Three pamphlets that challenge the left
Socialist Organiser1987 1987-07-09Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 6 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 6
Three new pamphlets have just appeared under the Workers' Liberty imprint.
Arabs, Jews and Socialism collects together a unique discussion which first appeared in the pages of Socialist Organiser. 54 pages long, it includes 49 articles and letters, mostly from the last 4½ years, with two new pieces and an introduction.
Authors represented include Lenni Brenner, author of 'Zionism in the Age of the Dictators' and "The Iron Wall'), Moshe Machover (a founder of Matzpen), Tony Greenstein, Andrew Hornung, Jeremy Green, SO editor John O'Mahony, and others.
All the debate revolves around one issue: what rights does the IsraeliJewish nation have?
In the 1940s, and up to 1967, most left opinion in countries like Britain was strongly pro-Israeli, and tended to dismiss the plight of the Palestinian Arabs as a secondary problem. That has changed dramaticallypartly because of the crimes of Israel on the West Bank and in Lebanon, and partly because of the growing influence in the left of Arab nationalism and of Third World nationalist ideas more generally).
Now most of the left are 'antizionist in the sense that they want to undo what Zionism did, and destroy the Jewish nation in Palestine. For obvious reasons, they don't put it in those terms - even to themselves.
Socialist Organiser, too, supported this "secular democratic state' policy, Organiser Arabs, Jews and Socialism £1.80; The New Anglo-Irish Treaty E1; The 1987 general election and the Marxist left 50p. All available from PO Box 823, London SE15 4NA. Cheques payable to SO: add 20% for postage (minimum The 1987 general election and the Marxist left Martin Thomas In the late "70s, one or two comrades came to think that the 'secular democratic state' was a fantasy, and over some seven years they gradually convinced a majority that support for the Palestinian Arabs' just demands must be coupled with recognition of the right of Israel to exist.
The discussion has also tackled other issues. If 'anti-zionism' means comprehensively undoing what Zionism did, then it is inescapably anti-Jewish - both against the Jews in Israel, and against that big majority of Jews world-wide who instinctively identify with Israel. Back in 1977, when Socialist Organiser still held firmly to the 'secular democratic state' policy, we had already condemned those who wanted to 'ban Zionists' in British colleges.
Now we realised that this 'banning Zionists' in Britain was inextricably 987 Page no.1 By suhe o'Minory Plus debate with Daisy p Mules of Sinn Fein linked with the programme of banning Zionism' in Palestine - and that most of the left was, despite all good intentions, anti-semitic.
Agree or not, you should study this The 1987 general election and the Marxist left collects articles from Socialist Organiser around the time of the election together with one from Workers' Liberty no. 6.
During the election, some SWP members were visibly stung by our editorial challenging them to canvass for Labour, and the Revolutionary Communist Party' made efforts to pull disgruntled Labour leftists around itself. Both those tendencies are now trying to brand us as opportunist' • The pamphlet goes on the offensive, and poses the debate in terms of their abstentionism.
It also challenges Militant's mystiand the Northern Ireland Protestants are rebelling against it only because they don't know what's good for them.
The reality is different. Britain has concluded that it cannot find a purely 'internal' solution to stabilise Northern Ireland, and has tried to bypass the Protestants - the major obstacle to its strategy since the early 19605 — by a deal with Dublin. The strength of the Anglo-Irish Agreement is that it does not depend on the consent of the Northern Ireland majority, and thus cannot be destroyed by that majority as long as London and Dublin hold firm.
Within that strong framework, the British government then hopes to develop towards power-sharing, devolved government and relatively 'normal' politics in Northern Ireland.
Simply to counterpose Catholic Irish nationalism to the Anglo-Irish Agreement is a dead-end. The Protestant resistance which the Agreement tries to bypass and manipulate is strong and compact enough that it cannot be defeated by a Catholic-nationalist movement. A serious attempt at taking the Protestant resistance by storm in that way would only lead to bloody civil war and repartition.
The only serious alternative to the Agreement is an attempt to get across to the Protestant workers with working class politics - politics which support the just revolt of the Northern Ireland Catholics, but link it with a consistently democratic programme which also offers guarantees to Ireland's Protestant minority.
----- pull-quotes -----
The new Anglo- Irish Treaty