Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Times are a'changing for the AIDS virus

Socialist Organiser no. 317, 13 June 1987 · scan p. 8 · about 752 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 8 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 8

Human, immunodeficiency virus (HIV) is evolving rapidly. This means that its genetic material is mutating or changing at a very high rate, perhaps five times that of the 'flu virus. This has several implications for the fight against AIDS.

Firstly, it confirms | the theory that HIV has only recently discovered its new niche in life - infecting humans. There is little pressure on it in its new environment as our immune system cannot threaten it and there is little competition from other viruses. So mutations in the genetic material (RNA) which might normally make a virus less able to survive have no effect.

Secondly, it brings forth the possibility that HIV will evolve so that it can attack other types of cell apart from the white blood cells called T4 lymphocytes. It might then cause other diseases apart from AIDS. Already, it seems HIV can infect brain cells, causing encephalitis and brain damage.

Thirdly, and most depressingly, it makes it less likely that an effective vaccine can be easily developed. 'Flu virus is notoriously difficult to immunise against because, as soon as one vaccine is developed, a new strain of the virus develops which is unaffected. A vaccine usually stimulates the white blood cells to attack the coat proteins of the virus and without its coat the virus cannot infect. A mutation which alters the make-up of the coat protein makes the virus unrecognisable to the white blood cell which will no longer attack it.

Mutants

Fourthly and less depressing, some of the mutants may be less harmful. After all, there is no particular advantage to the virus in killing off its host, the AIDS victim. If the victims no.317 13 June 1987 Page 8 suffered only mild illness, they would survive longer and might therefore infect more people. Such a virus would tend to prosper.

This seems to be what happened with the 'flu virus earlier this century. The great epidemic after World War 1 killed more people than died in the war, yet modern 'flu causes only mild discomfort (except to the old, young, and weak). There is evidence that this may be happening with HIV. At the international conference on AIDS in the USA last week, Robert Gallo announced that two new strains of HIV had been found in Nigerian patients which seem to cause a milder disease.

_ Humans, too, have mutations in their genetic material. As with viruses, these occur at random and usually have either no effect or a harmful effect on the particular individual.

But some individuals may possess a mutation that makes them less susceptible to infection by HIV or more resistant to it. Perhaps a proportion of those currently infected by HIV but without the full AIDS has such a mutation. The gene for resistance would be able to spread through the human population as such people had children while the susceptible people tended to die without offspring.

This would be a slow process as human generation times are around 20 years. In contrast, the HIV's life cycle takes a few months or years. If the spread of resistance was our only hope then we would have a dismal future in prospect as we waited for all the susceptible people to die. The process could in any case only progress significantly if HIV was a lot more infectious and widespread than it is.

Limit

Fortunately, other possibilities exist. Best is to limit the spread of intection with safe sex practices, changes of life style, hygienic use of needles, sterilisation of blood products, etc. Next is the development of drugs that help victims to resist infection. Last is to develop vaccines. This task has not been rendered impossible by the high mutation rate of HIV - merely made more difficult.

As a footnote, the analysis of the different strains of HIV sheds some light on the dispute about who discovered HIV first (and therefore owns the rights to the potentially lucrative AIDS-testing industry). This has been resolved by a compromise between Luc Montagnier's group in Paris and Robert Gallo's group in the USA. Nevertheless, the contention that Gallo's version of the virus was in fact grown from a sample given him by Montagnier is supported by the present research. A family tree of all HIVs analysed puts the Montagnier and Gallo viruses together as adjacent "twigs" on the same branch. Such a close relation would be incredibly unlikely between separate samples of virus found on separate continents.

Information: New Scientist.

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 317

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →