Death from a distance
Socialist Organiser1987 1987-07-09Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 6 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 6
Belinda Weaver 'Chronicle of a death foretold' is slow and rather stately, like an opera without music. It's not dramatic. We know a man will die, we see the build up to the killing, but we're held at a distance from it.
Set in a nameless South American town, it's narrated by the Doctor, an old man come back to the scene of the crime all those years ago. In recalling the tragedy of the killing of his best friend, Santiago Nasar, he brings it to life again before our eyes. The Doctor is haunted by his memories. He has made the trip up river to look over the records of the trial, revisit places, and talk to those who still remember.
Santiago is killed to avenge the honour of Angela, a bride returned to her parents on her wedding night, when Bayardo, her husband, discovered she wasn't a virgin. Forced by her twin brothers to name her seducer, Angela screams out the name of Santiago. The brothers sharpen their knives and drink to keep their courage up for the killing.
The Doctor knows, but cannot understand, that the whole town knew in advance that Santiago would be killed, yet no one tried to avert the tragedy. Only one person tried, by note, to warn Santiago. The police, the priest, the townspeople - all knew, and all ignored it. The Doctor is tormented - he wants to understand, to know how and why such a thing could happen.
He believes that Santiago was innocent of seducing Angela, and that he was killed in place of another man.
The Doctor mourns Santiago sincerely, and the death shattered him, but it is the loss of a dear friend, rather than the nature of the killing, that upsets him. He questions the code of honour that demands a death to avenge a seduction, but he questions it mainly because the consequences for him were tragic — he lost his best friend. He doesn't condemn the stupidity of a system where men can sleep with as many women as they like without marriage, but where a bride must be a virgin, and where a girl leaves the strict control of her father only to go to the strict control of a husband. In such a system, a woman can be virgin, wife or whore. She is defined totally by her sexual relation to men.
The film is based on Gabriel Garcia Marquez's story of the same name. Perhaps the story is richer than the film, which seems full of promises that go nowhere. The film hints of depths and mysteries that then never get revealed - it's full of loose ends and dead ends.
The character of Bayardo seems to promise much - the wealthy, enigmatic stranger who gets off the boat one day in search of a bride. But Bayardo never develops; he marries, he's deceived, he departs. Even his brief reappearance at the end leaves us in the dark.
Angela is even more of a mystery. At first she is adamant about not Workers' Ireland series marrying Bayardo. She seems contemptuous of his show off ways, and sue rescuis ner parents eagerness to conclude so financially suitable a match. It seems only too plausible that she should take a lover to spite her parentsYet from the moment she marries Bayardo, she conceives a doglike devotion to him, grieving for him after he has left her, and visiting their abandoned home as if it were a shrine. We never discover her true feelings.
The film is beautiful to watch, and satisfying even though it doesn't hang together too well. The film is haunted by what has been left out. Watching it, you experience that faint sense of incredulity you feel watching operas — the plots seem so over the top, with people dying or killing for love. Yet women in many countries today are ostracised or punished for the 'crime' of not being virgins, so we shouldn't just think the film is about some quaint old fashioned custom that we've grown out of in these sophisticated times.
fasten' the partition of Ireland, and
----- pull-quotes -----
reviews 'Chronicle of a Death Foretold"