The cause of Poland
Socialist Organiser1987 1987-06-13Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 9 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 9
THE INTERNATIONAL Workingmen's Association, the So-called First International, was set up in 1864, the first — and for a few years, a highly successful -attempt to establish an international working-class party.
Karl Marx eventually became one of its central leaders.
The political issue that first brought together trade unionists from France, Britain and Belgium to launch the International was Polish independence. There had been a Polish insurrection against the Tsar in 1863, and throughout working-class and radical Europe there was great sympathy for the Poles.
Karl Marx believed that the issue of Polish independence was a powder-keg at the foundations of Tsarist Russia - that great 'prisonhouse of nations' — and that it could be used to undermine and destroy Tsarism.
Today, the question of Polish independence is a powder-keg at the foundations of the Russian Stalinist bureaucracy's empire in Eastern Europe.
Paddy Dollard reviews a new television series Seven years ago the Polish workers rose in revolt against Stalinism and established 'Solidarnosc' , a hybrid trade union/political party. One of their demands was for Polish independence. One of the turning points of the development of Solidarnosc was the decision in late August 1980 that it would accept the status quo and try to change it from within rather than overthrowing it by revolution.
Solidarnosc made that decision under pressure of the fact that if they did try to overthrow the regime -and they probably could have done that - then the Kussians would have invaded, as they had invaded Czechoslovakia in 1968 and Hungary in 1956.
*The struggles for Poland', the first part of which went out on 7 June on Channel 4, more or less tells the story of what happened in Poland between the 19th century and Solidarnose.
Poland was a great medieval kingdom - at one time the most populous state in Europe = which failed to become a centralised monarchical state like France, Prussia, Russia, or even England. It could not compete, and was destroyed in a series of partitions at the end of the 18th century and in the early 19th centuryPoland was divided between Austria, Prussia, and Russia, more of it going to the Russian state than to the others. But Poland did not die. A nationalist tradition persisted all through the 19th century.
"The struggles for Poland' picks up the story at the end of the 19th century. In Russia the Poles were suppressed. In the Austrian empire they were treated quite liberally, as were all the nationalities - a Polish university was established in Austria, and the preaching of Polish nationalism was more or less legal.
But what of Polish socialists? The Polish Socialist Party came out for Polish independence. A dissident socialist minority, led by Rosa Luxemburg, came out in the 1890s against Polish independence.
It was retrograde and pointless, said Luxemburg, the great heroine of Polish and German revolutionary socialism who was murdered in 1919. Poland was economically integrated with the Tsarist Empire, and was the most economically advanced part of it. What sense did it make to talk about Polish independence?
Socialists should fight for socialism - and under socialism Poland and Russia would be united, naturally and organically.
Lenin and the Russian Marxists did not disagree with Luxemburg on that. But they did disagree with her by insisting that Russian Marxists should preach the right of independence if the Poles wanted Nationalism The Polish Socialist champion of Polish nationalism was Josef Pilsudski, who eventually became a nationalist first and shed his socialism (though even as head of state of an independent Poland, Pilsudski did resist, albeit teebly Polish chauvinism and such of its expressions as anti-semitism).
As the great powers squared up for World War 1, the Poles in Austria were allowed to organise a Polish Rifle Regiment. After 1914 they were allowed to organise a Polish Legion, with Pilsudski at its head.
When the Germans advanced into the Tsar's empire and captured Warsaw in 1915, pro-German Poles helped set up a 'kingdom of Poland' La phantom puppet kingdom without a king.
The Russian Revolutions of February and then October 1917 created new conditions. The Bolsheviks preached the right of every captive nation in the Russian empire to independence. Pilsudski broke with Austria. An independent Poland came into existence in the welter of war and revolution that engulfed Eastern Europe.
The victorious Allies, meeting Versailles in 1919, recognised an independent Poland, but they did not define the borders. They did specify that minorities in Poland should have national rights, like the more than three million Jews, most of whom were later to be exterminated by the Nazis.
Poland established its borders in bitter ethnic-communal conflict with Germany and in full-scale war with the Bolshevik Revolution. In 1920 Lenin believed that it made sense to respond to a Polish invasion with a war which would help the Polish workers (about a third of them had voted for the left-wing parties) and maybe also the left-wing workers in Germany. He called it 'prodding Europe with the bayonet'.
Trotsky - and even the Polish Jew Karl Radek, who basically shared Luxemburg's views on Polish nationalism - disagreed with Lenin's idea of following the defeated army of Poles who had invaded the workers' state over the borders of Poland.
Lenin's approach was permissible in principle. But, disastrously, it failed to take into account the feelings of a long-oppressed nation. The Poles rallied against the Russians, and at the battle of the Vistula in 1920 the Bolshevik tide flowing from the East was stopped. Poland wound up holding large areas of the Ukraine.
But Polish independence lasted less than 20 years. In 1939 Russia - now ruled by Stalin — and Nazi Germany agreed on a new partition of Poland, and in September jointly invaded.
Trotsky described the areas controlled by Germany and those controlled by the USSR as Hitler's slavery and Stalin's semi-slavery.
Russia
In 1944 the Russians conquered the whole of Poland. They kept much of the territory in the Ukraine they had annexed in 1939, and — as a means of tying the new Polish state to the USSR in perpetuity - gave Poland much of what was East Prussia. Ten million Germans were driven out. A Poland ethnically united - and religiously united as never before, after the destruction of the Jews by Hitler - resulted.
Today, as in Karl Marx's time, the cause of Polish nationalism is not only a just cause in its own right, but also something more — a powderkeg at the foundations of the Russian Stalinist empire.
Many socialists, however, remain aloof because of the preponderance of Catholicism in the workers' movement. That is utterly short-sighted.
There can be no greater force for socialism in Poland than the Polish workers' movement. If Catholicism rides so high, it is partly because it is the alternative to the totalitarian state and its epigone-'Marxist' quasireligion. The way to begin to liberate the Polish workers from Catholicism is to liberate Poland from the dead hand of Russian rule.
'The Struggles for Poland' is an important series. The labour movement needs to know about the history of Poland, which is central to understanding Solidarnosc, the most wonderful and encouraging development in working-class politics, East or West, for many decades.
Socialist Organiser no.317 13 June 1987