Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

The Suffering After Vietnam

Socialist Organiser no. 317, 13 June 1987 · scan p. 9 · about 683 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 9 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 9

Col (Chris Haywood) with Lorraine (Jennifer Cluff) before Agent Dranda kille him Belinda Weaver Orange and other defoliants used in the Vietnam war caused cancers and other physical and mental disorders.

But we didn't always know it. It took the suffering and death of many Vietnam veterans and their struggles to have their illnesses recognised as caused by Agent Orange before anyone sat up and took notice.

'A Street to Die' is a fictionalised account of the death of Colin Simpson (called Turner in the film), a Vietnam veteran contaminated by Agent Orange.

After his return to Australia from Vietnam, Turner (Chris Haywood) and his wife Lorraine (Jennifer Cluff) search for a new home and find a house in an area set aside for returned soldiers. On one side of the street live World War 2 and Korean vets, on the Vietnam vets.

The street looks similar to many in the sprawling western suburbs of Sydney. But it's not long before Col and Lorraine realise that there is something weird about their side of the street.

The little girl next door has strange, violent fits. Their neighbour has rashes on his arms. The woman next door keeps miscarrying.

Col himself has rashes and lumps he can't get rid of, and soon he's feeling tired and unable to do his morning run, and falling asleep on the train home from work.

The Turners' , slow realisation of the truth about Col's deteriorating health and its relation to Agent Orange is well done. Little snippets from the neighbours and from a survey done by a Vietnam veterans' association soon form a coherent picture.

Col learns he will die from lymphona. But he doesn't knuckle under. He tries to get compensation and official recognition that it was Agent Orange that killed him. He tries to set a precedent so that others will also be able to make and win claims.

Col doesn't live to see his victory, but his case did set a precedent - it was the first (and so far only) time any government in the world had admitted liability.

Millions of litres of Agent Orange were dumped on Vietnam during the war. Agent Orange contains 2,4,5-T and 2,4-D. - both deadly poisons.

The poisons were dumped by air over wide areas of Vietnam, and contaminated people as they drifted and got into the water. Agent Orange caused the rashes known as chloracne, cancers, stillbirths, birth defects, respiratory diseases like asthma, and also a wide range of mental disorders.

Its effects may not be immediate. Colin Simpson died 11 years after his exposure.

At first Col is a lively bloke, fond of a drink and a smoke, keen on racing and betting, not politicallyminded or militant but a union rep at work. To see him slowed down by his advancing illness is shocking.

When he learns the truth about his symptoms, he is not eaten up by resentment, but he does want justice. He wants something for the others who are suffering, and for his own family too. The film may sound harrowing, but it's not - Col and Lorraine are such positive characters that the film ends on an upbeat, defiant note, rather than seeming defeatist.

Simpson's case got a lot of publicity in Australia and opened the way for Vietnam veterans to fight back, the way similar cases in the States united the larger Vietnam vets group there.

Once Col figures out the link between his illness and Vietnam, it's as if the blinders have been taken off. All around him are veterans suffering similar or related problems. And Col is horrified to see 2,4,5-T sprayed near children's playgrounds to kill weeds.

But the deadly poisons in Agent Orange - 2,4,5-T and dioxin — are still in use today in many countries. The Italian city of Seveso had to be abandoned when a dioxin accident took place there some years ago.

And no-one knows what the Vietnamese have suffered from Agent Orange - without any hope of redress at all.

----- pull-quotes -----

'A Street Die' WE KNOW now that Agent

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 317

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →