Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Women and Class

Socialist Organiser no. 319, 9 July 1987 · scan p. 12 · about 1,464 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 12 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 12

Hints. We fight goainst the labour fertility, the right health and we stard childcare facilities, the right to work, T'AnI UNN mothers, the right to wages, benefits not relate to these movements. and legal -терно срно.... rengleren mane прм sino acmden ehenpwhshmi bacik m Fihin tecaboer ennen! @ilour igne:N capragat an 0 o and fight for it to take our needs as a government that ignores party decithe organisation and consciousness anlats demsosenm на р RAnT INe unions and labour and mr trane win ton Mes. WHMISE ре PNкLN6. highting tsst0sshms.

women already organised the аннісня Th WANM PHM- leC -10 - emenmeni to molaye whll 6 9g89 58: rut e ers.on seainegrO tailipo? not a bad idea — maybe we'll retain a different 10 per cent this time around.

When the book itself is about history that's been forgotten and has to be rediscovered over and over again, then the book becomes something to keep going back to "lest we forget".

When we think of the women's movement', we usually think of-the 1960s or else we think of Mrs Pankhurst and the suffragettes. What Sheila Rowbotham's book, Women, Resistance and Revolution reminds us is that the suffragettes weren't the beginning, but rather the continuation of one strand of early reminism.

Alongside the largely middle class suffragettes existed a more proletarian women's movement, led by Sylvia Pankhurst and Eleanor Marx. While the suffragettes chained themselves to railings in the West End to try to secure the vote, Sylvia and Eleanor organised women workers in the East End into trade unions and in struggles around basic issues of survival - food, jobs, etc.

Before those women in the 1890s, there were the women of the Paris Commune of 1870, who often fought more heroically than the men, and women who joined the French Revolution of 1789.

Struggles As you go back in time, various flashes of women's struggles - for identity, for independence — light up the great hidden store of women's Women appeared early on in the role of religious dissenters. In the absence of any democratic institutions of government, religious dissent was the only way to show opposition to the status quo. In the Puritan movement, women could claim to be the equal of men -women could be prophetesses and preachers, and they could obey a "higher order' than the male head of a household.

As ideas of the Enlightenment spread - ideas of liberty, equality and fraternity - and the ideas of the Owenite communes, women who took up these ideas enthusiastically often came up against male hostility to their activities. At first many individuals fought back, only to be broken by the struggle. Slowly, painfully, the idea of working together with others, of organising, 1. We aim to build a mass campaign such as the right to control our own the right to live in this country with the partner of our choice, the right to unionists and as women.

desen etsm nemmany •losı sed momeomeotciardm n Sw/ehilinmince angol mgoN r* ии Grin. . Wewaim ні нені вина by sane cIn мноВіна mals came to be seen as the way forward.

Feminism then had more than one strand, as it does now. Middle class women wanted greater access to education, and greater independence from men. But for working class women, the struggle for education had to take a back seat to basic questions of survival These women took part in bread rjots and in demonstrations against the brutality of early capitalism. For them, their aspirations could only be met by a new kind of society.

They were anxious to link up with workers in struggle, though workers were often unwilling to link up with them. The feminist cause then was not 'respectable'. To some women, this signalled the need for women to go off on their own to organise, rather than be beaten down by men in trade unions and other movements.

But, again, as history shows, women who tried this path ended up at a blank wall. They didn't have the power to make the changes they wanted, so the struggles ended up broken. Where women stayed in the trade unions and fought to have the issues taken up, some progress has been made. Trade unions now have equal opportunities, positive discrimination, maternity rights and equal pay as part of their programme for members.

In the women's movement today, we find the same kind of strands. We're a product of our history. Some of us see that women can never have true equality with men under the capitalist system, because it's a system that puts profit above human needs. It suits the system to have women doing unpaid work in the home and to reproduce a new generation of workers with little or no financial assistance from the state.

But we recognise too that just struggling for a new society won't guarantee equality for women once that new society is achieved. Sexism is deeply ingrained in men. Women will continue to have to struggle for their liberation - it won't just suddenly come right the day after ment, and to involve women who do meshen oms wwemenk.-c hig irkn mihe 13ть wn llmen-й We fight to change the sexist atMAnEG-A arrangements and prac- зенів Match Girls' Strike, 1888 capitalism is overthrown.

Lots of women reject this view. Blaming men, rather than the economic system under which we live, they have separated themselves from political ties with men, and gone on to organise separately.

This is a dilemma women have faced through history - to try to realise their aspirations by linking their struggles with those of other groups, such as male workers, or to build a separate women only movement.

If women have been driven to separatism, it's because men have shown themselves very reluctant to let women join their struggles in the past. Some early feminists who participated in the French Revolution and the Paris Commune were scorned and derided by men. Men often begged such women not to reveal themselves as feminists, since this could only harm the main cause. It sounds familiar - we still hear that It's easier to be part of a women best private boarding school for them, etc. — rather different from a woman who must pay a large part of her wage for childcare so she can work. The middle class woman may suffer sexism too, but her instincts lie with her class, not with her sex.

And her privileges mean thi she doesn't suffer the economic hardships that working class women do - a middle class woman can get a private abortion quickly, she can get nannies and au pairs to relieve her of childcare and housework, she may be wealthy enough not to have to work, she can pay for institutional care for ageing parents.

Women who want to organise separately should think again. History shows that separate movements have failed. And while all women suffer sexism, only working class women will have the drive to change the system. Middle class if women are to be liberated But this kind of self-help is not enough, and it dissipates the energy needed to build a strongly political movement that can bring change. As Rowbotham's book shows, women at all periods have been able to live in the cracks and crevices of the system - the early 'free unions' between women and men, the first experiments in communal living — these could all exist within the system because they didn't fundamentally threaten it. And again, tor women to organise for themselves necessary services like childcare just lets the system get away with not doing it.

Women are still oppressed today. To console themselves, many women have spun out a theory that women are better than men; women are able to produce the miracle of birth, women don't fight wars, women are the hope and future of the human believing oneself 'better' isn't much Thic matE manenlancome but A HIS lay LULL help when the stark facts show that women in work are paid less than men, have less access to promotion, have more boring jobs, and have to scratch around trying to get childcare so they can earn what they can. And many can't get work at all.

We live in the system - opting out can't work. The energy going into making the system more bearable could be channelled into changing the system once and for all.

Rowbotham's book shows us that. however haltingly, women have been trying to do that for centuries. The method was to link up with existing struggles so that women's struggles weren't marginalised. In reminding us of that history, even if we only keep 10 per cent of it, Rowbotham's book deserves a second reading.

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 319

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →