CPSA dispute: learn the lessons!
Socialist Organiser1987 1987-07-23Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 11 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 11
Grayson
After 15 weeks, the 1987 pay campaign of Britain's largest civil service union has come to an end. CPSA members voted against escalating the action to an indefinite all-out strike, by 53,251 to 19,468.
This means that the union will have to settle for the government's offer of 4.25% or £5.75 per week (which ever is the higher for the individual).
The union's claim had been decided by a special conference along with a 35 hour week, and six weeks annual leave per year. But the Broad Left's motion on strategy for winning this claim was defeated.
This called for selective and/or regional strikes during March 1987, which "must act as a prelude to an all-out strike and not as a substitute." Failing an acceptable offer being made, members would then have been balloted on an all-out strike to commence in April.
Instead of this, a motion originating with the soft-left/Stalinist grouping "BL "84" was carried. This placed more empnasis on selective action, "culminating, if necessary, in a consultation exercise on all-out action if satisfactory progress is not being made."
Given that the right-wing were then in control ot CPSA's Executive Committee, this motion was too loosely worded to tie them down to a definite programme.
The Executive's true colours were shown soon enough: when the Tories made their final offer of 4.25%, the vote was put to the membership without even an NEC recommendation to reject it! Despite the weakness of their leaders, CPSA members did reject the offer by 53,551 to 36,987.
There then commenced a six week period of regional strikes, involving the managerial union SCPS, as well as CPSA. These regional strikes gained tremendous membership support, and by the week of CPSA Annual Conference (11-15 May) — which coincided with the last of the six weeks of regional action - it was clear that there was a real chance to escalate to an all-out strike.
This could have commenced before the General Election, with the government feeling relatively vulnerable.
But again, "BL '84" , with the help of the right-wing General Secretary, John Ellis, put a spanner in the works.
They argued against an emergency motion which called for speedy escalation, and pushed through a motion setting out a further three-week session of regional strikes, following a national stoppage of only two days (& and 9 June).
The thain argument used by Ellis and "BL '84" was that unity had to be maintained with SCPS, who would not go for an all-out strike.
In fact, their views were also coloured by the desire not to rock the boat too roughly in the run-up to the General Election and the hope that Labour might win and solve CPA's pay problems for us.
Instead, of course, the Tories swept back into office, dealing a severe blow to members' morale.
The new NEC (which should have taken up authority immediately after Annual Conference, but was delayed for three weeks because of claims that some votes had gone missing in the post) was dominated by the Broad Left. They faced three possible choices:
*Call off the remainder of the selective action and go straight into a baliot on all-out strike:
*Allow the three-week programme of regional action to go ahead before balloting on escalation; or *Continue selective and regional into a lengthy guerrilla campaign.
It was clear that selective action would not work against the triumphant, newly-elected Tories, nor has the Broad Left ever seen it as a serious strategy for victory.
The first option may have been preferable, but it must be remembered T&G conference that this would have meant breaking a conference mandate. It is also unlikely that it would have made a major difference to the outcome of the vote.
So the three weeks of regional action went ahead — and in the middle of it, the SCPS leadership dealt a lethal stab in the back. It was suddenly announced that SCPS would be 'suspending' all industrial action (though their own members had not been consulted on this. CPSA found itself fighting alone.
With CPSA members demoralised by a long period of selective action that brought no improved offer, by the outcome of the General Election and by the SCPS pull-out, it was not surprising that union members did not feel they could continue the campaign. But even after all the setbacks about 27% of those voting were prepared to take ali-out action. This suggests what might have been achieved if the strategy and timing had been better handled.
CPSA's right wing and their "BL "84" allies will doubtless now be attacking the Broad Left leadership for "losing' the pay campaign; and covering up their own failures, mistakes and dishonesty. All CPSA activists should learn the real lessons of this year's pay campaign so that next time we can launch a successful campaign that will finally make up for years of low pay awards. By a UCW member Last Sunday I went to my branch meeting. I was expecting to hear a report on how our union's executive was planning to respond to management's threats to impiement the Revised Revision Procedure (RRP) in offices by executive action.
Barely two months ago our Annual Conference had passed a resolution in the foliowing terms:
"Conference agrees that the Revised Revision Procedure is not in the best interests of the UCW membership. It therefore instructs the Executive (incil to instruct al! che to withdraw from trial and negotiations on RRP. Should the Post Office attempt to introduce provisions in line with RRP, the Executive Council is instructed to ballot the membership on industrial action in those branches where the Post Ofuna reed Rem privisions introduce attempting introduce A few months before that Leeds, and other branches, had been out on strike over the very same issue.
So did our branch secretary report that the Executive were preparing to
----- pull-quotes -----
CW: build left!