Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

18 months in Northern

Socialist Organiser no. 320, 16 July 1987 · scan pp. 10–12 · about 4,292 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 10 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 10

The Unionist leaders have just climbed down and agreed to open talks with the British government, within the framework of the Anglo-Irish Agreement. This agreement, signed by the Dublin and London governments on 15 November 1985, gives the Southern Ireland government a major say in the running of The Orange and Unionist organisations say they will never accept it. But in practice they are having to learn to live with it.

The 13 Unionist MPs have slunk back to Westminster, after This is the height of the Orange marching season and it is possible that their bitterness and resentment will flare into serious John O'Mahony outlines and analyses events during the first The Protestants are still fiercely massive bipartisan opposed to the deal and maintain House of Common s which had back- boycott of Westminster. They their pledge that they will never ac- ed the new BritishStrikes. In January withholding of rates. None of it 26 Counties a direct say in the runn- 1986 15 of North ing of Northern Ireland. But they are Westminster MP: deeply confused and divided about others being the SD LP's John Hume ment was that it was an international what to do about it. In the immediate and the Provo lead er Gerry Adams). treaty between the 'two sovereign aftermath of 15 November 1985 they They forced a Northern Ireland governments' in Dublin and London. THE ANGLO-IRISH Agreement was signed at Hillsborough Castle in County Down on 15 November 1985. After 18 months, despite the massive and continuing opposition of the Unionist community in Northern Ireland, and the opposition also of the Sinn Fein nationalists, it seems pretty certain that the Agreement has been established as the framework for Northern Ireland politics in the foreseeable future.

The Democratic Unionist Party leader lan Paisley and James Molyneux, leader of the Official Unionist Party, have just agreed to talk to the British government without prior conditions. Until now they have refused to talk to the British government unless the Anglo-Irish Agreement had first been suspended.

Already there exists a degree of Anglo-Irish cooperation which would have startled both sides as recently as the Falklands war, when the Irish and British governments fell out of step with each other, bitterly and acrimoniously. In early April 1987 an historic first meeting of an Anglo-Irish Parliamentary Committee took place according to the terms of the Agreement. It was the first such Anglo-Irish parliamentary contact since the 26 Counties seceded in 1919 staying away for 18 months.

violence in the weeks ahead.

20 months of the Anglo-Irish Agreement. If a devolved Belfast government is tried all their avai set up within the terms of the Anglo- no avail. Irish Agreement, it will add its They called a m representation to future meetings of within days of the s the parliamentary committee. But upwards of thronging the cent Divided not sway — and ca - either the go cept any arrangement which gives the They organised s fi EX a Oral area of the town. Photo: Martin 'general election' to give the Six Counties majority the chance to express their verdict on the Agreement.

Though the Unionists lost one seat to the SDLP in a constituency finely balanced between Catholics and Prolable weapons, to testants, they got an overwhelming Protestant vote against the Agreeass demonstration ment. Neither the government nor igning of the deal. the House of Commons were impressed or swayed. re of Belfast did n't have surprised Boycott vernment or the majority of the Afterwards they tried a Unionist Irish treaty. organised civil disobedience like the tern Ireland's 17 achieved anything. s resigned (the The central feature of the Agreehakeshaft.

So long as the resolve of the governments held, there was not much the Unionists could do.

Mass unemployment - and a collapse of industry in the last eight years far more severe than the collapse in Britain — had undermined the industrial muscle of the Protestant working class. And they were affected by the general UK political climate. Just as the Northern Ireland majority working class used the current weapons of working-class militancy in May 1974 to defeat the power-sharing government which had been set up in Belfast in January 1974 — learning from the British working class, especially the miners - so in 1985 and afterwards they were affected by the spectacle of the miners' defeat at the hands of Thatcher. Thatcher's 'Iron Lady' mystique was a palpable factor in Northern Ireland after 25 November 1985.

Exhausting almost all its weapons, the Orange community - almost in its entirety — settled in to a war of attrition. The leaders orated and fumed. The legal para-military Ulster Defence Association (UDA), long shrivelled, began to grow rapidly, and to recruit openly in places like Harland and Wolffs shipyard.

A mainly rural equivalent of the UDA, the Ulster Clubs, started to organise a paramılitary formation. Outlawed groups like the UVF and the Ulster Freedom Fighters (a covername for a section of the UDA) started to kill Catholics at random.

The flashpoint for serious violence was always likely to come at the point where the police and the army - now politically under the influence of the Dublin government - tried to stop Orange marches through Catholic areas where they had "traditionally' swaggered their triumphalism, banging the lambeg drum and tooting the Orange flute. The previous summer, 1985, the mere knowledge of BritishIrish negotiations had spurred Orangeists into making a test case of an RUC attempt to control one of their 'traditional' marches, through the Catholic area of Portadown.

On 31 March 1986 a mass Orange rally at Portadown was to be the focus of a 'day of action' against the Anglo-Irish Agreement. It seemed to be flashpoint. There was talk of armed action by the most determined paramilitaries against the British state personnel. At one time 100 British troops were landed from helicopters to seal off a Catholic part of Portadown which seemed under threat of invasion.

But it wasn't flashpoi: the authorities "compromised', keeping the Orange crowds out of some

Scan page 11

Protestants clash with the RUC as Orangemen try to defy a ban on marches through Catholic he Tunnel', a Catholic latholic areas but letting them march rovocatively on the edge of a latholic housing estate.

It was to be the pattern of the sumter marching season. The authorities annily ducked out from confrontaon. The official Unionist leaders ere willing to play along with the ifeline' offered them by the uthorities. There was rioting by ouths who fought the police at Pordown and Belfast and other places, ut it was controllable. After 31 Mar1, the Official Unionist leaders coiled from confrontation. From day 1, 15 November 1985, range indignation had been stirred › white heat. Inter-communal tenon became acute. Over 1100 atholic families were forced out of leir homes by Protestants. The sumier of 1986 also saw the deployment f another weapon by the Unionists - an intense drive to subvert and inmidate the Royal Ulster Conabulary (RUC). Ninety per cent rotestant, the RUC was 'their own' s members lived in Protestant eartlands. Their social and political rejudices and sympathies were those E their community.

Intimidation

Men like Paisley publicly called on ne RUC to decide where their ›yalties were - with the 'dictators' t Westminster, or with their own rotestant community. On the round, RUC members were subacted to ostracism, intimidation, iolence - even to their children. lany policemen were driven out of neir homes. Recruitment to the RUC ad been slowing down anyway for ne previous five years.

Yet the state had an overwelming eapon here too. The British state is irectly responsible for 22% of jobs I the Six Counties, and indirectly for erhaps half. For RUC members, it as stick with the RUC - which, ith overtime and so on, pays very ell indeed - or go on the dole. hough the Police Federation came ut more or less explicitly against the greement, the attempt to subvert le RUC failed.

After the summer "season', thr ext dramatic event took place in the puth. The anniversary of illsborough was marked by a mass cursion into a border town, led by i Paisley's deputy and rival Peter ›binson. There had been Orange reats to strike at the south. A few all bombs were set off in Dublin d Donegal by the UDA/UFF. But it was stalemate, and the Protant politicians knew it. On the eve the Hillsborough agreement they 1 already started political manoeuvring, attempting to appear reasonable by offering political alternatives. Faced with a powerful voice being given to Dublin 'in loco parentis for the Catholic population, some of them suddenly started to talk about power-sharing in the North. The most interesting of a number of such kites flown was the January 1987 document of the political wing of the UDA.

Their problem here was that the Catholic constitutional-nationalist SDLP already had a powerful say in what happened through the mediation of the Dublin government, and an internationally-agreed perpetual guarantor in that same government. It would not make sense for them to abandon that in return for negotiations, which, even if they produced Six Counties power-sharing, would still leave the Catholics at the mercy of the Protestant majority, whose leaders might not be so amenable once the Anglo-Irish framework had been removed.

The Protestants began to pin their hopes on the two general elections which were looming in Britain and the 26 Counties. They hoped for the defeat of Thatcher in the election (as the Catholics hoped for her victory, and dreamed of holding the balance in a British parliament, and having the weight they had in the mid-70s when they helped sustain the minoriLabour government, at a price: Paradoxically, they also hoped for the return to power in Dublin of Ireland's main constitutional nationalist party, Fianna Fail. Fianna Fail's leader Charles J Haughey had denounced the 26 Counties coalition government which signed the Agreement for 'selling out' Ireland's national interests. He promised to renegotiate the Agreement. The Unionists looked to Haughey as a possible deliverer.

On the Northern Ireland Catholic side the Anglo-Irish Agreement was rightly seen as a great achievement for John Hume, the leader of the SDLP. If only because the Protestants were so hostile to the Agreement, most Catholics supported it. Naturally they felt more secure now that Dublin had a hand in Northern affairs. The IRA and Sinn Fein bitterly denounced the Agreement in terms identical with Fianna Fail, saying that it 'copper-fastened' partition. The Agreement became the focus of the competition between the constitutional and physical-force nationalists. At the time of the mini General Election in January 1986. Socialist party - disgraced itself and showed its basic Catholic communalist nature by making an explicitly Catholic sectarian appeal. In an election about the Anglo-Irish Agreement Sinn Fein, opposing the Agreement, appealed for a Catholic electoral bloc with the SDLP, which was one of the Agreement's originators and its main and most passionate champion in the election. It was the 'count the Catholics' sectarian politics long identified with the worst elements of the constitutional nationalists in the •40s, '50s, and '60s.

The elections, in February in the South and in June in Northern Ireland, clarified how things stood. The demagogic opponent of the Anglo-Irish deal, Charles J Haughey, formed a minority government, and predictably did a somersault. He went to Washington and was more or less told by Ronald Reagan to toe the line. He probably would have, anyway. He pledges his (and Fianna Fail's) support for the deal, and he has repaired his relations with Thatcher, ruptured when Haughey's Fianna Fail government sided with Argentina during the Falklands war.

Thatcher's victory in the 11 June UK election was the final blow to Unionist hopes. In Northern Ireland itself, the Unionist vote was down. The SDLP took South Down from the official Unionists, and pushed its : of the total vote up to 21.1% Sinn Fein, eld on to 11.4% vote (00l) dow= im 1983 Gerry Adams West Belfast despit the absence from the contes of Gerry Fin who have taken rotes from the SDLP in 1983.

Within two weeks of the slehion, the Protestant leaders withdrawn, or are about to withdraw, their demand for a prior areas. Photo: John Arthur, Reflex. British government commitment to scrap the Anglo-Irish deal before they will talk. But talking, even if the British government should decide to get the Unionists off the hook immediately, is not agreeing. It is improbable that either London or Dublin will trade in the Anglo-Irish Agreement for any form of powersharing in Belfast, or the Catholics make an indefinite commitment to the Six Counties entity.

Even should the main political leaders like Molyneaux and Paisley want to . reach agreement, their "followers' may not let them.

In February 1987 Paisley and Molyneaux announced in London that they would talk to Thatcher, only to be forced to eat their words when they got back to Belfast. And the various kites flown about powersharing cannot be taken at face value. They are the tools of political manoeuvre and bargaining.

The processes have been slower than I expected, but the prospect is still of a political differentiation in the Unionist camp between those who will ultimately be brought to try to reach some agreement for devolved government within the Anglo-Irish deal, and those who will continue to resist, perhaps going as far as serious armed resistance, or serious military activity against the South, on the cale of the murderous bombs in Monaghan and Dublin the early "70s or more.

An Phoblacht gloats in an editoriall (25.6.87):

*Frankly speaking, can be broken on the of power-sharing because of the pressures from the Hillsborough Treaty — which, when all is said and done, is really a product of the IRA bomb of Brighton and the electoral rise of Sinn Fein - then they can most certainly be broken on the issue of national self-determination"

Despite vague talk of socialism, by "national self-determination' An Phoblacht means in practice the incorporation of the Protestant minority, without minority rights or guarantees, into a Catholicdominated all-Ireland state.

Conceptions

In any case the Protestants haven't been broken on the issue of the Anglo-Irish deal yet, and they are probably a long way from it. Some of them will never accept it. They bow, it they bow, to their conceptions or the power of Britain and of Mrs Thatcher's determination to wield it against them as much as necessary. They do this in conditions which allow them still to think of the existing state in Northern Ireland as fundamentally, despite Dublin (involvement, the British state - their state. The case would be radically different if they were faced with coming exclusively under Dublin rule, or if Britain withdrew. Then they would certainly try to achieve their own 'self-determination' by carving out their own state in north-east Ulster.

The Provisionals talk dangerous and irresponsible nonsense here. The bourgeois constitutional nationalist John Hume is far more in touch with the reality from which working-class politics in Ireland (and working-class politics concerning Ireland in Britain) must begin: "We should begin where we are and not where we would like to be. The statement of sloganised objectives is easy. Achieving them is another matter. There are no instant or sloganised answers. Only a process...will heal the division in Ireland. Only patient work in developing that process over the years will produce the final stability...

We see the road ahead in three stages. The first stage is the creation of equality of treatment in the North for all people. The second, based on that equality, is the process of reconciliation, of breaking down the barriers which divide us.

in practice that means working together in all institutions of the North and by so doing over the years to build the trust to replace the distrust that has disfigured us till now...

The second stage, the breaking down of barriers, will evolve naturally into the third stage, the development of new relationships within Ireland and between Ireland and Britain. That will bring the only unity that really matters, a unity born of the agreement on how we are to live together, the forms of such unity to evolve by agreement and out of mutual trust and respect. This is a process that no-one need fear since all are involved and since the Ireland that will emerge will be an Ireland built and agreed to by generations of Cont'd over page

Scan page 12

Loyalists being escorted by gardai away from the vicinity of he court following the appearance of From previous page building together...

The framework for the process outlined above ought to be the Anglo-Irish framework. Firstly, because it is the framework of the problem. The relationships that are in conflict are not confined to the North, they are within Ireland and between Ireland and Britain. The framework of the problem, the British-Irish frmework, should be the framework of the solution.

Secondly, it is the framework of maximum consensus, since it is based on the consensus of 59 million people of both islands, rather than the consent of one-and-a-half million of them. Thirdly, and because of that, it is the road of minimum risk...

The process involved is not one that any Northern Protestant need fear if he or she enters the process with self-confidence. They must be part of the process, part of the building. What emerges must have By some Plus debate With baisy Mules of Sinn Fein A full analysis of the Anglo-Irish Agreement plus the debate between Socialist Organiser and Daisy Mules (Sinn Fein).

Available for £1 plus postage from PO Box 823, London SE15 4NA avvay ly TO MUHHLY VE TO VYVI their hallmark too and must respect and cater for the diversity of the Irish people. In the second half of the twentieth century, what is the alternative?

The harsh truth is that we will be sharing the same piece of earth for a long time to come..."

Of course Hume's objective is not ours. Our solution in Ireland is socialism - the complete economic, social and political reconstruction of Ireland on a new basis, integrated into a Socialict Inited States of measure of autonomy.

But only the Irish working class can create sociansin in treland. nigHt Dinha now, though the tremendous resistance in the South to Fianna Fail's cuts programme shows the potential of the Irish working class to fight for socialism, it is a working class chronically split on Catholic/Protestant communal lines. In Northern Ireland the working class is crippled by that split.

Though socialists have no reason positively to endorse or support the bourgeois tinkering that is the Anglo-Irish Agreement, we have an urgent responsıbılity to understand what the bourgeoisie is trying to do. Hume explains it plainly. The model is the EEC, which has to a serious extent overcome the antagonisms within Western Europe that tore it apart in iwo world wars.

Framework

After World War 2 the bourgeoisie needed to unify the West European economy, but they couldn't, because of the competing nationalisms. So they created an economic framework which left the sovereign states in being and groped towards economic union. First in 1951 they created the European Coal and Steel Community, in which the coal and steel of Germany, France, Italy, Belgium, the Netherlands and Luxemburg were integrated and placed partially under international control. Then in 1957 they signed the Treaty of kome, under which Western Europe has been - partially and piecemeal -economically integrated.

Riddled by the contradictions and stupidities of capitalism as it is, the EEC has nevertheless been an enorMR. mous success in integrating Europe. That is the governments' model in The Irish and British claims to sovereign control over Northern Ireland - or the rival claims of the Catholic and Protestant communities in Northern Ireland - are irreconcilable except within a British Isles framework. The hundred years since the first Home Rule Bill have demonstrated beyond serious argument that the twin Irish-majority claims to full Irish separation from Britain and for a united island are irreconcilable.

Partition 'worked' for 50 years on a basis of the Catholics being repressThen shant two decades a0n that 'settlement' broke down. All attempts at a new internal Northern Ireland settlement have failed.

So the competing claims have been. ignored, and a very loose framework, a sort of British-Irish political condominium, has been created over Northern Ireland. Over time, perhaps a long time, the ruling classes hope to create new structures. Part of it is the drawing together of Britain and the 26 Counties, for example in the British-Irish parliamentary committee.

Drift

This is more than just the general slow and faltering drift to West European unity that has been going on for nearly 40 years — it is the reknitting together of a new British Isles tramework.

On the economic level this is by no means new. The Anglo-Irish Free Trade Agreement was signed as long ago as 1965. The Hillsborough Agreement puts it in a new, internationally recognised, framework. Haughey's 'coming round' is more than opportunism - it corresponds to the basic logic of present-day British-Irish relations.

Socialists, of course, point out that capitalism in Ireland is bankrupt, and should be replaced immediately. We indict the Irish bourgeoisie for their present savage onslaught on the Southern working class, for mismanaging the economy and so driving out many tens of thousands of young people. But the bourgeoisie will exploit and mismanage until we overthrow them. And until we overthrow them, capitalism will evolve Potor Rohinean Democratic and develop, as it did in Europe after the failure of the working class to overthrow it in the wake of World War 2.

Irish bourgeois and petty-bourgeois nationalists and chauvinists may deplore the small tentative steps towards rapprochement between Britain and Ireland. Socialists should welcome them in general, while pointing out their inadequacies and maintaining our general opposition in principle to the bourgeoisies in London and Dublin.

Chauvinists Certain would-be Trotskyists and other 'anti-imperialists' who deal not in reality but in symbols and historic memories deplore the rapprochement as a victory for imperialism, pretending that the sovereign and independent (albeit economically weak) Southern Irish state is some sort of colony. On that basis they wind up as Irish chauvinists.

The Anglo-Irish Agreement should not be given credence; but neither bourgeois nationalist alternatives to should the bourgeois and it. In fact there are no viable nationalist alternatives. John Hume is quite right within his terms of reference. Nothing could be more shameful than to have the Irish would-be Trotskyist groups - the Mandelite People's Democracy and the British SWP's affiliate, the SWM, for example - denouncing the sell-out of Irish sovereignty involved in the Anglo-Irish Agreement PD even criticised the Provos for being too tepid in their opposition to the Agreement!

As with the EEC - a wretched and contradictory alternative to the Socialist United States of Europe which revolutionary socialists have advocated since World War 1 - we should take no responsibility for what the bourgeoisie has done, but we should not endorse nationalist myths and utopias in opposition to it.

The Protestant opposition to the Anglo-Irish power-sharing agreement is still far from having collapsed -perplexed and baffled though it is. It is impossible to know what bloody clashes will come this summer. It is impossible to know what die-hard Protestant resistance will be left after a prolonged process of differențiation in the Protestant community has led to a serious attempt to set up a power-sharing government in Belfast within the Anglo-Irish framework.

The danger of sectarian civil war is intrinsic to the basic situation in Northern Ireland. To ignore it or to minimise it in favour of a lightminded dismissal of the one million Protestants is politically unserious. There are signs that the British Marxist left is becoming less unserious about it than they used to be, and that some recognition (perhaps helped by SO's polemics) has crept in that immediate troops out without a political settlement would immediately mean sectarian civil war and repartition.

In any case the demand "Troops Out Now' is less popular than it used to be. Socialist Worker now confines itself to talking about 'socialism' — immediately, with a split and fratricidal working class? — as 'the answer', . Socialist Action has tried unsuccessfully to duck the issue by shifting to a proposal that the British troops must go in the lifetime of a Parnament.

In the debate at the 1986 Summer School (reproduced as an appendix in the Workers' Liberty pamphlet "The New Anglo-Irish Treaty"), Sinn Fein industrial organiser Daisy Mules was tar more honest and serious when, asked why there has not been civil war, she said:

"In new buildings near Derry, Catholic families have had to move out because of Loyalist attacks on their homes. So that possibility of civil war is always there. But in our analysis it certainly isn't going to happen at the movement. And Britain won't allow it to happen"

Meanwhile, in the South, the working-class struggle has been stoked up by the savage cuts pushed through by Fianna Fail (with the hypocritical but clear support of Fine Gael, who abstained). Struggles like this show that the Irish working class is capable of carving a way out of capitalism, and out of the bloody impasse in which the British and Irish bourgeoisies have put the working class in the Six Counties bearpit. We need a working-class socialist movement capable of linking those struggles with a consistently democratic and socialist programme.

----- pull-quotes -----

Workers' Ireland series The new Anglo- Irish Treaty

Europe. Within that the Irish Protes- tant minority could have a wide

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 320

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →