1917 - The left and a Scottish Assemblv
Socialist Organiser1987 1987-07-23Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 10 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 10
on Kinnoc YEAR OF REVOLUTION From page 8 combat the economic crisis is rejected in favour of a Menshevik-Social Revolutionary one. The Orel Soviet passes a resolution of protest against the dispatch of a local artillery division to the front. At a meeting of the Tomsk Soviet of Soldiers' Deputies, speakers declare that soldiers should be sent to gather in the harvest, not send to the front. On the Western front soldiers in the 12th Caucasian corps refuse orders.
Thursday 22 June The All-Russian Congress of Soviets votes down a Bolshevik resolution advocating the right of Ukraine to complete self-determination; instead the Congress resolves to postpone a decision until convocation of a Constituent Assembly.
On the Northern front 500 soldiers in the Neyshlotsky regiment of the 22nd Infantry division demonstrate with placards demanding "Down with the Offensive" and drive off speakers urging support for the offensive. Soldiers stationed in Simbirsk hold meetings, arrest officers, and stage a demonstration in opposition to being ordered to the front to support the offensive; the demonstration ends in armed conflicts.
The Belaya Tserkov Soviet discusses a resolution proposing sending a message of support to the army in the offensive; a counter-resolution from the Bolsheviks advocates sending bread and medicine to the soldiers, and capitalists to strengthen the ranks; the former resolution is adopted by 32 votes to 29.
Friday 23 June A meeting of workers at the Patilov works (Petrograd) protests at the withdrawal of revolutionary troops from Petrograd for use in the offensive. In elections for delegates to the Petrograd Soviet at the Baranovsky factory, three Mensheviks, hitherto the delegates, are replaced by three Bolsheviks. - War Minister Kerensky issues a decree ordering strict punishment of any soldiers who disobey orders. A meeting of the Kronstadt Soviet condemns the new offensive. Disturbances break out among the Tula garrison as a result of dissatisfaction with the continuation of the war. On the Rumanian front the commander of the 3lst Rifles regiment reports to his superiors that his troops are *hostile to the war and the offensive, almost all possess pamphlets by Lenin."
At the request of the President of the Union of Landowners, 200 cossacks arrive in Rechitsa in the Minsk province to put down the peasant movement. Saturday 24 June The All-Russian Congress of Soviets approves the decision of the Provisional Government to overturn an earlier decision of its own, and recall soldiers between the ages of 40 and 43 from agricultural work to full military service
The recent statement of the SO Editorial Board as to being "not
in principle opposed to devolution" for Scotland is welcome.
Although couched in the form of a double negative, the statement implies a principled support for a Scottish Assembly at a time when that is the major talking point in Scottish Unfortunately, the resolution goes on to suggest that the timing of a campaign for such an assembly is inappropriate, although the reasoning behind this position is not clarified.
In what follows, an attempt will be made to argue that, on the contrary, a socialist initiative on this issue is very appropriate at this juncture. -Clearly Donald Dewar, John Smith and their supporters will make no radical move towards the establishment of devolution. In doing so, they will claim that any such moves will tend to divert from the "real" issues, e.g. unemployment,
housing, etc.
Secondly, they will, rightly, argue
against the dangers of any crossparty, cross-class alliance to establish an assembly, such as epitomised by Campaign TOr a Scottish Assembly. Here they may find themselves increasingly at odds with their normal co-thinkers in the Scottish TUC, the leadership of which, and of several trade unions, is strongly influenced by the Communist Party, who see this as a means of raising their political profile.
Left
Drifting between these opposing strategies, the left of the PLP in Scotland, such as Camaron and Galloway, are unlikely, on past form, to break free and establish a campaign for an Assembly on a basis of a labour movement-led mobilisation.
Given these conditions, demonstrations such as that pro-Labour and British imperialism, in swearing loyalty to the USA and to Reagan, to agreeing to the possession of nuclear weapons by NATO and the USA, and indeed agreeing that Britain would "shelter" behind America's bomb (the nuclear "umbrella").
Kinnock even pretended that Reagan would not mind were Britain
jected for late August, are unlikely to lead anywhere. The result may well
be that the Nationalists, led by newly elected Alex Salmond, will begin to make gains amongst those who voted Labour on a conditional basis.
Nor should we dismiss the possibility of a Tory initiative on an Assembly. Although Rifkind continues to speak of it as being low on his list of priorities, he is under increasing pressure from influential Scottish Tories to move away from that position. It would not be surprising to discover that civil servants at St. Andrews House are at work on a project to produce a truncated form of Assembly with minimal powers.
Despite protests, the Labour establishment will settle for that and those socialists who feel more secure with a centralised state will continue with their business as usual.
Socialists should take the initiative on this issue. Whilst supporting forms of Parliamentary disruption by Scottish Labour MPs, we should Party to go unilateral, that it was open to negotiation in any case and that Reagan was neutral in the election and did not prefer Thatcher.
When the opportunity arose to speak out against war, e.g. by taking a stand against Reagan's warmongering actions against Iran in the Gulf, the Kinnock clique were (and remain) silent. They could, on this issue, have exposed and discredited the Tories as lackeys of American imperialism and a threat to peace during the election campaign but remained silent because, just like the Tories, they also wrap the Union Jack around themselves, As to Kinnock's television programmes, they were shameful. Selfadulatory, (the cult of the individual is obviously growing), the broadcasts included a witch-hunt on the Liverpool councillors and on Militant, an implicit support thereby of the Tory gutter press "loony left" campaign (which as we know followed an explicit attack from Kinnock's office belore the election) and a justification of the attack on Sharon Atkin.
Any lett wing paper worth its salt would have made it clear that the fight against the Tories is inseparable from the struggle against the right wing leadership in the Labour Party and the trade unions.
The fact that you've written the crap I've quoted and regard Kinnock's arguments "for running the Tories' own system"' as a "weakness" and not as the bed-rock of the Labour leader's policies discounts your paper as any organiser for socialism.
Yours fraternally, DAVID FINCH, Croydon
bly
argue for a Scottish labour movement conference, organised on the
broadest possible basis and with the maximum democracy, called to discuss an Assembly as one of a range of strategies to fight back against the Tories.
Mistaken
It would be mistaken at this juncture to lay down that support for such an initiative must be conditional upon acceptance of a prescriptive list of socialist policies. Once that initiative was set in motion, it would be obligatory upon socialists to argue within that forum for their detailed policies.
On the other hand, we can ignore all of the above, hope that it all blows over and return to "business as usual"
IAN McCALMAN Glasgow Liz Davies was quite right to highlight the recent "concerted attack" on the left in London, including at the London Labour Party Regional Conference she reported on (SO 320).
But I think she was wrong when she went on to suggest that the left's response should simply be to insist on the "proper presentation" of policies it has been associated with for the last eight years; that the way to win the next election was four years campaigning on the GLC model.
Labour does face a real crisis in London. It lost three seats to the Tories at the election. Its own membership dropped 13.7% over the last year. Who is to blame?
Certainly the Labour Party and trade union leaderships, who have always been more willing to attack the left in London than provide any solidarity. But that cannot let the left themselves off the hook. It was the "GLC left' , after all, that has occupied central positions in the London labour movement for the last eight years - the Regional Executive, the GLC and many local councils. And they failed on the basic tests - defending their manifesto commitments against the Tories and fighting for more resources from a central government intent on squeezing the purse strings.
GLC Despite the rhetoric, the 'GLC left" has presided over a decaying social fabric affecting most working class Londoners; has ended up passing on Tory cuts and attacking their own workforce; and seemed more intent on getting to the House of Commons than leading the fight they kept on promisingIn this context, their progressive policies against discrimination did often appear as gestures and an easy option to the fight for more jobs and houses. It was this record, as much as anything else, that accounts for Labour's present crisis in London.
The answer is not to ditch the progressive policies, which is what the right wing and soft left want, but to integrate them into a serious strategy to fight for more money from the Tories; into a programme for more jobs and houses. In this, we have much more to learn from the model of Liverpool City Council (pre-May 1984) than we ever do from the GLC Faced with a major new onslaught against local government by the Tories, the London left needs to pay much more attention to sorting out its own faults than blaming others if it is going to play its role in helping to provide an effective opposition.
JOHN BLOXAM, London
----- pull-quotes -----
Labour's crisis in London_