[Socialist Arpeniser 79-321 23-uly 1997 Pege Castle calls…]
Socialist Organiser1987 1987-07-23Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 5 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 5
Socialist Arpeniser 79-321 23-uly 1997 Pege Castle calls this "gradualism with a vengeance" and Sylvia complained of the "votes for ladies" attitude which Christabel espoused as early as 1907.
Rather than Sylvia organising a counter-attack on this right-wing development and its expression in the suffrage movement she was always frozen into inactivity by family ties and emotional commitment. Castle claims that Silvia was "torn...between admiration for her sister and her dislike of her politics" and that "for Sylvia blood was thicker than The Pankhurst leadership became sarcastically known as the "family party" and it was not without good reason, having autonomously placed themselves at the head of the movement. Emmeline and Christabel declared that the Central Committee would be appointed by themselves and cancelled a conference which showed signs of developing into a rebellion against Christabel's "autocracy"
Obsessed
Christabel became obsessed with her role in the leadership, preserving herself from arrest and issuing orders for hunger strikes and arson campaigns from her political sanctuary in Paris at the height of suffragette militancyHer justification is transparently put: "The government's purpose was to hold the shepherds captive, while they did their utmost to scatter the flock."
With such an unhealthy internal regime, it became difficult to question the growing severence of the Women's Social and Political Union (WSPU) from the newly emerging labour movement and members were asked to sign a declaration of withdrawal of support from all political parties until women had the The hallmark of the suffragettes was their indifference and hostility to all social reform in a period of working class militancy and their abstention from the growing tide of organised labour.
The WSPU tactic of opposing the Liberal government at any cost and organising campaigns against it which merely strengthened the Tory vote made Sylvia fear Christabel's "tunnel vision" and her incipient Toryism" . In the Bury St. Edmunds by-election of 1907 the suffragette policy of "keep the Liberals out" had helped to double the Tory majority.
Sylvia comments miserably, "My gaze turned from the jubilant, welldressed Tories on the balcony, across the laughing non-Party masses of the crowd, to a little group of frowning THE WOMENS SOCIALI AND POLITCAL UNION EMBERS GARDERNI же- 1E TIZENSHIP A OF ALL LIBERTY WSPU poster workmen with red favours. thoughts were sad."
It was not until Christabel had fled to Paris that Sylvia finally had the courage to organise a more proletarian campaign for women's suffrage. Agitating for a universal franchise and using propaganda about the hardship of working class women's lives she helped to increase the Labour Party vote in a Crewe by-election.
Christabel could not tolerate this and insisted that Sylvia and the working class women she had organised in the East End split from the suffragette movement. By this time the suffragettes had become a fragment of their size because of their insistence on army-like discipline and loyalty.
Indeed, it was Sylvia's East London federation of the suffragettes which spurred a changed attitude in Asquith towards women's emancipation. Sylvia was laid on the steps of Parliament after a prison cell in which she had been on both hunger and thirst strike. Asquith, fearful of her intentions of continuing the strike outside prison agreed to see a deputation of women workers who urged upon him the view that the vote was not only a right but a necessity in their lives.
Limited
Because Castle's book is so limited in its scope, the obvious, but controversial, conclusion is missed. By the beginning of the war, a new women's suffrage movement had emerged which had its roots in the organisation of local working class women. Only a fleeting mention is made in the book of the radical suffrage campaign in the Lancashire cotton mills who were bitterly opposed to the suffragettes' desire to strengthen the Tory vote with a memen ef roper of the franchise. 10, Working class women organised in the East End and the Women's Labour League worked to commit the labour movement to universal suffrage.
As such the WSPU grew increasingly isolated from the real movement for women's suffrage. The spiral of disruptive and militant tactics, the petty terrorist campaign and widescale arson, far from being an expression of the radical nature of the suffragettes was clearly a result of their isolation from working class Christabel's Moral Crusade and her slogan "Votes for Women and Chastity for Men" coincided with the demand of working class women for contraception and an end to sexual repression.
Image The suffragettes, inspite of their success in smashing the image of the respectable Victorian lady by spitting at police, preparing their own defence in court and by smashing windows, were deep reactionaries. With the outbreak of war their activity became centred around recruitment for the Empire and a frightening anti-Bolshevik campaign. Their radical appeal was to middle class women alone.
The most stunning fact is that the vote, when it came, was a limited and conservative gesture. In 1918, when women were forced back into the home, only women over 30 years of age were enfranchised. As such the vote was a reflection of the attitudes and tactics of so many of its previous advocates.
The women's movement would do well not to draw inspiration from the moral conservatism of Christabel but instead the socialist traditions of Sylvia who in 1918 said "Great is the work which remains to be accomplished."
landst t simktel astaker .33}. YEAR OF RE OL ITIO! Thursday 15 June A meeting of soldiers of the Moscow regiment of the Petrograd garrison demands the despatch of all officers and landowners to the front, the dissolution of the State Duma, and the closing down of Black Hundreds' newspapers. The Executive Committee of the Helsingfors Soviet votes in support of the policies of the Kronstadt Soviet and condemns the Provisional Government's attacks on the latter. A provincial peasant congress in Archangelsk declares its support for the Provisional Government and a Strengthening of the army.
By 262 votes to 182 the Moscow Soviet of workers' deputies votes down a Bolshevik resolution advocating workers control over production and distribution. A general meeting of the regimental committees of the 169th infantry division on the Western front condemns the domestic and foreign policies of the Provisional Government as a threat to the revolutionary democracy of Russia.
Friday 16 June The first All-Russian Congress of Bolshevik military organisations opens in Petrograd, attended by 107 delegates representing 26,000 Bolshevik members in Bolshevik military sections. The All-Russian Congress of Soviets resumes its session after a break from 13-15 June; it discusses the commission of enquiry into the Tsarist government's activities and use of provocateurs, especially R V Malinoxsky. -The Mogilevsky provincial governor requests troops to put down the agrarian movement. The Saratov Soviet votes down a Bolshevik resolution advocating the right of political parties to participate in the 18 June demonstration under their own slogans; only those slogans adopted by the Soviet are permitted. On the Southwestern front, delegates of the 101st Infantry division inform their commander that they will open fire on Russian artillery positions if they are used to prepare for a new offensive. A meeting of soldiers of the Ist Reserve Infantry regiment in Petrograd calls for all power to the Soviets and declares in their resolution: *We shall die, but we shall be victorious over the most cursed, the most evil enemies of the revolution - the bourgeosie"* Saturday Pravda calls for support for the demonstration of 18 June. The Central Council of factory committees in Petrograd calls for support for the demonstration on the basis of "Long live workers' control over production and distribution", "Long live the revolution", "Down with the lock-out capitalists", "All power into the hands of the Soviets". The Helsingfors Soviet issues the slogans "Down with the batallions ofdeath — down with the provocation of an offensive... "All power to the Soviets", "Free all arrested socialists" and "Long live popular control of production"
On the South Western front the commander-in-chief orders the use of cavalry against soldiers who disobey orders for the launching of a new offensive. In Rostov-on-Don workers take over the Metall factory after management attempts to sack them and close down the factory. Fighting breaks out in Astrakhan after soldiers are ordered to the front for the new offensive.
Sunday 18 June. "News of the Petrograd Soviet" cart an appeal signed by all parties, includ the Bolsheviks, not to carry weapons that day's demonstrations!
Nearly half a million demonstrate in Continued on page 8