Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Stop the backlash!

Socialist Organiser no. 320, 16 July 1987 · scan p. 2 · about 669 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 2 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 2

There has been much in the news recently about the subject of child abuse and particularly recent developments in Cleveland.

Apart from the actual child abuse, probably the worse aspect of that case was the way in which the gutter press and sections of the left reacted towards it.

-Their attitude was stark and hideous: "How dare these interfering, nosey-parkers take these children out of the family!" Hardly any of the articles examined the subject of child abuse or seriously takes into account the vast experience of work wth children of Dr Higgs, the central figure in the Cleveland case.

This reluctance to deal with the subject of child abuse helps to keep the huge number of victims away from the public's knowledge and that inevitably makes it harder to deal with.

Nobody knows the true extent of child abuse and child sex abuse. The NSPCC guesses that it is one in every ten children. To bring it into stark reality, that means that at present half a million children are being abused.

What should be on the minds of people who are genuinely concerned with tackling the problem of child abuse is the probable outcome of the recent hysterical outburst in the media.

Although I have never had any dealings with children who are being abused, haveworked in a psychiatric day hospital. I encountered many people, mainly women: who were admitted for depression and anxiety, etc., which was the consequence of abuse they had suffered in childhood.

The two most significant reactions of these people were deep feelings of guilt — and anger towards the world for standing by and letting it happen.

This guilt, which often leads to suicide attempts, comes from the belief that they themselves were somehow responsible for what happened to them. They feel that because nobody did anything to stop it, then it must||have been either alright or else their own fault.

Even when someone did intervene it may have been too late and the barbed guilt had already been sown deep.

In the Cleveland case all the tabloids rushed to protect the institution of the family and to deny what the experts - both in Cleveland and generally - say about the extent of child abuse within the family.

This crass and sickening tabloid campaign is part of a backlash against the fight to stop child abuse. If this campaign succeeds the subject of child abuse will again be unmentionable. Many of those whose job it is to report known or suspected cases and to act to protect children will be intimidated. People in positions where they may be able to identify child abuse, teachers, GPs, nurses, social workers, etc., will think twice before they risk sharing the fate of Dr Higgs who is being hounded as an "enemy of the people"!

Harder

After the witch-hunt of Dr. Higgs, people will be less willing to identify abuse and think twice before taking or recommending action. Victims of child abuse will continue to suffer horrific abuse and subsequent crippling and torturing guilt. They will now find it harder to come forward and look for help.

Two final points. Firstly, contrary to what sections of the left, like Socialist Worker, say, child abuse is not just a working class problem, caused by deprivation and class oppression.

Child abuse has no class barriers. Bank managers, doctors, barristers, tabloid editors, solicitors, as well as working class people have all been identified as child abusers.

Secondly, of all the writings of recent weeks, we haven't heard much from people who have been abused in the past. One letter sent to Dr Higgs, from a person who had been abused as a child said, "I am sorry that I was born a generation too soon."

What the press campaign against Dr. Higgs will do if we let it is ensure that the present generation also will be a generation which grows up in a dark age of child abuse which society pretends not to know about.

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 320

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →