposed, but to have seized the power ourselves. Our second mistake may be considered to be this, that we spent almost two days marching in the streets, instead of immediately occupying all the institutions, palaces, banks, railroad stations, telegraph offices, arresting the whole Provisional Government, " etc., etc.
As applied to an insurrection those words would be unanswerable, but to convert the July movement into an insurrection would have meant almost certainly to bury the revolution.
The anarchists in summoning the masses to battle referred to the fact that "the February revolution also took place without the leadership of a party." But the February revolution had its prepared tasks laid down by the struggle of whole generations, and above the February revolution stood an oppositional liberal society and a patriotic democracy ready to receive the power.
WORKERS LIBERTY elea Price The July movement, on the contrary, would have had to lay down a wholly new historic road-bed. The whole of bourgeois society, the Soviet democracy included, were implacably hostile to it. This basic difference between the conditions of a bourgeois and a workers' revolution, the anarchists did not see, or did not understand.
Had the Bolshevik Party, stubbornly clinging to a doctrinaire appraisal of the July movement as "untimely" , turned its back on the masses, the semi-insurrection would inevitably have fallen under the scattered and unco-ordinated leadership of anarchists, of adventurers, of accidental expressers of the indignation The debate on Palestine.
Zionism and anti-semitism including Trotsky and Zionism")
A Workers' Liberty Hobsbawm and SDP Communism Marday A Workers' Liberty pamphlet Mellroy. of the masses, and would have expired in bloody and bootless convulsions.
On the other hand, if the party, after taking its place at the head of the machine-gunners and Putilov men, had renounced its own appraisal of the situation as a whole, and glided down the road to a decisive fight, the insurrection would indubitably have taken a bold scope.
The workers and soldiers under the leadership of the Bolsheviks would have conquered the power - but only to prepare the subsequent shipwreck of the revolution. The question of power on a national scale would not have been decided, as it was in inia EXPERT ENCEE OF A WOMAN BONe WORKER The fight against sexism in the workplace, by Jean Lane, 50p.
February, by a victory in Petrograd.
The provinces would not have caught up to the capital. The front would not have understood or accepted the revolution.
The railroads and the telegraphs would have served the Compromisers against the Bolsheviks. Kerensky and headquarters would have created a government for the front and the provinces. Petrograd would have been blockaded. Disintegration would have begun within its walls. The government would have been able to send considerable masses of soldiers against Petrograd. The insurrection would have ended, in those circumstances, with the tragedy of a Petrograd Commune.
At the July forking of historical roads, the interference of the Bolshevik Party eliminated both fatally dangerous variants - both that in the likeness of the June Days. of 1848, and that of the Paris Commune of 1871. Thanks to the party's taking its place boldly at the head of the movement, it was able to stop the masses at the moment when the demonstration began to turn into an armed test of strength.
The blow struck at the masses and the party in July was very considerable, but it was not a decisive blow. The victims were counted by tens and not by tens of thousands.
The working class issued from the trial, not headless and not bled to death. It fully preserved its fighting cadres, and these cadres had learned During the February overturn all the many preceding years work of party found their place in the struggle, but there was still no direct leadership from the party.
In the April events the slogans of the party manifested their dynamic force, but the movement itself developed independently. In June the enormous influence of the party revealed itself, but the masses were still functioning within the limits of a demonstration officially summoned by the enemy Only in July did the Bolshevik Party, feeling the pressure of the masses, its slogans, but with its organised leadership, determine the fundamental character of the movement. The value of a close-knit vanguard was first fully manifested in the July Days, when the party - at great cost - defended the proletariat from defeat, and safeguarded its own future revolution.
S. Africa and the miners strike. S. Africa Articles 1e abour mine: Party s strike:
A Work A Workers' Liberty pamphlet pa mphlet ice
Scan page 9
Reviews * Les Heari's
----- pull-quotes -----
- Turn to page 10~ -= Organiser no.3226 How should socialists
Arabs,, ant social
the Bolsheviks came to fruition, and progressive workers educated by the
come out into the street against all the other parties, and not only with
Available from SO, PO Box 823, London SE15 4NA. IS THE SWPIAN