Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Struggles inside Israel

Socialist Organiser no. 318, 2 July 1987 · scan p. 4 · about 1,588 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 4 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 4

In the past months, students in the Israeli universities have become increasingly agitated over the issue of tuition fees. As part of the government's economic austerity policies, funding for the universities (and for education in general) is steadily being cut, resulting in a rise in tuition fees.

This year, Israeli students had to pay more than $1300 for the privilege of entering the "Ivory Tower"

For next year, the university administrations want to charge even more $1600; some believers in laissez-faire economics want to go as high as $2200 or even $3000. For its part, the Israeli National Union of Students demands that tuition fees be fixed at $800, as recommended several years ago by a government commission.

When negotiations proved fruitless, a prolonged student strike broke out, paralysing the university campuses. Students went out on the streets; several student demonstrations were violently dispersed by use of tear gas and club-swinging police horsemen. So far, the student struggle was conceived as a SOCIOeconomic issue, unconnected with Jewish-Arab relations; though student peace activists, who took a prominent part in the student struggle, pointed out similarities between police brutality towards the students and the behaviour of policemen and soldiers in the occupied territories.

The character of the struggle changed abruptly on 17 May. After several futile attempts at mediation, the cabinet was to reach a final decision on the issue of tuition fees. Education Minister Navon proposed $1,150 as a compromise, and this proposal seemed likely to be accepted. Since the early morning, thousands of students gathered in front of the Prime Minister's Office, tensely waiting for the conclusion. To their shock, they found out that the cabinet had determined upon two levels of tuition fees - $i,050 for students who had served in the army, $1,550 for those who hadn't.

Practically all Jews in Israel are drafted to the army; the Arab citizens of Israel, except for a few communities considered "loyal" , are not allowed to become soldiers, even had they desired to do so. Thus, there was little doubt about the racist meaning of the government decision. It was proposed by Science Minister Gideon Patt, member of the so-called "Liberal" Party, and passed by the votes of the Likud and religious ministers, against the opposition of the Labor Party.

When news of the cabinet's decision reached the students waiting outside, there were moments of confusion and consternation. The first to recover were the Arab students, who immediately started shouting "Down with the racist government!" Together with members of the left sraeli peace protesters unite wing "Campus' student movement, they rushed into the road, attempted to block the passage of the departing ministers' cars, and were forcibly removed by police.

Within hours, the shock wave spread. The students affiliated to the moderate left Ratz and Mapam parties joined in the protests; so did the leadership of the student unions, dominated by Labor. At night, angry students picketed Prime Minister Shamir's residence; some wore KuKlux-Klan masks, and carried signs reading: "Look in the mirror, Mr. Shamir!"

On the following day, mass protest rallies took place in all Israeli universities. Aside from student activists, the speakers included senior representatives of the university administrations. Deans, rectors and university presidents firmly vowed that racial discrimination would never enter the universities. Within two days, all Israeli universities officially and unanimously declared their refusal to implement the government's decision; this was clearly backed by a majority among both students and lecturers. Uriel Reichman, Dean of the Tel-Aviv University Law School, startled his students when he said: *Today I will talk about something more important than the law of property" and proceeded to denounee the government's racist decision. Many other lecturers did the same in their classes.

On May 18 Science Minister Patt was to be the guest of honour at a degree-awarding ceremony in the Hebrew University of Jerusalem. One by one, three hundred science graduates pointedly ignored the minister and refused to shake his hand.

When student Yan Foreman went on the podium to collect his degree in biochemistry, he suddenly seized the microphone and shouted: "I refuse to take my degree while someone who initiates racist decisions is here!" Thereupon, the gathered graduates burst into shouting *Pratt go home!" The minister had to leave hastily through the back entrance.

Right-wing students, supporters of the Likud and of the extreme right Tehiyan party, made desperate efforts to organise counterdemonstrations in favour of the government decision; these ended in miserable failure. On 19 May student union elections took place in the Jerusalem Hebrew University. The right wing students suffered a crushing defeat and lost nearly half their seats in the student union coun cil. Palestinian demonstration While demonstrations continued daily on the university campuses, two appeals against the government decision were presented to the Supreme Court: one was initiated by an Arab student who is a member of the Progressive List for Peace, represented the other — by the National Union of Students, The Union of Arab Students and several Arab and Jewish students affected by the government's decision. (Aside from Arab students, the government decision discriminated against certain categories of Jewish students, such as cripples, married women and mothers, who are exempted from military service, and would thus have to pay the higher rates).

The controversy had wide repercussions outside the universities. Not only the Arab students, but the entire Arab community felt itself threatened and mobilised in numerous demonstrations. The Committee of Arab Mayors, which includes the mayors of all Arab towns and villages in Israel, took an active part in the struggle.

In the Jewish public, too, emotions run high. Anti-racist groups, civil rights associations and political parties all voiced strong protests. Of crucial importance was the position of the Labor Party, which firmly opposed the government decision. Labor Secretary-General Uzi Bar'am stated: "Morally this may be the most grave decision ever taken by an Israeli cabinet; it makes Israel similar to South Africa and lan Smith's Rhodesia."

Never before did the Israeli Labor Party take such a position. Indeed, in previous cases it not only supported anti-Arab discriminatory measures, but also initiated them; the most notorious example occured in 1976, when the Labor government introduced an amendment by which a large part of the welfare payments in Israel were made conditional upon army service by at least one member of the recipient family. Through this system, which is still in force, Arab families receive welfare benefits much lower than those given to equivalent Jewish families.

The Labor Party's change of front was partially dictated by opportunistic motives; at exactly this time, Labor was engaged in a head-on confrontation with the Likud, its partner in the "National Unity Government" , and the issue of tuition fees provided Labor with additional ammunition.

Labor was also sensitive to the turmoil among its Arab membership. Abed-el-Wahab Darawsha, Labor's Arab Knesset Member, voted against the government in protest. In a deeper sense, however, Labor's new position is a reflection of the deepening polarisation of Israeli society.

Spectrum

On both sides of the political spectrum there is a growing radıcalisation; both racıst and antı-racıst posıtions are being pronounced more and more clearly. These undercurrents also make temselves felt in the big parties.

The Likud leaders were caught by surprise by the rising tide of protests. At first, Prime Minister Shamir replied arrogantly: "The Arab students feel too well in our universities; they are PLO supporters" This statement aroused a new wave of protests, from both Arabs and Jews. However, the sharp defeat of the Likud students in the Jerusalem student elections caused a second thought., Maxim Levy, Mayor of Lydda, who is a Likud member and the brother of Housing Minister David Levy, declared his opposition to the government measure; he stated that, as the mayor of a town with a mixed Jewish-Arab population, he feels an obligation to speak out against discrimination.

By 24 May, the Likud ministers had decided to cut their loses. At the cabinet meeting they agreed to reopen discussion on the issue of tuition fees. Thus, the anti-racist part of the student struggle seems nearly won. However, the socio-economic part still remains; it may yet happen that tuition fees will be fixed at a level equal for Jewish and Arab students, but so high that only the rich in both communities could afford to study. Thus,the Israeli students still face a hard struggle.

On the level of the anti-racist struggle in Israel, it can already be stated that the mobilisation of May 1987 marks a new stage in the history of the anti-racist movement. Previous anti-racist mobilisations such as the ones in Um-el-Fahm and Givatayim*, were directed against the open, extreme racism of Rabbi Meir Kahane. While being very important these mobilisations held the danger that, because of the concentration on Kahane, less open (but more influential) racists will be ignored. Now, tor the first time, wide sections of the Israeli public have come to realise that respectable" ministers, who form a majority in the cabinet, can also behave in a racist manner, and should be opposed as such. *In August 1984 Jews and Arabs, standing together, prevented the racist Kahane from entering the Arab town of Um-el-Fahm ("The Other Israel", No.. 10, p.4). In August and September 1985, thousands of demonstrators repeatedly frustrated Kahane's efforts to hold a rally in Givatayım, a suburb of Tel-Aviv (No. 17, p.4; no. 18, p.4).

Reprinted from The Israel" no. 26, June 1987.

----- pull-quotes -----

PEA NOW

Jewish and Arab students

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 318

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →