Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

On our side

Socialist Organiser no. 317, 13 June 1987 · scan pp. 10–11 · about 1,975 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 10 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 10

Socialist Organiser no.317 13 June 1987 Page 10 Prime Minister Lvov orders the release of General Petrov, arrested earlier in the month by the Sevastopol Soviet for corruption and embezzlement. The Vyatka Soviet declares its support for the coalition gvernment. The Tiflis Soviet of soldiers' deputies supports the Provisional Government and the entry of representatives of the Petrograd Soviet into it.

A workers' mass meeting in Revel, numbering some 2,500, demands immediate publication of secret treaties, supports fraternisation at the front and condemns the coalition government. An 8,000-strong mass meeting of workers and soldiers in Moscow calls for an immediate end to the war and declares its lack of trust in the Provisonal Government. On the South-Western front soldiers of the 172nd infantry division adopt a resolution calling for an immediate end to the war._ In Novocherkassk a Don regional peasant congress calls for all private estates to be transferred into a communal fund, and declares support for the coalition government and a continuation of the war until victoryA mass meeting of 3,000 workers of a Moscow military uniform factory passes a resolution of no confidence in the Provisional Government and calls for the publication of secret treaties. By 24 votes to 11 the Executive Committee of the Ufa Soviet approves the entry of socialists into the Provisional Government, as the representatives of the soviets in the government. A general meeting of miners from the mercury and coal mines in the Gorlovko region condemns the entry of representatives of the Petrograd Soviet into the coalition government and calls for the transference of all power to the Soviets. In Helsingfors a meeting of crews from three cruisers calls for an end to the war, but also declares their readiness to "repel the enemy from wherever he may appear" as long as the war continues.

Tuesday l May In articles entitled *Subscribe to the Freedom Loan" and "What the New Government Wants", the paper of the Petrograd Soviet appeals for the entire population of the country to subscribe to the freedom loan to finance the war effort; only 866,407,870 roubles have been collected to date, while daily costs of the war run at over 40 million roubles.

By 320 votes to 160 a joint meeting of the Moscow Soviets of workers' deputies and soldiers' deputies declares its full support for the coalition Provisional Government. A meeting of the Zlatoust Soviet welcomes the entry of socialists into the Provisional Government. The Baku Soviet declares its complete confidence in the Provisional Government.

The Marienburg Soviet of workers" deputies declares the Provisional Government to be a tool in the hands of the propertied classes, and thereby incapable of ending the imperialist war or solving the economic crisis. The Kronstadt Soviet endorses the decision of 13 May of its Executive Committee to declare the Soviet the sole power in Kronstadt.

Prime Minister Lvov urges them to take action against attacks on private property and the sacking of managers from their positions by their workforces. All printworkers in Perm come out on strike for higher pay and an extension of rights at work, which ends in victory seven days laterThe Melitopol Soviet of workers' and soldiers' deputies declares full support for the coalition Provisional Government. The Samara Soviet elects a commission to organise Red Guards.

On the Northern front, a meeting of -oldiers (539th Borovsky infantry egiment | declares support for soviets and the distribution of socialist papers soldiers. In Riga, a meeting of Deputies (Lettish rifle regiments)

les 201 so 1 in support of fraternisation the mont and power to the Dim the R front, soldiers of the 103rd refuse advance ra the fi CONSTANCE GORE-BOOTH led the well-off life of an 'AngloIrish' ruling class family until she was 40 - introduced as a debutante to Queen Victoria in the late 1880s, art student in Paris, part of the aristocratic hunting fraternity in her home county of Sligo.

She married a Polish count, Casimir Markievicz, and thereafter was known as Countess Markievicz. She was an early advocate of votes for women, but apart irom that there was nothing unusual about Constance Gore-Booth - except, maybe, her sister Eva, who went to live in England and became a suffragist and a socialist, Then something happened to Constance. The Irish working class was stirring and moving. Jim Larkin, a Liverpool Irishman working in the docks as a foreman, was sacked because he sided with the dockers in a dispute with the bosses, and was sent to Ireland by the National Union of Dock Labourers to organise dockers in Belfast.

It was the beginning of a drive to organise the 'unskilled' workers of Ireland. Soon Larkin was at the head of a growing movement of militant workers.

They used the weapon of the sympathetic strike (what is called 'secondary picketing' in Thatcher's Britain) to build up the labour movement. No workers were left to fight alone: every connected trade was brought into even limited trade union battles.

For example, the Dublin dockers struck until the seamen working the port of Dublin were allowed to join the seamen's union. In 1913 the Dublin bosses combined to lock out the workers who were members of Larkin's union. A bitter class war followed. Dublin's workers even organised their own militia, |the Citizen Army.

Decades

At the same time the Irish workers" movement became drawn into the militant nationalist movement. For decades the Irish nationalist cause had been in the hands of a Home Rule party dependent on the Liberal Party in the British Parliament. —But after 1910 the Liberals tried to bring in Home Rule. They met strong resistance from the Irish Protestants, and a small-scale mutiny in the British Army. The Irish nationalists armed themselves and became more militant in response, while the Liberals retreated and moved towards the partition of Ireland.

Constance Gore-Booth was drawn into this maelstrom. She threw herself into the trade union struggle, organising soup kitchens during the 1913 lockout. She took part in the nationalist uprising of Easter 1916, and was sentenced to death for it.

15 men were summarily shot and one, Roger Casement, was hanged in Pentonville Jail after an Old Bailey trial. Constance Gore-Booth had her life sentence commuted to life imprisonment solely because of her sex, benetiting from the uproar about the Germans, nine months earlier, shooting a nurse who had helped escaping British soldiers, Edith Cavell.

In fact she was released after a year, but spent much time in jail thereafter — in 1918, in 1919-20, and then in independent Ireland, in 1923..

She was elected to the House of Commons in December 1918, the first woman MP. As a Sinn Fein MP, however, she took her seat not at Westminster but in the secessionist Dail Eireann, in Dublin, When the Irish nationalist movement split in 1921 over the issue of whether or not to accept Dominion status for the 26 counties of southern Ireland within the British Empire, Constance sided with the Constance Markievicz Republicans who rejected that status.

The Republicans lost the ensuing civil war. When De Valera split Sinn Fein in 1926 and founded Fianna Fail on a policy of participating in the 26 coun ties parliament, Constance followed him.

Aged 59, she died in a hospital for the poor before she could take her parliamentary seat.

Diana Norman's biography of Constance Markievicz is a very supportive, loving, indeed even polemical, exposition of her life. She thinks Constance has been unjustly neglected by historians and misrepresented by those who can't play fair with a women revolutionary because they can't play fair with women.

She exaggerates: surely it is not really true that most politically educated people have not even heard of Constance. But she does make a convincing case that Constance has been slandered and diminished by the standard historians. For example, she cites the widely-accepted canard that Constance shot an unarmed policeman in cold blood at the start of the Easter Rising, and shows that it could not be true.

She effectively shows up the idea that Constance was stupid by quoting extensively from her writings.

Norman says that she finds Constance one of the nicest people imaginable - and she justifies that assessment in her portrait.

Constance wound up as 'Minister for Labour' in the Sinn Fein Provisional Government, and as a founder of Fianna Fail, the party which has represented the Irish bourgeoisie for most of the long period of class struggle in Ireland since 1932.

Still, whatever the political ments that can be made sixty years later, Constance Markievicz was someone who came over to our side — completely. She went to live with the poor of Dublin. She used what money she had to help them. She starved herself. She humped bags of turf (peat) up the stairs for people too ill to do it for themselves. Something like 100,000 Dublin working-class people walked past her coffin!

Accept

In the Dail Eireann debate on whether to accept the Treaty with Britain in December 1921, she objected to the Treaty because it gave guarantees to a ruling class that had always "combined against the workers [and] used every institution in the country to ruin the farmer, and more especially the small farmer, and to send the people of Ireland to drift in the emigrant ships...

My ideal is the Workers' Republic for which Connolly died. And I say that this is one of the things that England wishes to prevent. She would sooner give us Home Rule than a democratic Republic. It is the capitalists' interest in England and Ireland that are pushing this Treaty to block the march of the working people in Ireland and England"

Still, she became a supporter of De Valera. Would she have gone all the way with Fianna Fail after 1927, when it became the main opposition in the Dail, and after 1932, when it became the main government party?

Perhaps, but I don't think so. An honest and sincere woman, she would probably have just died. Diana Norman thinks she did just that, partly because she tound the Irish civil war and its aftermath unliveable.

From the mid-1980s, Norman's book might perhaps be more critical of the Irish nationalist movement in which Constance Markievicz flowered. But on the whole I think the loving and appreciative tone of the book is right. Constance was a great heroine of the labour movement — not just of Irish nationalism - and it's time she got her due.

Reading about Constance's last period, when she lived - by choice - on the edges of the Dublin slums which an official report before World War 1 said were worse than the slums of Calcutta, I recalled a conversation with a supporter of the 'Mandelite' Trotskyist current.

An upper-class indian, very rich, much-publicised, globe-trotting, selfserving and self-regarding in all things, he explained to me that in Sri Lanka the gap between the workers and the petty bourgeois and bourgeois like himself was just too great for the upper-class "Trotskyists' to go and live with the workers and build a mass working-class Trotskyist movement.

Constance Gore-Booth went to the workers. She held nothing back. The tragedy was that her socialism merged into left-wing nationalism and became populism. Her fate was that of a whole generation of Irish But she was a socialist - and she lived and died a socialist in a way that is foreign to most of the British socialist movement today. She deserves to be remembered and honoured and - I think Diana Norman is right — loved as a socialist and feminist pioneer. * Terrible Beauty: a life of Constance Markievicz', by Diana Norman. Hodder and Stoughton, £14.95.

Scan page 11

Industriall

----- pull-quotes -----

1917 YEAR OF REVOLUTION Sunday 14 May

Monday 15 May

Wednesday 17 May In a circular to provincial commissioners,

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 317

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →