We need a campaigning Broad Left
Socialist Organiser1987 1987-07-23Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 11 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 11
THE TWU faces serious problems. Hemmed in by the slump, mass unemployment and eight years of Tory government, membership has declined 30% since its high point of two million in the late 1970s.
The rate of decline has slowed recently but the union still lost 56,000 members between December 1985 and December 1986.
The union leadership's response to this was outlined to the 800 delegates on Tuesday by Bill Morris, deputy general secretary and the most prominent black trade union official in Britain. They had, he said, "a three-legged strategy": • a "major consolidation of our position in traditional areas; • a search for union mergers, particularly with unions in the 'high tech' industries; • a 'Link Up' campaign, aimed at recruiting part-time and temporary workers who are now a quarter of the total workforce.
For Bill Morris, who heads the Link Up campaign, this was the 'new unionism' of today, equivalent to the 'new unionism' of the end of the last century, which organised the unskilled workers and eventually gave rise to the TGWU, GMB, etc.
Whatever the strategy, however, the union's membership have seen little of it in practice. Far from "consolidation" workers in the areas traditionally organised by the TGWU have suffered defeat after defeat, with the union's leadership showing little of the will and none of the policies needed to organise resistance.
Bus deregulation was imposed with litde opposition. Workers' jobs, wages and conditions were slashed. In the one area where it has not yet been pushed through, London, the union organising resistance' largely in the High Court!
In Scarborough it was the union's lorry driver members who most clearly expressed bitterness at the situation. Faced with an industry increasingly dominated by Exclusive: JTS From page 12 of the MSC and the bosses have gained from the union movement's involvement — both from the credibility it gives the government and also from the practical help in starting up YTS There is a big need for our movement to stand on its own two feet ad fight for our class interests. We should aim to pull the TUC out of the MSC as part of our package - to unionise YTS schemes and fight for union rates; to make the movement unionise the unemployed.
In the Labour Party Young Socialists, Youth Fightback has launched a campaign to highlight the dangers that JTS poses for working class youth and for the working class John Bloxam assesses the TGWU conference firms like TNT, afflicted by problems of 'moonlighting' and agency labour, and with TGWU cards often handed out as 'cards of convenience to boost the membership figures, the 150,000 strong Road Transport section of the union has seen the leadership ignore 1985 conterence policy opposing 'agency labour" At this year's conference the Executive Council unsuccessfully asked delegates not to pass a resolution calling for the reduction of drivers' hours to 58 hours!
Morris's "three-legged strategy" will make sense. if it happens. There would be no better recruiting agent for temporary and part-time workers than the sight of already unionised workers taking on the bosses and winning. Recruitment becomes that much harder when workers see the largest union in the country unable to bring to heel reactionary employers like the Moat House Hotel group, where 62 workers in Liverpool have been in dispute since they were sacked for joining a trade union 3½ months ago.
But whatever the failures in other areas, the Link Up campaign deserves support. Unions do need to take seriously organising part-time and temporary workers, many of whom are women, and the TGWU's campaign gives the official seal of approval for that. It has already had spin-otts, like moves to make the union more habitable to both women and black Delegates unanimously agreed to an EC proposal for twelve extra places on the union's delegations to both the TUC and Labour Party conferences, reserved for women, and to be elected by the Regional and National Women's Advisory Committees.
But union members are rightly asking when Link Up will become more than just good publicity, and when the union will as a whole.
Branches have taken to the streets using a national petition as a focus for street meetings and pickets of Job Centres and Tory Party offices.
The petition, which Arthur Scargill and Tony Benn have both signed (but Neil Kinnock was "too busy" to bother with), Will be handed in at a picket of Sight and Sound on 14 August.
Sight and Sound are one private training agencies.
Our campaign is helping to expose these parasites who make huge profits from putting youth onto the cheap labour schemes.
If you want a speaker to your YS or are interested in showing the video Youth Fightback is having made about the JTS - write to Youth Fightback address. put in the resources to back up the words. They also want more than a campaign just focussing on individual advice and concerned to bump up the membership figures.
That is unlikely to come from the union leadership. In fact, the only discussion at the conference about some of the practical problems of organising and mobilising new groups of workers, and particularly those on the government's cheap labour schemes, was at a fringe meeting organised by rank and file workers in the 688 branch based in Wallasey and Birkenhead.
What better start to the Link Up campaign than that the TGWU publicly withdraw from collaborating with the government on the MSC in favour of an organising campaign on the ground? Instead the union leadership made sure that an emergency resolution calling for such withdrawal was not even debated.
Without the immediate prospect of a Labour government the union's EC was clearly at sea. Throughout the week at Scarborough the platform's main concern seemed to be getting to Friday tied to as few commitments as possible.
Much to the anger of delegates they regularly resorted to the device of recommending support for resolutions "with reservations" . When the resolutions were then carried the EC said the reservations had been accepted as well!
Steam-roller
The only time they tried to steam-roller an issue through was on the Labour Party constitutional reform of 'One member, one vote' . For the rest they seemed content to avoid commitments and manoeuvre through policies supported by the Labour leadership. Although they were overturned on some issues, they were basically successful.
Unilateral nuclear disarmament, with the money saved going to conventional weapons, was endorsed. Opposition to "bans, proscriptions and witch-hunts' but support for expelling those who break Labour Party rules, including Militant, was overwhelmingly carried. 1985 Conference policy in favour of closing down the nuclear power industry was effectively overturned in favour of a 'balanced energy policy'.
On the floor of Conference the left and right wings of the union were evenly divided. With the right pushing hard and the union leadership lined up behind Neil. Kinnock, the left only lost the vote to retain the existing system of reselection of MPs by 48 votes. On the other hand, the right wing got within 20 votes of overturning the union's clear commitment to unilateral nuclear disarmament.
While the left was numerically strong, and was able to win important votes like opposition to wages control under capitalism, it never provided a coherent alternative to the semi-paralysis shown by the union's leadership. With the EC having shifted to the right, and the left candidate for General Secretary, Ron Todd, firmly in Kinnock's camp, the strategy of simply electing 'good left wingers' has not worked.
While needs certainly ill organised as the right wing, good organisation alone is not the solution. The left needs to draw up its own strategy for dealing with the problems the union faces, and it needs to have a forum to do this.
Throughout the Conference the union's Broad Left had one meeting. no literature, and maintained its shadowy, behind-the-scenes existence. With Morning Star supporters in the union declining in influence, and Militant only able to attract ten people to its readers meeting, some of the problems faced by Broad Lefts in other unions do not exist in the TGWU. With such a potential, the need for an open, campaigning Broad Left is more urgent than at any time London buses ballot the relevant branches? That they were planning a campaign make sure ol a yes vote, and to ge support from other branches? Well not quite.
He reported that they had over turned the Conference decision and were now instructing branches to cooperate with management in introducing it. Just like that, as they say!
What happened was that the Executive called representatives from each of the 11 offices due to imple ment RRP immediately, to a meeting at union headquarters. They did not say what the meeting was about, so the branches concerned had no opportunity to hold meetings to instruct their representatives.
Once at headquarters they got the eleven in a room and asked them point blank if they could guarantee to
----- pull-quotes -----
abuse exposed