Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Freedom train SOCIALISM

Socialist Organiser no. 321, 23 July 1987 · scan p. 7 · about 586 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 7 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 7

and sanctions: the debate Mandatory sanctons and disinvestment al the only few remaining means whch could assist in bringing about a non-violent, truly democratic and non-racial South Africa" declared Elijah Barayi, mineworker and president of COSATU at the end of the COSATU now backs a comprehensive sanctions policy. We look at the debate inside the workers' movement about the issue. Federation's recent conference.

pressure. The present form of disinvestment by foreign companies is also not effective pressure. Their investments are either held in trust by local managers or are being sold to the Anglo-American Corporation...Our concern is to apply pressure. We will therefore push for ways to maximise the pressure on capital and the state and minimise unnecessary detrimental effects for workers.

COSATU knows only too well that we can never rely on sanctions alone (to remove the regime). The real struggle is here, on our own doorstep."

The key question is workers' control. As the South African Metal Worker commented:

"It is clear that disinvestment is a far larger issue than just creating or destroying jobs. Workers need to talk about this issue in a different way. For, so long as workers have no say in how money is invested - into FOR what industries and what areas this money should go - they will be bound to decisions made by the government and bosses (local and foreign). Surely the issue for workers is not the amount invested or where it comes from, but how workers can begin to control these investments so as to make a real contribution to the struggle to create a South Africa which is free from capitalist oppression and exploitation in the form of apartheid?"

There are other issues at stake. The whole strategy of sanctions should be examined more closely.

As one CCAWUSA militant put it:

"Companies will pull out of South Africa. Then what? Hopes here are being put on that threat leading to the transfer of power. But I don't think the workers can come to power through such a mechanism, which is remotely controlled.

Imagine the future of South Africa relying on Mrs Thatcher's mood. If she applies sanctions, then we have won freedom; if not then we are still in chains. What kind of power would that be? We would be back to square one. We would be a colony.

Companies are pulling out now, not because of sanctions but because their own interests are being threatened inside the country.

Buthelezi (the leader of the right wing Zulu movement Inkatha) is frank with the workers. He says sanctions equal no jobs. This turns the workers against their unions. If the reasons for sanctions were explained to the workers, then people would probably back sanctions. But the ground Buthelezi has made is worrying.

I don't understand where the whole strategy of sanctions and boycotts comes from. During the consumer boycotts in South Africa members of our union faced retrenchments as the shops sold less. This put the union in the position of saying 'yes, we support the consumer boycott, but... " We said that if they retrenched any workers we would go out on strike.

There is a contradiction between support for the disinvestment campaign and commitment to defend workers jobs and develop international workers' solidarity. Workers should rely on certain things they can carry out themselves. They should do things for themselves. Actions like the Dunnes Store strike in Ireland, or the support for the BTR strikers, are the kind of action we need."

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 321

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →